Lee & JP finally lose the confidence of the Board??

cochise said:
I'm advocating to do a review and determine what problems exist in our club that prevent us from setting and maintaining a consistent direction and what is causing the continual operational errors.

Nothing more, nothing less.
Click to expand...
Thats fine that's your prerogative even though I don't agree with it for the disruption it's causing.....not to mention this is a privately owned company.

But you decided to launch a petition and accept the results even though you invited sections of the media to promote it.

Having gained what you wanted in a review being launched are you still in touch with the media?

And if so why?
 
Last edited:
Tucker said:
You’re happy to keep losing eh?…just as long as Wests are involved.
Click to expand...
Who said we will keep losing?

What of the negative press this is generating and it's role in possibility costing us recruits?

You got a crystal ball?

And why shouldn't Wests be involved?

And thanks for clarification re your position.
 
Anyone defending Lee or JP and against the review having some effect are insane.

Those two are toxic for the club.

We’re going into next year with a rookie coach … well not even rookie bc most rookie coaches have been an assistant coach for more than a year… and we have an untested, rookie, halves pairing… and we’re coming off two wooden spoons… and we haven’t made the finals - yet gone backwards on the football field since both of them have been involved in the club.

End of story.

People who think we are in good shape next year are living in hope! Like they did when Sheens was appointed last year so we could play expansive 2005 football and Brooks was going to finally stand up and run the team. Lol.
 
What would people think if we did this review and Lee Pascoe and the board survived?
Its a possibility it us remember, me personally outside looking in i'd like Lee moved aside and if Pascoe must stay move him from CEO to some corporate guy lookerafterer absolutely nothing to do with the footy Dept.
 
Magpie_Magic said:
We chose jack.

After Wests were axed at the end of 83 and 84 only to be reinstated due to court action which Wayde personally set in motion the NSWRL were at it again in 86....deciding that there would only be 12 teams and Wests would go.....after they lost the High court appeal in 85 4-2, they had no recourse to legal action.

At this point Peter Moore one of the delegates on the 9 man NSWRL board asked Rick to help him set up Johnies disco at Canterbury leagues and that he would back Wests retention in the competition if we left most of our juniors to Canterbury and shifted to Campbelltown. The deal was also that Canterbury would abandon Liverpool to Wests.

So we choose nothing .
Click to expand...
Yeah right. Cheers for the info
 
BAGNF05 said:
Tucker said:
Tucker said:
You’re happy to keep losing eh?…just as long as Wests are involved.
Click to expand...

The negative fans are being proactive in forcing change.
The positive fans are those sitting on the hill with their little propellor caps on, waving their flags and cheering as the side loses again and again.
Click to expand...

It shouldn’t have gone to this point. People might be threatening to walk away completely now but that doesn’t capture the many thousands who have part walked away over the last ten years and contribute a small fraction of what they would have if the club was showing any semblance of competence. It’s a crying shame it’s gone on unchecked so long.
Click to expand...
I understand that, but am of the opjnion it was the splinted coaches such as Jason Taylor and Ivan Clearly that were largely responsible for our downfall with dumb recruitment and retention decisions and a genuine lack of care from the club.
I don’t think Madge was that great a coach despite winning a comp with the red hot South’s team he was involved with, but you could easily tell he was at least genuine and done his best.
The biggest crime crime Lee and Pascoe have committed was putting too much faith and trust in these coaches they appointed to make things better, I’m not sure
 
tony soprano said:
Thanks mate

Just a bit of confusion

So would it be correct in saying

Wests ashfield fund

Wests, Harold matts, SG ball, NSW cup

Balmain, Harold matts, SG ball

WT flegg

Women's team

WT First grade


And Campbelltown Leagues fund all the other lower grades in the Macarthur region??


Is the operations to funnel the teams from Macarthur into the pathways wests ashfield doing to from HM to NRL??
Click to expand...
Pretty sure that's it.
 
Vicious said:
I understand that, but am of the opjnion it was the splinted coaches such as Jason Taylor and Ivan Clearly that were largely responsible for our downfall with dumb recruitment and retention decisions and a genuine lack of care from the club.
I don’t think Madge was that great a coach despite winning a comp with the red hot South’s team he was involved with, but you could easily tell he was at least genuine and done his best.
The biggest crime crime Lee and Pascoe have committed was putting too much faith and trust in these coaches they appointed to make things better, I’m not sure
Click to expand...


Pascoe’s biggest mistake was he trusted too much? Wow lol.

I’m convinced you’re trolling now.
 
Magpie_Magic said:
Who said we will keep losing?
Click to expand...
Very naive statement given our player and coaching roster as well as historic results with this group.
Magpie_Magic said:
What of the negative press this is generating and it's role in possibility costing us recruits?
Click to expand...
As opposed to the mountain of negative press our performances over the past 2 years have generated? It’s a fart in the wind.
Magpie_Magic said:
You got a crystal ball?
Click to expand...
Grow up.
Magpie_Magic said:
And why shouldn't Wests be involved?
Click to expand...
They are the constant in our run of awful results
Magpie_Magic said:
And thanks for clarification re your position.
Click to expand...
I never hide my position.
 
Tucker said:
Very naive statement given our player and coaching roster as well as historic results with this group.

As opposed to the mountain of negative press our performances over the past 2 years have generated? It’s a fart in the wind.

Grow up.

They are the constant in our run of awful results

I never hide my position.
Click to expand...
What a poor reply lol
 
I’m confused at what many on here that claim they are sick of losing believe will turn the on field results around and become successful ASAP ?
Is it sacking Lee ?
Sacking the entire current board ?
Sacking Pascoe ?
Sack Lee, the entire board and Pascoe ?
Sacking Benji ?
Sacking Farah ?
Sacking Fulton ?
Sacking all of Benji, Farah and Fulton ?
Sign one or two marquee players ?
Sacking some of our top 30 ?
Sacking all of our top 30 ?
Not worrying about keeping our rising talent, just worry about our top 30 only ?
Sack everyone?
What is it that people want or expect will make the on field results much better ASAP ?
 
Magpie_Magic said:
Who said we will keep losing?

What of the negative press this is generating and it's role in possibility costing us recruits?

You got a crystal ball?

And why shouldn't Wests be involved?

And thanks for clarification re your position.
Click to expand...

The club has been a media whipping boy for years, well before the any review. it’s an easy target with a dysfunctional board, rotating coaches, decade of on field failure, poor signings, no home ground do I need to go on?


At least vicious is just dumb, you are much more sinister in your motives. You’d rather wests tigers continue to fail just so you can have your bin bird logo on both sleeves. It’s pathetic.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 403 (members: 2, guests: 401)
Back
Top