Just not a first grade squad

[1_4_chicken_chips]

Too many reserve graders are making up the numbers …if the story is correct about peyton ,then JT is on his last legs .but if we sign the big 4 we need others to make them a decent side .lovett got knocked backed every time he hit the defence ..Edwards ? .our centres ....

 

[Eddie]

There is no doubt he have a below average roster with too many plodders.

However a lot of people in here were tipping us to make the finals in the pre season.

Maybe it was more hope then expectation.

We have zero depth in the club.

 

[tigerlogic]

Too many reserve graders are making up the numbers …if the story is correct about peyton ,then JT is on his last legs .but if we sign the big 4 we need others to make them a decent side .lovett got knocked backed every time he hit the defence ..Edwards ? .our centres ....

What's the story on Payton?

 

[supercoach]

There is no doubt he have a below average roster with too many plodders.

However a lot of people in here were tipping us to make the finals in the pre season.

Maybe it was more hope then expectation.

We have zero depth in the club.

And the reason we have zero depth is because we have about 8 depth players playing in the top grade.

 

[Guest]

There is no doubt he have a below average roster with too many plodders.

However a lot of people in here were tipping us to make the finals in the pre season.

Maybe it was more hope then expectation.

We have zero depth in the club.

Correct, it's going to be a long season unfortunately.

 

[ricksen]

15 of today's 17 were signed, re-signed or took up an option under the current coach.

 

[Milky]

The coach assembled the squad. The coach played Edwards over Felise. The coach started the only prop that we had on the bench. The coach played a backrower who has not played a game in 5 months. The coach is the reason our side has no direction.

I could go on. Where was our game plan?

 

[hobbo]

The coach assembled the squad. The coach played Edwards over Felise. The coach started the only prop that we had on the bench. The coach played a backrower who has not played a game in 5 months. The coach is the reason our side has no direction.

I could go on. Where was our game plan?

Game plan was left on the bus inside JT's lunch box !

 

[Geo]

Too many reserve graders are making up the numbers …if the story is correct about peyton ,then JT is on his last legs .but if we sign the big 4 we need others to make them a decent side .lovett got knocked backed every time he hit the defence ..Edwards ? .our centres ....

What's the story on Payton?

Buzz wrote in the paper that the Players want Payten installed as the next Coach…

 

[jadtiger]

15 of today's 17 were signed, re-signed or took up an option under the current coach.

Yes but once he gets rid of the other 2 you just watch the turnaround. :roll
\
\
\
we will be hoping for the days we only get flogged by 50

 

[Flippedy]

Too many reserve graders are making up the numbers …if the story is correct about peyton ,then JT is on his last legs .but if we sign the big 4 we need others to make them a decent side .lovett got knocked backed every time he hit the defence ..Edwards ? .our centres ....

What's the story on Payton?

Buzz wrote in the paper that the Players want Payten installed as the next Coach…

Ah the nostalgia! I always thought that Payten would make a good coach. I guess we'll find out soon enough. Though it's probably just idiot Rothfield stirring the pot again.

 

[MacDougall]

So I just spent an hour typing up an NFL style breakdown of our depth chart and the site signed me out before I hit post and instead of saving the post in the browser it was just gone after I signed in. Feels good.

 

[Jam_Wowz]

If I'm not mistaken, Woods, Ted and NoFo were the last 3 Potter signings still remaining, and they're arguably the 3 key pieces going forward. Moses and Brooks had long-standing options from a while back.

To be fair, would Tatola (0) and Felise (8 games) have made much of a dent in the Raiders' pack? If anything, I'd say they'd provide size and incentive to go harder, since they could be dropped at any moment. Chances are, the same 17 will get copy-pasted in again next week with ET and possibly Idris as potentials. A real lack of NRL experience sans Ballin in the reserves, think this brings up that depth thread from a couple weeks before season started.

 

[MacDougall]

Here's the depth chart I did anyway. I won't ramble like I was going to but what you see is that we have a huge unbalance. We have almost zero depth in the backs and a ton of untested forwards.

This would be a problem, if not for the fact that our actual starting forwards completely suck.

