MCK and Sirro

[pacman]

MCK and Sirro > Lovett and Rowdy, all day every day. Both offensively and defensively.

 

[clifferdSH]

Siro only played 5 mins but agree Chee Kam is a much better option than Lovett

 

[TYGA]

MCK is better than Lovett, Lawrence over Edwards for mine.

 

[supercoach]

Lovett was pretty strong most of the year and Rowdy was also strong, but I think MCK is a real athlete and the sky is the limit to where he could go, where Lovett and Rowdy what you see is pretty much what your going to get. As for Siro, love to think he could be a class back rower, but he just seems to be missing something

 

[matchball]

Lovett was pretty strong most of the year and Rowdy was also strong, but I think MCK is a real athlete and the sky is the limit to where he could go, where Lovett and Rowdy what you see is pretty much what your going to get. As for Siro, love to think he could be a class back rower, but he just seems to be missing something

No fire in his big frame.
Gentle giant.

 

[Buffalo]

Lovett and Rowdy all day every day

 

[Nelson]

Lovett was pretty strong most of the year and Rowdy was also strong, but I think MCK is a real athlete and the sky is the limit to where he could go, where Lovett and Rowdy what you see is pretty much what your going to get. As for Siro, love to think he could be a class back rower, but he just seems to be missing something

Both Lawrence and Lovett are probably suffering from some burnout after a long season with a lot of minutes played at first grade level in the forwards. Neither of them are used to that. I think the coaching staff should see how everyone goes in the preseason and trial games on refreshed legs before deciding on the second row and bench for next season.

 

[Guest]

I'd like to find a spot for MCK, he was good today, defensively and with the ball in hand. Whilst Lovett has improved noticeably this year, he is very one dimensional in attack, and this is where MCK has it all over him. Backrower by trade who can handle the centres without problem if need be, and he has superior speed to Lovett which gets the vote for me.

 

[ricksen]

Lovett seems to have been given time to develop and learn on the job in first grade - I just wish we'd had spent that time on MCK instead, as I think his ceiling (and floor to be honest) would be a lot higher.

 

[TrueTiger]

I'd like to find a spot for MCK, he was good today, defensively and with the ball in hand. Whilst Lovett has improved noticeably this year, he is very one dimensional in attack, and this is where MCK has it all over him. Backrower by trade who can handle the centres without problem if need be, and he has superior speed to Lovett which gets the vote for me.

Willow,I don't see much of the State Cup but I really like MCK when he plays in the fg team,do you think he will be in the NRL side next year considering his utility value,he appears to have what it takes to make it….

 

[Guest]

I'd like to find a spot for MCK, he was good today, defensively and with the ball in hand. Whilst Lovett has improved noticeably this year, he is very one dimensional in attack, and this is where MCK has it all over him. Backrower by trade who can handle the centres without problem if need be, and he has superior speed to Lovett which gets the vote for me.

Willow,I don't see much of the State Cup but I really like MCK when he plays in the fg team,do you think he will be in the NRL side next year considering his utility value,he appears to have what it takes to make it….

He's good enough to play FG, I think a lot will depend on who ends up in our top 25 next year.

 

[TYGA]

I'd like to find a spot for MCK, he was good today, defensively and with the ball in hand. Whilst Lovett has improved noticeably this year, he is very one dimensional in attack, and this is where MCK has it all over him. Backrower by trade who can handle the centres without problem if need be, and he has superior speed to Lovett which gets the vote for me.

He is a superior athlete and has more versatility than Lovett.
He looks the goods in first grade however, I like him as a centre and if we made this move over the offseason it may give the Tigers the option of moving Simona to the wing and Rankin left right out.

 

[Sully]

Keep both in the side

Swap Lawrence for Edwards and I think we have a solid side to defend against the Raiders