Might have a lot of enemies after this post but here goes...

[TJL]

The original poster made sense in his first post but since then has come off as a complete


We should invoke the concussion rule me thinks.

Yes but how many weeks should he be out for?

Following footy since he was 4, he probably didn't even make the under 7-5's on the wing.

 

[bigsiro]

I know what you're saying Anthism but it's not just the injuries he's already suffered (can't believe i'm saying that) it's the injuries he WILL suffer if he keeps running like that. It's physics. And yeah no need for snide remarks champ. I live rugby league and have done since i was 4 which you'll soon discover with my future insights and analysis of the game

For the record - I thought your first post was intelligible and made sense.
But dude, it's your first post and you're already sick of snide remarks?
Snide comments are the best stuff on here!
Take this next one for example: Your future insights will now be taken with a grain of salt. And I know salt. I have been eating it since I was 4.

 

[PJ_]

Milky, Im sorry champ, but you have no idea who you are dealing with here… This guy has lived footy since he was 4, and this is only the tip of the iceberg, if you cannot grasp these current insights you are going to totally blown away with his future insights and truth bombs. We are lucky to have him, and im personally just dying of anticipation to hear his analysis of the game...

This could be a once in a generation member...

:roll
love this forum

 

[bonstonker]

i haven't read all of this thread so i'll start with the comments by gus.
i don't agree with him at all.the only injury his running style risks is concussion.

now what he does after contact is what i see as a potential problem.he still fights the tackle which makes him prone to strains from forces going in opposite directions and twisting.

i don't want a player that submits like moltzen,
so if it costs me a few more dollars and some injuries then so be it.i'll take that chance any day off the week.
and how has moltzen fared with injury over the last 3 years by submitting 90% of the time.

injuries happen,the rest is just noise.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

And Fumbles get a grip on reality bud no tigers players read this especially not Tedesco in what will be most likely the biggest contract period of his career - Why should we not talk about this is a forum and it it is incredibly important to our club.

Some people on this forum just like to be critical even if what they're saying is pure rubbish

NEGATIVE AT ALL COSTS! Thank to some people who understand what I"m driving at.

The assumption made in your first sentence is incorrect I'm afraid.

Definitely incorrect, if my memory serves me right Beau actually posted on this forum in the past and Mayer often visits it too.

And you know these things how?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I agree with Balmainboyyy regarding Tedesco. YES, i want him re-signed, but i also do think he'll be injury prone. That isn't a slight on him, just how some players are. They can't afford to go overboard with what they offer, cos next thing you know the next couple seasons he'll struggle with injury, and people will get amnesia and say the club should never have re-signed him like they say about Lawrence, despite the fact before his injury people considered Chris Lawrence as the clubs most precious commodity. So yes, sign him, but proceed with caution imo.

I think Nofoaluma will prove to have been a more important signing in the long run.

 

[Milky]

And Fumbles get a grip on reality bud no tigers players read this especially not Tedesco in what will be most likely the biggest contract period of his career - Why should we not talk about this is a forum and it it is incredibly important to our club.

Some people on this forum just like to be critical even if what they're saying is pure rubbish

NEGATIVE AT ALL COSTS! Thank to some people who understand what I"m driving at.

The assumption made in your first sentence is incorrect I'm afraid.

Definitely incorrect, if my memory serves me right Beau actually posted on this forum in the past and Mayer often visits it too.

And you know these things how?

http://weststigersforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=9&t=1809

 

[Wacko_Jacko]

Has David Nofoaluma ever played FB ? I don't think his got ball playing skills to play FB

He played fullback for Wests Harold Matts and SG Ball if I'm not mistaken.

I have only seen him in 20's so thought he was wing only. Interesting

Teddy saying on Twitter that Nofo us to set up tries for him and Nofo was FB with Teddy on wing

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Pretty sure Nofoaluma was fullback ahead of Tedesco in the Australian schoolboys.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Teddy is hardly injury prone, he's rolled an ankle and popped an ACL. I didn't realise being kneed in the head made you injury prone?

