Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?

[rihannafan1]

Worst contract: Josh Reynolds/Russell Packer

Least talent: Nathan Milone

Most disappointing: Adam Blair

Most peas in heart: Braith Anasta

Biggest dog: Ben Teo/Mitchell Moses

 

[TigerJunior4]

Worst contract: Josh Reynolds/Russell Packer

Least talent: Nathan Milone

Most disappointing: Adam Blair

Most peas in heart: Braith Anasta

Biggest dog: Ben Teo/Mitchell Moses

 

[dazza65]

Not a fan of Mbye but lets be serious for one second - he is by far NOT the worst player we have had - just the most recent whipping boy on an unbelievable over the top contract.... that is all.

 

[Snake]

Would not say Mr Lotto was the worse but probably one of the most unproductive players every for the money paid WAIT ON maybe the second PACKER is the KING for that one !

 

[Guest]

Discuss.

Just no. You think so?

If I had a choice between Mbye and a 41 year old Nick Bradley Qalilawa it'd be welcome back to first grade Nick.

 

[Spartan117]

Come on guys, your not really trying here.

We have a history with some names that would make u cry.

Almst 20years of garbage recruitment

Hoparte
Terry hill

 

[Demps]

Come on guys, your not really trying here.

We have a history with some names that would make u cry.

Almst 20years of garbage recruitment

Hoparte
Terry hill

AT LOWES!


 

[TillLindemann]

His inflated contract is not his fault, but the fact he plays like a cat is.

 

[rihannafan1]

Discuss.

Just no. You think so?

If I had a choice between Mbye and a 41 year old Nick Bradley Qalilawa it'd be welcome back to first grade Nick.

Hassan Saleh says hi.

 

[Depressed]

Hotly contested field that one

 

[Depressed]

Nick bradley something

 

[Depressed]

Kyle Lovette
Bwaif canasta
Buchanan
Hopoate
The tall Mc Guinness brother
L.Withers
H.Saleh
Sooo many they are just not memorable.

 

[tig_prmz]

Really unfair of Mbye here

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Kyle Lovette
Bwaif canasta
Buchanan
Hopoate
The tall Mc Guinness brother
L.Withers
H.Saleh
Sooo many they are just not memorable.

Are you kidding about Withers? He was an absolute champion for a guy his size. Absolutely smashed guys twice his size. So much ticker.

 

[Demps]

Really unfair of Mbye here

How he's treated our club has been unfair.

He's easily top 5 worst players we've signed in the last 10-15 years.

 

[JD Tiger]

Really unfair of Mbye here

**How he's treated our club has been unfair.**

He's easily top 5 worst players we've signed in the last 10-15 years.

Imo there Demps, totally, right on. He doesn't seem to care, he nor Packer how crippled their contracts have left our club. Our own fault for doing the contracts sure, but they have a responsibility to try and make it work.

Maybe MBye has been (he seems to be having more of a go then Packer but maybe Packer's injured? idk) but it does appear to not have been a big enough effort from an outsider's point of view.

 

[happy_tiger]

Well that explains it then ...if Mbye played for Wests he be at least 45 ...no wonder

 

[Harvey]

Played more games than Josh Reynolds, output & contract similar, effort and enthusiasm about 1/50th

 

[Demps]

Really unfair of Mbye here

**How he's treated our club has been unfair.**

He's easily top 5 worst players we've signed in the last 10-15 years.

Imo there Demps, totally, right on. He doesn't seem to care, he nor Packer how crippled their contracts have left our club. Our own fault for doing the contracts sure, but they have a responsibility to try and make it work.

Maybe MBye has been (he seems to be having more of a go then Packer but maybe Packer's injured? idk) but it does appear to not have been a big enough effort from an outsider's point of view.

Packer is having a laugh aye.

These guys are disgraceful imo.
Strong believe in, "If you do something, do it the best you can"
These pair have never shown any interest.

Ivan can only be blamed so much.
I hope we learn from this and only recruit players who are willing to put in.

 

[JD Tiger]

Really unfair of Mbye here

**How he's treated our club has been unfair.**

He's easily top 5 worst players we've signed in the last 10-15 years.

Imo there Demps, totally, right on. He doesn't seem to care, he nor Packer how crippled their contracts have left our club. Our own fault for doing the contracts sure, but they have a responsibility to try and make it work.

Maybe MBye has been (he seems to be having more of a go then Packer but maybe Packer's injured? idk) but it does appear to not have been a big enough effort from an outsider's point of view.

Packer is having a laugh aye.

These guys are disgraceful imo.
Strong believe in, "If you do something, do it the best you can"
These pair have never shown any interest.

Ivan can only be blamed so much.
I hope we learn from this and only recruit players who are willing to put in.

Did you hear on here a few months ago, a poster posted that an ex-player (of pretty decent calibre) approached Packer whilst Russell was in Reserves offering advice on how he can get back to First Grade. Packer's response was of thanks but no thanks, I'm right thanks.

I knew it's all rumours, but fair out, can you just imagine that??