Fullback: James Tedesco, Justin Hunt, Jordan Rankin, Watson Heleta

Wing: David Nofoaluma, Moses Suli, Jordan Rankin, Justin Hunt, Ryland Jacobs

Centre: Kevin Naiqama, Michael Chee Kam, Jamal Idris, Watson Heleta, Ryland Jacobs

Halfback/five-eighth: Mitchell Moses, Luke Brooks, Jack Littlejohn, Justin Hunt, Jordan Rankin

Front Row: Aaron Woods, Tim Grant, Ava Seumanufagai, Sauaso Sue, Joel Edwards, JJ Felise/Junior Tatola/Wes Lolo/Jordan Grant

Hooker: Matt McIlwrick, Matt Ballin, Jacob Liddle

Second Row: Chris Lawrence, Sauaso Sue, Josh Aloiai, Joel Edwards, Kyle Lovett, Michael Chee Kam, Jamal Idris, Matt Eisenhuth/Taniela Paseka/Esan Marsters/Bayley Sironen

Lock: Elijah Taylor, Joel Edwards, Tim Grant, Sauaso Sue

It's time to just give some of these dudes a crack. There is no way known that any of those backrowers are going to be doing worse than Lawrence, Edwards, Lovett et al. Those guys starting ahead of exciting talent like Paseka or Felise does my damn head in.

 

[TCL]

Something is up with the team.

They are not playing fluently, sure it's only round 3 but there are problems across the park.

Last year our defence was ordinary but this year our attack has lost its zing as well.

Even Teddy threw a panicked forward pass. His attack is reduced to jinking and weaving.still the only stand out.

We missed ET's work rate and link with the halves, we also miss not having a geniune dummy half for the 80 mins. Maybe Ballin can add some calm and direction to the team 😕

Im don't know if contracts are the problem, the coaching strategies or maybe even the relationship between players and coach but I can state with certainty that there are few nervous players, player managers, coaches and exec's at the Tigers's tonight!

 

[ricksen]

15 of today's 17 were signed, re-signed or took up an option under the current coach.

Yes but once he gets rid of the other 2 you just watch the turnaround. :roll
\
\
\
we will be hoping for the days we only get flogged by 50

Sorry it's actually 14, my mistake, but the general point remains.

 

[vlad]

Too many reserve graders are making up the numbers …if the story is correct about peyton ,then JT is on his last legs .but if we sign the big 4 we need others to make them a decent side .lovett got knocked backed every time he hit the defence ..Edwards ? .our centres ....

What's the story on Payton?

Buzz wrote in the paper that the Players want Payten installed as the next Coach…

The same Buzz who wrote this

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/wests-tigers-have-a-readymade-replacement-for-coach-jason-taylor–his-assistant-brett-kimmorley/news-story/000eb7ca6cb18ff5bc1604739f5b8cbe

NOD OF APPROVAL

The Wests Tigers have a ready-made replacement for Jason Taylor. Brett Kimmorley has done his apprenticeship as an assistant coach and is highly rated around the clubs.

His name has been mentioned inside the Wests Tigers boardroom as an option.

-----------

keep throwing darts , Buzz , you'll hit the target eventually !

 

[Eddie]

Kimmorely would be Payten level bad.

 

[Nelson]

Here's the depth chart I did anyway. I won't ramble like I was going to but what you see is that we have a huge unbalance. We have almost zero depth in the backs and a ton of untested forwards.

This would be a problem, if not for the fact that our actual starting forwards completely suck.

Fullback: James Tedesco, Justin Hunt, Jordan Rankin, Watson Heleta

Wing: David Nofoaluma, Moses Suli, Jordan Rankin, Justin Hunt, Ryland Jacobs

Centre: Kevin Naiqama, Michael Chee Kam, Jamal Idris, Watson Heleta, Ryland Jacobs

Halfback/five-eighth: Mitchell Moses, Luke Brooks, Jack Littlejohn, Justin Hunt, Jordan Rankin

Front Row: Aaron Woods, Tim Grant, Ava Seumanufagai, Sauaso Sue, Joel Edwards, JJ Felise/Junior Tatola/Wes Lolo/Jordan Grant

Hooker: Matt McIlwrick, Matt Ballin, Jacob Liddle

Second Row: Chris Lawrence, Sauaso Sue, Josh Aloiai, Joel Edwards, Kyle Lovett, Michael Chee Kam, Jamal Idris, Matt Eisenhuth/Taniela Paseka/Esan Marsters/Bayley Sironen

Lock: Elijah Taylor, Joel Edwards, Tim Grant, Sauaso Sue

It's time to just give some of these dudes a crack. There is no way known that any of those backrowers are going to be doing worse than Lawrence, Edwards, Lovett et al. Those guys starting ahead of exciting talent like Paseka or Felise does my damn head in.

Just for the sake of having some new faces to watch it would be good to see something like:

1\. Teddy
2\. Nofo
3\. Marsters
4\. MCK
5\. Suli
6\. Moses
7\. Brooks
8\. Woods
9\. McIlwrick
10\. Ava
11\. Aloiai
12\. Felise
13\. ET

14\. Grant
15\. Tatola
16\. Sue
17\. Ballin

 

[Geo]

I take it you guys haven't been to too many ISP games this year…