Consider Marshall and Moltzen who have had a host of repetitive injuries, Teddy is anything but by comparison.

 

[Balmainboyyy]

GNR4LIFE is a very smart man. I dont know why I received so much disrespect and resistance from my opinions…my whole view was basically sign tedesco at a reasonable price, but not to a point where it will cost us a nofo and a sironen or more.

Nofo re-signed today is a very smart move, the ideal situation is now signing tedesco and siro at reasonable prices, but yeahhh as gnr alluded to, "brace yourselves, people saying we shouldnt have thrown the chequebook at teddy is coming"

 

[Balmainboyyy]

Lol at happy, fraze, tigerlogic, wd in perth, milky and wacko jacko for TRYING to make fun of me - key word trying if you missed it…my opinions are reasonable and you all know it. P.S lol milky

 

[Balmainboyyy]

Milky just out of pure interest and fun and lets face it me being a bit mean, how much do you think roosters or say manly or storm would offer sironen and thompson respectively?

 

[tigerlogic]

Lol at happy, fraze, tigerlogic, wd in perth, milky and wacko jacko for TRYING to make fun of me - key word trying if you missed it…my opinions are reasonable and you all know it. P.S lol milky

Y do u keep saying "you all know it"!
Surely by our responses u can see we are not in awe of ur 'amazing long term experience and insights' and that we have clearly disagreed with you with various things, y does that mean we are making fun of you?
And you know it :slight_smile:

_Posted using RoarFEED V.4_

 

[Milky]

Milky just out of pure interest and fun and lets face it me being a bit mean, how much do you think roosters or say manly or storm would offer sironen and thompson respectively?

No one knows how much any player is on mate, if everyone was to add up players salaries according to the telegraph every team would be over the cap.

In my opinion though, they would not offer any over 280k

You have stated your opinion and we have stated ours, it's a forum, I cop a lot of crap and put up with, toughen up.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I wouldn't say Tedesco is injury prone atm, but imo he definitely has the look of a player that could be in the long run. Have a look how many times in the opening 5 weeks he's stayed down clutching at his legs. I'd been saying for a few weeks he was flirting with a serious injury, and it turns out i was right. I want to keep him, don't mis-understand me, i just think he's the type of player who might see extended stints on the sidelines.

 

[jirskyr]

GNR4LIFE is a very smart man. I dont know why I received so much disrespect and resistance from my opinions…my whole view was basically sign tedesco at a reasonable price, but not to a point where it will cost us a nofo and a sironen or more.

Mate people are allowed to disagree with you, that is the whole point of the forum.

You are fighting a losing battle if you want to engage every forum member you disagree with, you will be on here forever.

Say your piece, voice new opinions, let grudges and arguments go. You know what they say about opinions.

 

[batboy]

So it's Don't sign Teddy cos he's injury Prone…
But Siro is a MUST!!

Mate, If you had turned up more than 10 minutes ago, You'd know that Siro has spent most of the last 5 yrs Injured!!
Next time try have a think about what you're about to type before you actually type it...

Doesn't this forum had Mods anymore..... Or are they all in Primary School?

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

I wouldn't say Tedesco is injury prone atm, but imo he definitely has the look of a player that could be in the long run. Have a look how many times in the opening 5 weeks he's stayed down clutching at his legs. I'd been saying for a few weeks he was flirting with a serious injury, and it turns out i was right. I want to keep him, don't mis-understand me, i just think he's the type of player who might see extended stints on the sidelines.

As long as he's like Bradley Clyde and always fit for the clutch games.

 

[Guest]

Lol at happy, fraze, tigerlogic, wd in perth, milky and wacko jacko for TRYING to make fun of me - key word trying if you missed it…my opinions are reasonable and you all know it. P.S lol milky

These are not the droids you're looking for :unamused: