Josh Reynolds

[pawsandclaws1]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

Does the same stand when the abuse of a Father, brother or son is subjected to the situation in the video..?

We know domestic abuse is not only perpetrated by males.

As advised in the attached link, it is not only physical violence.

In this particular case, the allegation is directed towards a male,

 

[voice_of_reason]

Does the same stand when the abuse of a Father, brother or son is subjected to the situation in the video..?

This is the salient point. The gender of the victim tends to generate an automatic response. We have no context of what happened before the video started. For all we know she may have secretly filmed them having sex and threatened to release it publicly which would explain why he so desperately wanted the phone.

The video offers no proof he did anything beyond use some abusive language. I certainly don't condone this - I'm not a fan of swearing of any sort in front of women - but I also don't want to condemn him for something which may or may not have been fabricated.

It just clarifies that none of us know the full context of the story and speculating offers little value. The fact he's been cleared to play would tend to suggest the NRL can see where the case is headed. And let's not forget Toddles is a lawyer.

 

[TillLindemann]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

I couldn't care less if they got slapped.

 

[wokesmoke]

Eye opener this thread for how DV is perceived. Hope none of you who are making excuses don’t have daughters. You’re all pathetic

 

[Geo]

Eye opener this thread for how DV is perceived. Hope none of you who are making excuses don’t have daughters. You’re all pathetic

Maguire seems to support Reynolds...source..his mouth on 9 News..

 

[hobbo1]

Eye opener this thread for how DV is perceived. Hope none of you who are making excuses don’t have daughters. You’re all pathetic

Maguire seems to support Reynolds...source..his mouth on 9 News..

Keep watching ... we’re gonna win the comp ?

 

[Geo]

Eye opener this thread for how DV is perceived. Hope none of you who are making excuses don’t have daughters. You’re all pathetic

Maguire seems to support Reynolds...source..his mouth on 9 News..

Keep watching ... we’re gonna win the comp ?

For sure..undefeated..

 

[Sco77y]

Eye opener this thread for how DV is perceived. Hope none of you who are making excuses don’t have daughters. You’re all pathetic

I don’t think most people are making excuses as such. Just observing all available information to draw an opinion with the ability to keep an open mind about either side of the story. Unlike the classically woke who ignore all evidence and logic to condemn because it’s the woke option.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

 

[TillLindemann]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

If your child was with someone who was mentally abusing them, mentally torturing them with fabrications about dead parents, cancer, miscarriages, extorting money from your child, trashing your child's reputation and character, wrecking their career... your advice to your child would be "it's contingent on you to be disciplined"?

 

[Harvey]

Lots of victim blaming in here since last night. Just to clarify assaulting a woman is justified because her character is bad and she lied about stuff... got it.

Yeh smoke you got it!
We see this a lot. You attack the messenger or victim to water down the story.

Who is the victim here? Is that posting a video on twitter with a backstory suggesting coke benders & comedowns to set up a narrative that sounds a load better than check out how this bloke reacts to finding out out that the woman who will not leave his house has faked 2 pregnancies and miscarriages while he has broken down at the loss of a child and spent thousands setting up nurseries for said non existent children?

 

[Harvey]

Will wait for the court testimony but even with her apparent behavior, I cannot agree that she deserved to be belted, slapped or some of the of the other suggestions on this thread.

However that is not my understanding of the initial allegations, there was some bruising on extremities, not black eyes and broken noses that suggest an extreme violent attack.

 

[cochise]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

If your child was with someone who was mentally abusing them, mentally torturing them with fabrications about dead parents, cancer, miscarriages, extorting money from your child, trashing your child's reputation and character, wrecking their career... your advice to your child would be "it's contingent on you to be disciplined"?

I would hope the advice would be to get as far away from them as possible and not abuse the person as some here are suggesting!

 

[Moh]

Happy this has all come out now, obvious there was more to it but didn't stop some people with wild accusations.

Nice one smokey, yet again proving you're all class.

What are u on about peanut? I said there was a concerning video of JR about to drop before any of you had a clue about it. Regardless of the character of this woman, all that’s been said yesterday has nothing to do with the incident that happened that night he has been charged for. And it sure doesn’t warrant any assault on her that may have occurred that he’s been charged with. And if you think it does, then you really shouldn’t comment on the “class” of someone moh.

Unbelievable :joy:

Mate honestly if I had the time or cared enough I can go back and highlight so much.

