Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?

[Yossarian]

Possibly from a salary to performance or potential talent to actual results test.

There have been far worse players at the club. Anyone who lived through the 2001-2003 years could testify to that.

 

[krissy]

Worst signing would have to include Anasta

 

[steve-o]

Adam Blair is the tigers worst value-for-money signing,

Got to disagree: Russel Packer. So bad we can't even offload him probably offering to pay half his salary.

Na that’s recency bias. Blair was worse. We were in a premiership window, and we signed Blair at the expense of letting others go.

 

[Twodogs]

Isn't he on like 600-700 grand per season?

Meanwhile Corey Thompson was 10 times the player and was scraping in 150 grand per season.

Worst value for money at least, except for maybe Russell Packer.

 

[Twodogs]

There’s no way Mbye is the worst player to play for us. Even after tonight, I’d still take him everyday over Billy Walters.

Walters isn't getting $850 grand per year.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

Top 5 at least.

Talau is useless too.
Should never see grade again.

Did Mbye break a sweat ?
He’s an imposter

Absolutely…..you only have to look at his bubbly personality when he appears on commentary panels compared with his grim, do zilch Rugby League strategy..he does not want or care to be there..give someone a go that would kill to play first grade

 

[hobbo1]

Mbye got paid 30k last night

 

[jadtiger]

Mbye got paid 30k last night

I wouldnt have paid him 30 cents.

 

[Muffstar]

Top 5 at least.

Talau is useless too.
Should never see grade again.

Let's hope Talau has the ability to catch the plane back to Sydney as he could not catch a ball last night.

 

[steve-o]

There’s no way Mbye is the worst player to play for us. Even after tonight, I’d still take him everyday over Billy Walters.

Walters isn't getting $850 grand per year.

If you’re taking contract into account then you’re arguing that Mbye is the worst value player, rather than the worst based purely on onfield output.

 

[happy_tiger]

They are all useless tossers ..all deserve equal blame ...paychecks or no paychecks ...no more excuses WT's management ...fix this crap

 

[happy_tiger]

Wonder if they will invite all members to a training session this week lol

 

[Guest]

Anyone still think I'm wrong that this bloke just will not defend.

 

[Guest]

But one thing's guaranteed.
HE WON'T BE DROPPED.

 

[theraptor456]

Pound for pound (dollar for dollar) between him and Russell packer probably our worst ever yes

 

[TheDaBoss]

Something tellw me Dwight hates mbye but i cant put my finger on it

 

[rustycage]

No way he's the worst. We've had far worse.

 

[theraptor456]

No way he's the worst. We've had far worse.

Have we had far worse marquee players though taking 1/6 of the salary cap?

 

[rustycage]

No way he's the worst. We've had far worse.

Have we had far worse marquee players though taking 1/6 of the salary cap?

Thats not the question in the OP.

 

[theraptor456]

No way he's the worst. We've had far worse.

Have we had far worse marquee players though taking 1/6 of the salary cap?

Thats not the question in the OP.

All he has to do is add pound for pound and OP would be spot on with his analysis. As for worst in general He’s still not far off. Adds nothing in attack or defence.