OFFICIAL Moses Mbye [Discussion]

[getagrip]

There is a comment on Fox Sports website saying that Mbye doesn't know where he will be next year???

 

[Telltails]

And yet Douehi makes mention of Mybe in the interview at the end of the game - how good it was having him at the back.
All pressure on the coach. Such a shortage of players across the competition the players hold all the cards. They know they will get picked up if it doesn't work out for them here, and they play that way.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

And yet Douehi makes mention of Mybe in the interview at the end of the game - how good it was having him at the back.
All pressure on the coach. Such a shortage of players across the competition the players hold all the cards. They know they will get picked up if it doesn't work out for them here, and they play that way.

If he wasn't on so much money I'd advocate for him to be played in reggies all next year and completely blow up his ability to earn another big contract.

 

[TYGA]

Some really bad contracts Mbye, Packer, Reynolds, Matulino have crippled the club.
Our rebuild should have started 3 years ago instead we are treading water with a lack of talent. Unbelievable mess Cleary created.

 

[DJG]

Its only 4 games.. more or less will play, lets just hope he gives his all for the last few games..

 

[Tiger5150]

Needs to GO.

Hit the thumbs up if you AGREE!

Mbye is an interesting example of poor recruitment. No denying he has some skill, and I guess that’s what Qld selectors saw in him? He hasn’t been a good fit at WT. I think the dogs should take him back at FB.

Ahead of Dufty?

 

[Needaname]

I thought Cini organised our defensive line better than Mbye when at the back. Also showed more urgency to cover the kicks in 4th, 5th play on the line.
Attack wise ran more but we didn’t see what his passing game was like as there wasn’t the opportunities available.
I’m adamant that mbye is more suited to a first reciever role being at half or ball playing lock and that’s where he should remain for the year. I’d like Cini to have more time at fullback.

 

[twentyforty]

Needs to GO.

Hit the thumbs up if you AGREE!

Mbye is an interesting example of poor recruitment. No denying he has some skill, and I guess that’s what Qld selectors saw in him? He hasn’t been a good fit at WT. I think the dogs should take him back at FB.

Ahead of Dufty?

Haha, their fullbacks aren’t working so why not have one more?

 

[Tiger-ferret]

Some really bad contracts Mbye, Packer, Reynolds, Matulino have crippled the club.
Our rebuild should have started 3 years ago instead we are treading water with a lack of talent. Unbelievable mess Cleary created.

And to me it highlights the point that changing a coach disrupts a clubs progress more. Packer Mbye would not have been as disillusioned and although still over priced, would have been better valued contracts (Reynolds would still have been injury prone, I thought Mats had a crack, also injury prone).

 

[earl]

Unbelievable mess Cleary created.

He completely stuffed us didn't he. I'm so glad he is gone. He is why I'm not a Madge hater. I don't see Madge stuffing this club longer term.

Cleary got those guys playing above their level. Madge hasn't got out team playing to their level.

I'm much more confident long term that Madge would have the team performing better than Cleary would. Madge will develop a better roster.

I think Mbye gets a spot in our team because we are short on talent but geez he is a borderline first grader in our team. Melbourne are going all out for Brandon Smith and offering him 600k. We are paying Mbye top dollar.

 

[Guest]

He continues to prove me right every week.
The man will not put his body in harms way.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Just reading this last page.. Ohara was good enough once to play origin, Head was terrific at saints as was Mcqueen at south's, another origin rep.
Craigie had some awesome raps from legends at one stage

They come here and we turn them into duds

McQueen breaking his neck after he signed with us is what turned him into a dud. I mentioned in another thread only a couple days ago that I thought Head was terrific for us. Something must have been going on behind the scenes for it to go the way it did. I’m probably the only person that remembers O’Hara after a slow start, really settled into a groove in his last season and looked a good player. Craigie, I think he was just lazy, nothing to do with us. He was just one of those players who could do anything he wanted, but his biggest weakness was his heart

 

[rihannafan1]

Discuss.

Just no. You think so?

 

[rihannafan1]

Worst contract: Josh Reynolds/Russell Packer

Least talent: Nathan Milone

Most disappointing: Adam Blair

Most peas in heart: Braith Anasta

Biggest dog: Ben Teo/Mitchell Moses

 

[Telltails]

Unbelievable mess Cleary created.

He completely stuffed us didn't he. I'm so glad he is gone. He is why I'm not a Madge hater. I don't see Madge stuffing this club longer term.

Cleary got those guys playing above their level. Madge hasn't got out team playing to their level.

I'm much more confident long term that Madge would have the team performing better than Cleary would. Madge will develop a better roster.

I think Mbye gets a spot in our team because we are short on talent but geez he is a borderline first grader in our team. Melbourne are going all out for Brandon Smith and offering him 600k. We are paying Mbye top dollar.

Very hard to get the best out of players that you are moving on in a bog average team. From the get go Maguire has had to try and move on our highest paid senior players with little interest be cause they were all ridiculously over paid. Your highest paid players should always be your best players and good luck to any coach who has it the opposite way around.

 

[Ultimate Warrior]

Unbelievable mess Cleary created.

He completely stuffed us didn't he. I'm so glad he is gone. He is why I'm not a Madge hater. I don't see Madge stuffing this club longer term.

Cleary got those guys playing above their level. Madge hasn't got out team playing to their level.

I'm much more confident long term that Madge would have the team performing better than Cleary would. Madge will develop a better roster.

I think Mbye gets a spot in our team because we are short on talent but geez he is a borderline first grader in our team. Melbourne are going all out for Brandon Smith and offering him 600k. We are paying Mbye top dollar.

Very hard to get the best out of players that you are moving on in a bog average team. From the get go Maguire has had to try and move on our highest paid senior players with little interest be cause they were all ridiculously over paid. Your highest paid players should always be your best players and good luck to any coach who has it the opposite way around

Exactly!

Some coach was going to have to come in and do the necessary dirt work to move players on that are on huge contracts and concentrate on the juniors. Madge is the guy. He should be able to enjoy the fruits of his labour once he can actually field a team he wants

 

[Harvey]

I just can't work him out. He does have some skills, but seems to be coasting at the moment.

Running the ball into touch yesterday was something I just could not work out, though I will say he got to that ball with more urgency than I have seen from him in the last 3 months. He floats around the ball runner but it appears like he is trying to get on camera, he doesn't appear to actually want the ball.

His efforts returning kicks are embarrassing, he is looking for anyone else to (and prepared to throw stupid passes to get someone else to) do the work. When he is isolated, he jogs to the defence and submits to the tackle.

I honestly can't wait to see the back of him and would prefer to to see anyone prepared to make an effort picked ahead of him.

 

[Speed2burn]

Dragons fans actually seem to want him lol

Found this pearler and had to share

Mbye is a very smart footballer, he is not a player like Pongia but more like a Hornby. With our young players coming through we need a player like Mbye.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Dragons fans actually seem to want him lol

Found this pearler and had to share

Mbye is a very smart footballer, he is not a player like Pongia but more like a Hornby. With our young players coming through we need a player like Mbye.

Jesus they must be really desperate.

 

[WT2K]

Dragons fans actually seem to want him lol

Found this pearler and had to share

Mbye is a very smart footballer, he is not a player like Pongia but more like a Hornby. With our young players coming through we need a player like Mbye.

Things must be desperate over at the Steelers