OFFICIAL Kelma Tuilagi

[dazza65]

50/50 at best after multiple views- not clear either way imo so advantage to attacker and called a try so should have been given

 

[TieDye]

50/50 at best after multiple views- not clear either way imo so advantage to attacker and called a try so should have been given

Mate… it has to be conclusive to overturn a decision. Ref didn’t even seem to instruct them on the second inspection - has to be a TRY !

 

[Geo]

How many times do you hear given the inconclusive evidence we support the on-field decision..

Not the Klown Klien tho..blag bla blaaaaaah

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Like I said if that was Easts they would have looked at every angle seventeen times to be sure he got a finger to it.

 

[Merlot]

Like I said if that was Easts they would have looked at every angle seventeen times to be sure he got a finger to it.

and more than likely give it 2 them any way without conclusive evidence.when things change the comp will even out

 

[TieDye]

and more than likely give it 2 them any way without conclusive evidence.when things change the comp will even out

I’m not paying/watching until such time

 

[Merlot]

I’m not paying/watching until such time

lets hope hell doesnt need 2 freeze over and we can all enjoy a fair contest soon

 

[Tiger Woods]

Is he back ?
Was hoping he’d get taken by a croc 🐊

He’s back with one less arm
🖐 🐊 😂

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

and more than likely give it 2 them any way without conclusive evidence.when things change the comp will even out

Whenever that will be...

 

[BAGNF05]

I’m not sure what you guys are saying
No downward pressure?
He bounced it.
For him to bounce it, the ball would have to hit the turf. Otherwise he has dropped it.
When has downward pressure ever been a thing?
It only has to graze a blade of grass for it to be a try.
I’m outraged this has just been blown off so lightly.
Every other team would get 1000 looks to see if he had dropped it or maintained control.
I listened live but just watched the bunker replay. They pretty much claim he dropped it on the first view and then spend the next 4mins trying to determine how much of an impact Lomaxs contact is.
Fair dinkim get your priority’s right.
Get your pitchforks ready and start the March to HQ for Ansley’s performance review.

Should of just took the tap and set up for one of our superstar backs to score a try… oh wait 🤪

 

[69-05-41]

Like I said if that was Easts they would have looked at every angle seventeen times to be sure he got a finger to it.

If it was Souffs it would have been an 8-point try and Lomax would have been sent off

 

[Speed2burn]

If that was a no try then the Burgass golden point try against us last year should have been a no try aswell

Still pissed with how quickly they dismissed it...especially after the warriors debacle earlier in the year

 

[Needaname]

If that was a no try then the Burgass golden point try against us last year should have been a no try aswell

Still pissed with how quickly they dismissed it...especially after the warriors debacle earlier in the year

Same hopeless ref as well.

 

[stryker 69]

I hope the club is giving Annesley a tough time.
Legitimately getting screwed out of wins.

 

[Sco77y]

I hope the club is giving Annesley a tough time.
Legitimately getting screwed out of wins.

And it’s the only way they’ll stop the bias and general incompetence against us

 

[earl]

I'm not a conspiracy theorist so I put it down to human bias and gross incompetence.

I agree. The problem is though it's happened to us a couple of times this season.

 

[earl]

Still pissed with how quickly they dismissed it...especially after the warriors debacle earlier in the year

I said this is another thread and one poster said that my understanding was incorrect. It was stated that bunker looks at different views or something.

Personally I can see his hand on the ball and the ball on the ground. That is a try.

I can't believe it wasn't mentioned. Luc's try was a try as well. In both situations it appears they just don't even check.

 

[rex2ce]

I am as one eyed as anyone on here, but I thought he dropped the ball

 

[Sco77y]

I am as one eyed as anyone on here, but I thought he dropped the ball

I honestly don’t think you could tell with the available angles (to us viewers anyway). Unless the bunker saw some sort of alternate angle which confirmed it. Because it went up to them as a try.. So would need to be proven otherwise. It was seemingly dismissed too quickly, and I can’t say they made the right decision because of all the camera angles we saw, none actually confirmed that he didn’t ground it

 

[Stevec]

I honestly don’t think you could tell with the available angles (to us viewers anyway). Unless the bunker saw some sort of alternate angle which confirmed it. Because it went up to them as a try.. So would need to be proven otherwise. It was seemingly dismissed too quickly, and I can’t say they made the right decision because of all the camera angles we saw, none actually confirmed that he didn’t ground it

That's the point I don't remember close try situation (sent up as try) with so few camera angles and few replays and no very slow motion .So I can't tell
Why?