You said there was a concerning video of JR - sure, but that was all over twitter before you said anything. To even state 'before any of you had a clue about it' clearly says a lot about you and what you are after here.

But hey, JR *definitely* won't be here aye. Sensationalism at its finest.

 

[TillLindemann]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

If your child was with someone who was mentally abusing them, mentally torturing them with fabrications about dead parents, cancer, miscarriages, extorting money from your child, trashing your child's reputation and character, wrecking their career... your advice to your child would be "it's contingent on you to be disciplined"?

I would hope the advice would be to get as far away from them as possible and not abuse the person as some here are suggesting!

That would be my advice too, but I certainly wouldn't get all preachy if after all that they were caught on camera dropping a c bomb.

 

[Guest]

Please discuss this like rational adults thanks.

 

[cochise]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

If your child was with someone who was mentally abusing them, mentally torturing them with fabrications about dead parents, cancer, miscarriages, extorting money from your child, trashing your child's reputation and character, wrecking their career... your advice to your child would be "it's contingent on you to be disciplined"?

I would hope the advice would be to get as far away from them as possible and not abuse the person as some here are suggesting!

That would be my advice too, but I certainly wouldn't get all preachy if after all that they were caught on camera dropping a c bomb.

Funnily enough I have used that word once in my life, to my dad in an argument when I was 16 in front of all my mates. Dad actually put a short left onto my chin when I said it, last time I have ever used that word. I am a person who against violence, I have never even smacked my daughter, but I will say that taught me a very valuable lesson.

 

[TillLindemann]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

If your child was with someone who was mentally abusing them, mentally torturing them with fabrications about dead parents, cancer, miscarriages, extorting money from your child, trashing your child's reputation and character, wrecking their career... your advice to your child would be "it's contingent on you to be disciplined"?

I would hope the advice would be to get as far away from them as possible and not abuse the person as some here are suggesting!

That would be my advice too, but I certainly wouldn't get all preachy if after all that they were caught on camera dropping a c bomb.

Funnily enough I have used that word once in my life, to my dad in an argument when I was 16 in front of all my mates. Dad actually put a short left onto my chin when I said it, last time I have ever used that word. I am a person who against violence, I have never even smacked my daughter, but I will say that taught me a very valuable lesson.

And I wonder how your dad would have reacted if you'd told your partner he was dead, to extort money from her?

 

[cochise]

It's not only physical violence as you will read at the attached link. I asked myself if I would want my mother, sister or daughter (if I had one) placed in that situation in the video? Truthfully, we all know the answer.

The issue of the credibility of the young lady is a separate issue.

https://www.police.nsw.gov.au/crime/domestic_and_family_violence/what_is_domestic_violence

I'll be honest, if ANYONE I knew, including a mother, sister or daughter, lied about having cancer to extort money, lied about their parent's death to extort money, lied about being pregnant, lied about having a miscarriage, and deliberately set someone up on camera and splashed it on the internet...

**I couldn't care less if they got slapped.**

Sorry I just can't accept that. No matter what the provocation, it is contingent upon us to demonstrate discipline and restraint.

If your child was with someone who was mentally abusing them, mentally torturing them with fabrications about dead parents, cancer, miscarriages, extorting money from your child, trashing your child's reputation and character, wrecking their career... your advice to your child would be "it's contingent on you to be disciplined"?

I would hope the advice would be to get as far away from them as possible and not abuse the person as some here are suggesting!

That would be my advice too, but I certainly wouldn't get all preachy if after all that they were caught on camera dropping a c bomb.

Funnily enough I have used that word once in my life, to my dad in an argument when I was 16 in front of all my mates. Dad actually put a short left onto my chin when I said it, last time I have ever used that word. I am a person who against violence, I have never even smacked my daughter, but I will say that taught me a very valuable lesson.

And I wonder how your dad would have reacted if you'd told your partner he was dead, to extort money from her?

He would have disowned me!

 

[Harvey]

Unfortunately it is a very uneven playing field in domestic relationships for a number of reasons.

Men are less likely to report (or detail to friends) any mental, verbal or physical abuse that they are subjected to as it makes them appear weak or stupid. They are also more likely to be dragged into legal proceedings (AVO's and criminal charges) whenever there is any allegation made.

However there appear to be no repercussions where deliberately false allegations are made in order to provide an upper hand during property or custodial proceedings.