Marshall and Farah

[GNR4LIFE]

If they can’t lead us to the finals this year, what hope do they have of doing it next year when they are yet another year older. They rarely did it in their 20’s and we’re now meant to think they can do it in their mid 30’s? The fact Ivan was so blaise in leaving the decision to play on up to them, maybe that’s the giveaway Cleary won’t be here to worry about them next year.

 

[matchball]

Yes. He is out for sure.
It will all get sorted in the off season. At least the forums will be lively in that often dull period.

 

[Newtown]

If we keep them next year the coach will have to play them in every firsts game throughout the year. If they are dropped just one first grade game Farah will throw a tantrun and Benji will feel indignant and crestfallen, it's happened before and means much more problems for Wests tigers in 2019.

 

[TIGER]

If they've got half a brain they'd call it quits and I think both of them will.

They'll embarrass themselves worse than JT if they run around next season.

 

[sheer64]

Yes time to hang up the boots and move on.

 

[851]

If they've got half a brain they'd call it quits and I think both of them will.

They'll embarrass themselves worse than JT if they run around next season.

Hope you are right, Benji is cooked and Farah not far off

 

[hobbo]

Farah off the bench

Marshall is finished

 

[GNR4LIFE]

If they've got half a brain they'd call it quits and I think both of them will.

They'll embarrass themselves worse than JT if they run around next season.

Hope you are right, Benji is cooked and Farah not far off

If Farah is a bit behind Marshall in looking cooked, it’s because he hasn’t played a full season and still has a bit of energy in the tank. No way he lasts another year.

 

[Snake]

Both have been playing at other Nrl clubs of late and both were playing out of reserve grade this says it all ..they have had there last moment in the sun time to ride off in the sunset.

 

[foreveratiger]

Farah off the bench

Marshall is finished

I agree with this , Liddle can start .

Farah will just be a cheap option for us and can play of the bench God forbid if Liddle gets an injury and we play ET at hooker unless we can get Segyaro

 

[Snake]

Farah off the bench

Marshall is finished

I agree with this , Liddle can start .

Farah will just be a cheap option for us and can play of the bench God forbid if Liddle gets an injury and we play ET at hooker unless we can get Segyaro

If the club ever wants to play finals footy this is not an option , you are not going to carry another hooker on the bench …times up for Farah he has to move on .

 

[foreveratiger]

Farah off the bench

Marshall is finished

I agree with this , Liddle can start .

Farah will just be a cheap option for us and can play of the bench God forbid if Liddle gets an injury and we play ET at hooker unless we can get Segyaro

If the club ever wants to play finals footy this is not an option , you are not going to carry another hooker on the bench …times up for Farah he has to move on .

Liddle can't play 80 minutes to great effect .

 

[Doc_Tiger]

Segeyaro is a must imo.

 

[Snake]

Farah off the bench

Marshall is finished

I agree with this , Liddle can start .

Farah will just be a cheap option for us and can play of the bench God forbid if Liddle gets an injury and we play ET at hooker unless we can get Segyaro

If the club ever wants to play finals footy this is not an option , you are not going to carry another hooker on the bench …times up for Farah he has to move on .

Liddle can't play 80 minutes to great effect .

Sign someone that can! If Liddle can not play a full 80 after a full off season punt him simple .

 

[Tcat]

If they've got half a brain they'd call it quits and I think both of them will.

They'll embarrass themselves worse than JT if they run around next season.

Tonight's game could be the catalyst.

 

[happy_tiger]

Farah off the bench

Marshall is finished

I agree with this , Liddle can start .

Farah will just be a cheap option for us and can play of the bench God forbid if Liddle gets an injury and we play ET at hooker unless we can get Segyaro

If the club ever wants to play finals footy this is not an option , you are not going to carry another hooker on the bench …times up for Farah he has to move on .

Liddle can't play 80 minutes to great effect .

No doubt the Robbie lovers are going to come after me with a big stick , but the biggest problem with Robbie is the gulf now between his good performances and the today type performances

Robbie won't sign for league minimum or even close and nor should he , he has played well at times this season

We need someone who has self control , that will take control of a game and play smart and simple

Robbie and Benji still lack that

 

[tigerbalm]

Still a fork in both of them.

 

[gallagher]

Signing Farah was a coach clutching at straws. A 9 game contact for a bloke stuck in reserves.
Clearly lost me that day.

 

[Doc_Tiger]

Signing Farah was a coach clutching at straws. A 9 game contact for a bloke stuck in reserves.
Clearly lost me that day.

Where's the like button?

 

[Byron_Bay_Fan]

I am amazed. About everyone in the team made a blunder except Farah. When he was taken off they failed to get a kick away on the fifth, the try they achieved had little to do with the DH I think, but their first try the DH was involved (RF).

I am happy whatever he decides to do but he was far from being responsible for the loss to night. Brooks on one occasion did not get a kick away on the fifth so soon after Farah gets one good away himself far into the tackle count - good play. He displayed quick reflexes to catch balls in tight play etc etc - I won't claim that he is still fast but Damien Cook has recently proven that being fast by itself is insufficient. Liddle is great but lacks smarts near the line but is definitely learning.