Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

Jedi_Tiger said:
still halfback of the year in 2018 I know it ruins your narrative demps but it's fact he won the award .
More importantly who wins tonight SBW or Hall ? I think SBW
Click to expand...
My narrative is always the #truth
😉

I'm always team sonny....
Barry broke his ribs on SAS and that wasn't that long ago... we breaking these ribs again tonight.
Inshallah.
 
Demps said:
Outplayed Cronk all year aye...
Click to expand...
Most of it - Cronk came good when it mattered…

That’s what champions do.

I thought he was a chance most of the year - he Bradbury’d it… the other guys had an off year all at the same time.
but he can only play what’s in front of him - and for most of the year… there wasn’t anyone
 
GNR4LIFE said:
They don‘t stand up for each other when an opposition player gets stuck in to one of them. Outside of Stefano, what’s so great about the pack and why do they constantly avoid any criticism?
Click to expand...
Plodders. I like Twal but between him and Mikaele they haven’t scored a try in about 10 seasons. It’s not much of a platform and puts too much pressure on the spine.
 
BAGNF05 said:
Plodders. I like Twal but between him and Mikaele they haven’t scored a try in about 10 seasons. It’s not much of a platform and puts too much pressure on the spine.
Click to expand...
Hopefully some upgrades coming though.

Pele > Mikaele
iPapz & Nikora > Luc, Kelma, Garner

Need a prop to replace Tamou & Offa


If we get those deals and a few more done we're moving in the right direction away from these duds.

Twal is a worker and we got him locked, good club man so he stays.
 
Demps said:
Hopefully some upgrades coming though.

Pele > Mikaele
iPapz & Nikora > Luc, Kelma, Garner

Need a prop to replace Tamou & Offa


If we get those deals and a few more done we're moving in the right direction away from these duds.

Twal is a worker and we got him locked, good club man so he stays.
Click to expand...
Any announcements on those Sharkies?
 
Demps said:
Hopefully some upgrades coming though.

Pele > Mikaele
iPapz & Nikora > Luc, Kelma, Garner

Need a prop to replace Tamou & Offa


If we get those deals and a few more done we're moving in the right direction away from these duds.

Twal is a worker and we got him locked, good club man so he stays.
Click to expand...
lets bring Haas back,
 
batboy said:
Most of it - Cronk came good when it mattered…

That’s what champions do.

I thought he was a chance most of the year - he Bradbury’d it… the other guys had an off year all at the same time.
but he can only play what’s in front of him - and for most of the year… there wasn’t anyone
Click to expand...
Six games he got 3 Dally m points. 4 points off claiming the Dally M. That’s the reason why he was halfback of the year.
Moses did similarly the following year and everyone was just like yeah well of course he deserves it.
Credit where credit is due in 2018 he won the award.
 
Needaname said:
Six games he got 3 Dally m points. 4 points off claiming the Dally M. That’s the reason why he was halfback of the year.
Moses did similarly the following year and everyone was just like yeah well of course he deserves it.
Credit where credit is due in 2018 he won the award.
Click to expand...
Wasn’t disagreeing with you at all - that year, he was the best and most consistent half back…
Pretty sure the position awards aren’t always calculated on points.
 
Last edited:
batboy said:
Wasn’t disagreeing with you at all - that year, he was the best and most consistent half back…
Pretty sure the position awards aren’t always calculated on point
Click to expand...
batboy said:
Most of it - Cronk came good when it mattered…

That’s what champions do.

I thought he was a chance most of the year - he Bradbury’d it… the other guys had an off year all at the same time.
but he can only play what’s in front of him - and for most of the year… there wasn’t anyone
Click to expand...
Plenty of other halves missed games that year and others had to share points with other stars.
You really think he was better that year than Cleary, DCE, Cronk, Pearce, Reynolds etc?
Best half of the year?
Must have played SOO or for Australia?
No.
Must have at least have been considered?
No.
 
cktiger said:
Plenty of other halves missed games that year and others had to share points with other stars.
You really think he was better that year than Cleary, DCE, Cronk, Pearce, Reynolds etc?
Best half of the year?
Must have played SOO or for Australia?
No.
Must have at least have been considered?
No.
Click to expand...

They were quiet that year - yes he was better…
Had an argument with a good mate a month out that he was playing better football than all the above mentioned for the most part of the year.
Cronk just got to the roosters, - Panthers had all the scandals and had a crap year (I think) manly got off to a shocking start.. Parra won the spoon…
 
batboy said:
They were quiet that year - yes he was better…
Had an argument with a good mate a month out that he was playing better football than all the above mentioned for the most part of the year.
Cronk just got to the roosters, - Panthers had all the scandals and had a crap year (I think) manly got off to a shocking start.. Parra won the spoon…
Click to expand...
You must have been so shocked when he wasn’t even considered for big rep teams then?
An example from the other halves : Panthers actually ran 5th - with Cleary missing 8 rounds with injury and then the SOO rounds.
Really think Brooksy was a better player than Cleary that year?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 515 (members: 45, guests: 470)
Back
Top