In my opinion there are certain players that need to leave a club once or twice to get more different coaching looks in order to reach their potential. I like taking on a player who is like early to mid twenties, has looked good without being great, around 50-100 games. I also think that players like that that we have that didn't set the world on fire from day 1 are unlikely to reach their potential with us. This also doesn't seem to apply so much to halves and fullbacks.
The likes of Aloiai, Sue, Nofoaluma (and Liddle is also projecting this way) fit into the category of those I feel would be better off elsewhere to get different coaching looks.
The likes of Lawrence, Brooks, Marsters fit into the category of those that don't need that to succeed. They were first grade ready when they came into first grade.
The likes of Fonua, Chee Kam and Thompson sort of fit that mold but not perfectly. They have improved by virtue of this being their 3rd or 4th first grade coaching look. They don't fit the profile ideally.
We actually have very few of those types of players.
I would like us to sign some 23-26 year old players who have played 50-100 first grade games in the outside backs/forwards that aren't star players looking to cash out (the Jack Bird type signings) Corey Oates would fit into the latter category as would have Valetine Holmes (and sadly Josh Reynolds).
Manly have a ton of these guys. Shaun Lane, Api Kor, Curtis Sironen, Jack Gosiewski and Brian Kelly all fit the profile ideally.
Warriors have one, Ken Maumalo.
Cowboys Javid Bowen.
Parramatta's George Jennings and Peni Terepo (an ideal candidate as he has also looked to have had his best year yet).
Souths Hymel Hunt and Robert Jennings.
If we could sign Hymel Hunt, Ken Maumalo, Peni Terepo and Shaun Lane for instance, I think they would be really good investment buys.