OFFICIAL Moses Mbye [Discussion]

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

I don't know whether or not we should keep Mbye. There are variables to consider.
- Can we pick up a good player in return?
- Does letting him go help us re-sign one of our better players, such as Luciano?
- Jackson Hastings - where will he play?
- Is there a spot for Mbye, Doueihi, and Hastings in the same team?

At this stage I think we're better off keeping him. So long as he's happy and keeps performing well then I have no issues.

 

[TheDaBoss]

Stay. If Walters leaves then who else comes in? ZDC?

Si

If he keeps his form up i do see him makimg a push

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Here’s a question. If he’s here in 2022, is he worth re-signing? Significantly reduced obviously.

 

[hank37w]

Here’s a question. If he’s here in 2022, is he worth re-signing? Significantly reduced obviously.

Yes, but for no more than $400k - $450k max, at which point he is a good signing assuming his form is still good.

 

[TigerBlood93]

Hypothetically if mybe agreed to split his 800k contract into 400k with and extra year with us in 23, would you guys take him for a extra year if it mean we split his contract amount in half?


400k - 2022
400k -2023

Pro - his contract is halved
Negative - he stays an extra year

If we won the next few games I wonder
What you guys would say..

 

[TigerWest]

Hypothetically if mybe agreed to split his 800k contract into 400k with and extra year with us in 23, would you guys take him for a extra year if it mean we split his contract amount in half?


400k - 2022
400k -2023

Pro - his contract is halved
Negative - he stays an extra year

If we won the next few games I wonder
What you guys would say..

I think what he has shown the last few games, it is certainly worth consideration, but other clubs would have noticed and I don't think he would need take such a large pay cut? He can stay here next year on full rate and leave?

Also, I think the club has taken steps to replace him, so don't think they would interested either, but you never know?

 

[jadtiger]

Hypothetically if mybe agreed to split his 800k contract into 400k with and extra year with us in 23, would you guys take him for a extra year if it mean we split his contract amount in half?


400k - 2022
400k -2023

Pro - his contract is halved
Negative - he stays an extra year

If we won the next few games I wonder
What you guys would say..

He is our highest paid player at reportedly 900k+.There is no way i could see him playing for half of his salary next year and the year after(no gain in it for him).Give him the flick if we can if not let him see out his contract with no extension

 

[happy_tiger]

If we could upgrade him yes , if we can't no

Pretty simple really

 

[Spartan117]

Here’s a question. If he’s here in 2022, is he worth re-signing? Significantly reduced obviously.

In my Business Experience .... 100% NO

There will always be the Subconscious feeling that I'm getting half therefore I am only doing half. It is the nature of man.

This is not his last contract in the NRL but hopefully his last with the Tigers.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Keen to see what everyone thinks...If he goes, we would he paying a large amount of his salary and would have to replace him with someone better on minimum salary to justify it.

Do we keep him at 5/8 with Brooks playing decently having him there or do we let him go?

Major problem keeping him is we probably lose Doueihi...

Only if we do not get a decent deal done.

 

[hobbo1]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Here’s a question. If he’s here in 2022, is he worth re-signing? Significantly reduced obviously.

In my Business Experience .... 100% NO

There will always be the Subconscious feeling that I'm getting half therefore I am only doing half. It is the nature of man.

This is not his last contract in the NRL but hopefully his last with the Tigers.

He’s nowhere as horrible as Milford. I don’t think the Broncos are offering him a contract at all. Given the way he’s played the last few weeks, if he keeps it up, I can see a contract on the table for 2023. Assuming he’s here next year.

 

[happy_tiger]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

At half he is probably playing at a 550 k level player .......unless you play him at half ...who would take him for 550 k .....thats the problem

 

[hobbo1]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

At half he is probably playing at a 550 k level player .......unless you play him at half ...who would take him for 550 k .....thats the problem

He’s a crappy half .. even $550k is way overs

 

[JD Tiger]

The Top Paid MUST be the TOP Performers.

It can never be a must because players get injured. It should though be a goal. The last thing we want to do though is make our team perform worse in order to meet this criteria.


We Should not dismiss remuneration when judging a players ***value on the field*** and to the club

Serious question, ***why***?

I understand the impact of his salary on the make up of the squad, but after that what significance does it have to his selection and on field value?

I think it would play on the minds of players for one thing. I think it weighed us down (impacted team harmony and cohesion, confidence, trust in each other) when we had players like Packer, Reynolds, McQueen in reserve grade collecting decent money for not much return.

 

[happy_tiger]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

At half he is probably playing at a 550 k level player .......unless you play him at half ...who would take him for 550 k .....thats the problem

He’s a crappy half .. even $550k is way overs

Crappy halves get paid way more ...your new lover for example ......

Have you told MCK you have dumped him yet ......cheater ...

 

[hobbo1]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

At half he is probably playing at a 550 k level player .......unless you play him at half ...who would take him for 550 k .....thats the problem

He’s a crappy half .. even $550k is way overs

Crappy halves get paid way more ...your new lover for example ......

Have you told MCK you have dumped him yet ......cheater ...

Brooks is on $650k

I’m having lunch with Cheeks tomorrow
I’ll tell him then ( after he pays)

 

[Enmoretiger 0]

Mbye has been a absolute master stroke by Madge, Brooks is playing with such confidence & Luke is a shy kid & needs his confidence up and Mbye is a perfect foil.
Mbye's cut out passes are fantastic, I am sure Jimmy will catch them all form now on. His defence and link play is very affective, he has great ball skills, short kicking game & he is wasted at hooker
Me, I think keep him and sign him up again if we can.
We are building a strong team

 

[Geo]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

At half he is probably playing at a 550 k level player .......unless you play him at half ...who would take him for 550 k .....thats the problem

He’s a crappy half .. even $550k is way overs

Your not providing any incentive for another Club to sign him...

On the one hand you say punt him on the other you say he’s not worth a PIE and Sauce...

You won’t get a better player in return for 150k if you are paying 800k for Mbye to play for someone else.. that’s the issue not simply punt him...

 

[happy_tiger]

65% nay
35% yay
The tribe has spoken ..
Trade him ..
We can get better for the coin he’s on .

At half he is probably playing at a 550 k level player .......unless you play him at half ...who would take him for 550 k .....thats the problem

He’s a crappy half .. even $550k is way overs

Crappy halves get paid way more ...your new lover for example ......

Have you told MCK you have dumped him yet ......cheater ...

Brooks is on $650k

I’m having lunch with Cheeks tomorrow
I’ll tell him then ( after he pays)

Thats low .....