Let's be honest

Y

Year_of_the_Tiger

Well-known member
I am not too fazed by that game but there are some dead set bustards amongst our gems:

- Rowe - no where near FG
- Anasta - he is worse than campese, a total waste of space. It was actually fair for 10 mins when Myles went off
- (harsher) Galloway - he is our worst most non impactful forward. So slow!
- (harshest) - Fulton - plays his guts out but just no impact … At all
- Luani is fine but no first grader

Raps on Lawry for his best game since I can remember. And Bodene has surprised me, took no shite from any tits today. I really like Austen, but he and brooks are still rocks and diamonds. They will come good. I thought our forwards minus Galloway were generally really good. Scrappy game. Injuries killing our great start!

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Even though I don't want to agree with you, I have to, Gavet to Start for Galloway and Sironen for Fulton when fit.
 
Luani was amazing in defense.

Also how the hell can you compare Anasta and campese? He is probably the form 5/8 of the comp behind Reynolds and the other obvious choices.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
@tig_prmz said:
Luani was amazing in defense.

Also how the hell can you compare Anasta and campese? He is probably the form 5/8 of the comp behind Reynolds and the other obvious choices.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
Click to expand...

Are you kidding re campese?!

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Galloway is not chosen for his length of the field try scoring or saving ability, and is as slow as a wet week. He is also a very solid metre gainer and whilst he stops most pretty well dead in defense, he is also the only player in our side that does not lose a player that he gets his hands on.
 
Of the five you have listed. Rowe and Luani and just filling in, yes they are under performing but there isn't much else out there.

Fulton had one of his worst games in a while but it was strange him coming off the bench. He either has to play the 80 or not at all. Only one of him and p Thompson really fit in the team.

Galloway he goes alright. He major impact but not horrible. I prefer the impact of Taupau and Gavet coming off the beach and can't see who else would start ahead of Galloway.

Anasta - well even he must realise that his days are numbered.

Young sirro will come straight back into the side - for who will depend on who is injured at the time.
 
Kapow to start Galloway to the bench
Fulton should go on the Bench when all our second rowers are fit but it won't happen
Anasta should retire or head to Reserve grade but it won't happen Austin in with Moses getting a sniff and run around origin time.
Teddy will be back so that should sort out Rowe
Robby back soon

Anasta is being found out as to how ineffective he is due to Robby and Teddy being injured , was hoping he would stand up but like the roosters said when they let him go his running on old legs , one season to long for Bwaif.
 
I agree with year of the tiger. At the end when it looked like anasta may be limping I jumped for joy. He has to go.
 
We had an off day today, which will happen. Still doesn't take away the fact it is disappointing to see when it does happen, but we'll have a few troops back on deck soon. First and foremost, we're missing Farah and Tedesco the most. Gavet follows behind them, along with Sirro and Sue IMO. Expect Farah and Sue back for the Sharks match, Gavet may be an outside chance. Sirro and Halatau are due back 2 weeks after the Sharks. Moltzen is about 6 weeks away now, but given how long it took him to recover from his first knee reco, including his confidence, he'll be in State Cup for awhile.
 
I love the redhead. But who of these mean islanders is not in front of him? I like the post re his defence. He is great there, for a big slow guy. But he is so slow … and the biggest thing for me is that no team gives him real respect.

Luani is fine. And yes defended well. But offers what? He will not be in FG in 5 years. Hope for him I'm wrong

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
@formerguest said:
Galloway is not chosen for his length of the field try scoring or saving ability, and is as slow as a wet week. He is also a very solid metre gainer and whilst he stops most pretty well dead in defense, he is also the only player in our side that does not lose a player that he gets his hands on.
Click to expand...

Didn't he grab…and let go of kelly( think it was kelly?) that lead to titans first try?

When he actually gets on the field he seems to do everything at snail pace. He has no speed Into the line, very few offloads. The slow pace he plays the ball seems to kill any momentum the team may have. He was fine when we didn't have anyone better but now we do.

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
Galloway has been great so far this year, as has Fulton. We had an off day and the Titans played well. Put Farah and Tedesco back in that side and we win today - simples!
 
The rorters will be licking their lips after Rowe's performance. Simona will be out. I am very concerned for the next game. Nofo to FB? Lulia at centre but I am not keen there. Koro on the wing. I fear we will be lapped like the raiders today

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_
 
@Oxygen said:
Anasta is being found out as to how ineffective he is due to Robby and Teddy being injured ,
Click to expand...

Thats an excellent point!
 
@Flippedy said:
Galloway has been great so far this year, as has Fulton. We had an off day and the Titans played well. Put Farah and Tedesco back in that side and we win today - simples!
Click to expand...

Fulton isnt good at all hes like hindmarsh out of his prime
 
Against Roosters Moses must come in as fullback, Austen start and continue as 5/8\. Taupau start as prop. Patterson to replace Fulton. Lulia is also likely to get a start.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 532 (members: 19, guests: 513)
Back
Top