Live Game Thread *Spoilers*

[AdelaideTiger]

Just saw the clip of Mitchell run down the side line I’m sorry what was talau doing in defence he has to go out of first grade he done silly things like this on D so many times leading to tries I don’t get the clubs obsession with him

It’s laughable

He’s living off the name ...
Looks weedy and frail ...
Gets caught out heaps ..
Drop him .

The clubs a joke cini should be in - wonder what cini contract situation is

Cini might get his chance in the centre’s since AJ went down

Better judges than me reckon his defense is shocking though so who knows

Based on Madges previous selections I would assume that BJ will be back in for AJ. He won't see much need for change otherwise.

 

[TigerVinnie]

Just saw the clip of Mitchell run down the side line I’m sorry what was talau doing in defence he has to go out of first grade he done silly things like this on D so many times leading to tries I don’t get the clubs obsession with him

It’s laughable

He’s living off the name ...
Looks weedy and frail ...
Gets caught out heaps ..
Drop him .

The clubs a joke cini should be in - wonder what cini contract situation is

Cini might get his chance in the centre’s since AJ went down

Better judges than me reckon his defense is shocking though so who knows

Based on Madges previous selections I would assume that BJ will be back in for AJ. He won't see much need for change otherwise.

Id like to see Mybe at centre and Liddle 14. However, in the presser Madge mentioned he liked what he saw from Mybe in the middle - so I would assume he wants to keep him in that 14.

 

[Guest]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

 

[tony soprano]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

That’s on the coach not utilising everyone

 

[Guest]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

That’s on the coach not utilising everyone

He did utilise everyone - you're missing the point.

 

[tony soprano]

Just saw the clip of Mitchell run down the side line I’m sorry what was talau doing in defence he has to go out of first grade he done silly things like this on D so many times leading to tries I don’t get the clubs obsession with him

It’s laughable

He’s living off the name ...
Looks weedy and frail ...
Gets caught out heaps ..
Drop him .

The clubs a joke cini should be in - wonder what cini contract situation is

Cini might get his chance in the centre’s since AJ went down

Better judges than me reckon his defense is shocking though so who knows

Centre what be a risk but would put him on the wing

 

[tony soprano]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

That’s on the coach not utilising everyone

He did utilise everyone - you're missing the point.

How is coach utilising the 17 with stats like that. I get lower stats lower time but why are they getting less time

 

[Guest]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

That’s on the coach not utilising everyone

He did utilise everyone - you're missing the point.

How is coach utilising the 17 with stats like that. I get lower stats lower time but why are they getting less time

Balancing the workload among the props - because the game has sped up it's not in the team's best interests to keep two props plugging away just to try and get over 100m in attack - they're not going to have enough juice to defend properly.

 

[hobbo1]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

That’s on the coach not utilising everyone

He did utilise everyone - you're missing the point.

How is coach utilising the 17 with stats like that. I get lower stats lower time but why are they getting less time

Cause they are plodders

 

[tony soprano]

How long will this team parade under 100 meters

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2021/round-6/rabbitohs-v-wests-tigers/


- mikale - 58meters
- mbye 11
- garner - 47
- tamou - 92

Stefano can’t crack 100 on 82


I’m sorry but this first grade side is broken and it’s up to Madge and heartigan to fix it but they do the same over and over.


If the club any stomach for hard calls

Liddle
Amone
Cini
Chee kam

Would be in first grade.

You need to take a look at minutes played - there's more to it than just running over 100 metres.

Tamou played 48 minutes
Stefano played 41 minutes
Twal played 56 minutes
Mikaele played 19 minutes
Musgrove played 25 minutes
Joe O played 58 minutes
Mbye played predominantly as a second receiver and then moved to the centres, and our centres are typically starved of the ball.

That’s on the coach not utilising everyone

He did utilise everyone - you're missing the point.

How is coach utilising the 17 with stats like that. I get lower stats lower time but why are they getting less time

Cause they are plodders

Exactly

 

[851]

The Cowboys could only manage 6 points in the first half against Canterbury, puts in to perspective how bad we were last week

 

[AdelaideTiger]

Just saw the clip of Mitchell run down the side line I’m sorry what was talau doing in defence he has to go out of first grade he done silly things like this on D so many times leading to tries I don’t get the clubs obsession with him

It’s laughable

He’s living off the name ...
Looks weedy and frail ...
Gets caught out heaps ..
Drop him .

The clubs a joke cini should be in - wonder what cini contract situation is

Cini might get his chance in the centre’s since AJ went down

Better judges than me reckon his defense is shocking though so who knows

Based on Madges previous selections I would assume that BJ will be back in for AJ. He won't see much need for change otherwise.


Id like to see Mybe at centre and Liddle 14. However, in the presser Madge mentioned he liked what he saw from Mybe in the middle - so I would assume he wants to keep him in that 14.

Madge really seems to favour a Utility player. I actually think the bench make up has been improving of late, still think Mikaele could make way for either a Simpkins or Amone.

 

[sleeve]

Just saw the clip of Mitchell run down the side line I’m sorry what was talau doing in defence he has to go out of first grade he done silly things like this on D so many times leading to tries I don’t get the clubs obsession with him

It’s laughable

He’s living off the name ...
Looks weedy and frail ...
Gets caught out heaps ..
Drop him .

The clubs a joke cini should be in - wonder what cini contract situation is

Cini might get his chance in the centre’s since AJ went down

Better judges than me reckon his defense is shocking though so who knows

Based on Madges previous selections I would assume that BJ will be back in for AJ. He won't see much need for change otherwise.


Id like to see Mybe at centre and Liddle 14. However, in the presser Madge mentioned he liked what he saw from Mybe in the middle - so I would assume he wants to keep him in that 14.

Madge really seems to favour a Utility player. I actually think the bench make up has been improving of late, still think Mikaele could make way for either a Simpkins or Amone.

Ogden and Cooper in cc look good and may be the answer to our backline problems next year.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

Funny how Brooks does nothing again and all his fanboys are blaming Doueihi for the loss. Talk about deflecting.

Dude if you can’t see how poor AD is in defence , then you have no idea about football .

Many of us have been saying it for a while , and Joel Caine pointed out how teams attack it in his Sportsbet analysis.

Tonight proved , that if you just roll through your sets and plant a bomb on the 5m , you are going to be in most games .

You can’t carry a passenger in defence . AD should play origin one day , but he won’t if he doesn’t fix his front on defence .

I didn't say he didn't miss the odd tackle ... you and the other members of Brooksy's fan club are just looking for a scapegoat because Brooks did nothing again.
How do you think he went in comparison to his opposite number tonight?
BTW it's getting a bit tiring for you to keep saying that anyone who doesn't agree with you has no idea about football.
Maybe you should try looking in the mirror.

Why should I look in the mirror , I didn’t play . ? We didn’t lose because of a lack of attack . We lost because of 3 defensive reads . Simpkin was responsible for 2 , which is fine as he’s 19, AD the other , which has been a big reason for our losses this year .
It’s not Blame , it’s a fact , we need to fix that part of the field .

What we need is a decent halfback to help get us a few more points and not go missing.
You still think Brooks played well tonight...I notice you didn't answer how he went in comparison to Reynolds.

I thought Reynolds did nothing for 82 of 83 minutes . But because of his kick , and it was only 1 , guys like you will harp on and on . I thought LM and walker won that game for Souths . And Reynolds did exactly what he was supposed to , just bomb to the corners and kick and chase .
He’s just a way better kicker than Brooks .

I find it hillarious that you come out and blame brooks , and many of us point out , that no , in actuality it was defence that lost us the game , namely AD and JTJ , and you say stop using AD as a scapegoat . You’re off your head . And I already said why I think it was the defence , and how professional football commentators have pointed out what I did , on national tv , but you just want to blame brooks . One of us has no idea , and it’s not me .

Anybody tell you self praise is no recommendation?
BTW I never blamed Brooks...just said he offered nothing.
You’re the bloke blaming people and blessing us with your unmatched understanding of rugby league.?

Not unmatched . Usurped by many . Just not by you.

There you go again... delusional.

? How so ? that you know nothing ? Doubt it . Or that plenty of people know way more than me about this game ? Well I know that’s true .

You’ve got it twisted bro . I rate AD . I also rate brooks . And I know 1 fact that has existed since the dawn of any sport . The team that defends better will always be the one that wins , as you only have to win by 1 point.

And AD needs to sort his out . For the tigers sake and his own career . As he will never reach his true potential . Because he is a liability close to the line . He fixes that , and now we have a top 8 team for sure IMO , with brooks .

Brooks needed to step up when we had 4 odd sets in a row ..
Apart from going missing then he wasn’t too bad ( except for some garbage passes)

Yea agree . But for some reason we are the only team who can’t score in the first 10 minutes , if that’s on Brooks , it could be , and probably is.

I think AD had the right game plan , kick in behind and see what happens . That’s how most teams get broken down first thing into a game when everyone is fresh .