OFFICIAL Moses Mbye [Discussion]

@papacito said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407089) said:
There seems to be a lot unhealthy of jealousy over another man's pay packet on this forum.....

That's the Aussie way ..you know that 😉
 
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds? he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.
 
@papacito said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407089) said:
There seems to be a lot unhealthy of jealousy over another man's pay packet on this forum.....

I'm extremely jealous of what he gets paid, aren't you?

We are not getting value for money out of him, if he is indeed on 800K a year, I would be OK with the club carrying $500K of that to have him play elsewhere next year and put that money and spot toward another centre, winger or second rower.
 
@avocadoontoast said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407056) said:
@tore85 said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407050) said:
What are the chances we can restructure Mbye for next year and beyond?

I thought he & Brooksy looked ok yesterday.
Liddle also had his best game this year
Laurie is our best player hands down, Douehi not far.

What if we keep Mbye until until 2024, we restructure his deal next year and extend him two?

In stead of paying him $850k-900k 2022, we could get Mbye down to $750k 2022, $700k the 2023 and $600k in 2024? These numbers could even be lower, am just using them as an example.

That would mean the player has a future, he gets a bit more confidence, we get continuity in the spine and we get to take Mbye's effective salary to say $700k a year over the next three years? What are your thoughts on this?

Lets be honest, he isn't going to get that sort of money elsewhere. We get some cap relief next year and we also get to give him a chance to see what he can do with Brooksy, again, I think they combined well yesterday. Seems silly to start all over again with someone else if the combo flourishes.

The NFL does this sort of thing a lot to reduce the cap $ on guys that are being paid overs or regularly injured.

Nope, I think we just hang on and get him off our books once and for all at the end of next year. No point prolonging the agony.

Exactly. Use him where possible but if he doesn't deserve to be in first grade don't pick him. I wouldn't pick him.
 
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. **As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds?** he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

I never thought Ben T’eo would be topped

Well there you have it quoting James Bond.. Never say Never again
 
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds? he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

Yeah I've changed my mind on him after yesterday. If he can't even be bothered trying on his own milestone 150th match, he's never going to bother trying again. Get him out of here ASAP.
 
@geo said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407103) said:
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. **As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds?** he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

I never thought Ben T’eo would be topped

Well there you have it quoting James Bond.. Never say Never again

Mbye ..pussy galore
 
@hobbo1 said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407113) said:
@geo said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407103) said:
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. **As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds?** he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

I never thought Ben T’eo would be topped

Well there you have it quoting James Bond.. Never say Never again

Mbye ..pussy galore

???
 
@hobbo1 said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407113) said:
@geo said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407103) said:
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. **As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds?** he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

I never thought Ben T’eo would be topped

Well there you have it quoting James Bond.. Never say Never again

Mbye ..pussy galore


Very harsh,she was good looking
 
@jadtiger said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407117) said:
@hobbo1 said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407113) said:
@geo said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407103) said:
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. **As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds?** he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

I never thought Ben T’eo would be topped

Well there you have it quoting James Bond.. Never say Never again

Mbye ..pussy galore


Very harsh,she was good looking

All in the name mate ..
 
@snake said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407093) said:
@papacito said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407089) said:
There seems to be a lot unhealthy of jealousy over another man's pay packet on this forum.....

That's the Aussie way ..you know that ?

We care too much what others think?
 
@happy_tiger said in [Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?](/post/1406823) said:
@krammy said in [Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?](/post/1406325) said:
Mate, It was a long time ago, but there were some awful buys in the early 2000's. One that comes to mind was the really talented, but really lazy centre, come five eight from Newcastle. Just remembered - Owen Craigie. The current Sportsbet guy at fullback; Corey Patterson, Kyle Lovett, and who could forget Matt Groat. Yeh, we've had our share of shockers.

Nick Graham and Jason Cayless ......

Ryan O'Hara, Matthew Head, Chris McQueen.

Don't forget our great young future stars: Jacob Miller, Kurtis Rowe, Jack Buchanan, Delouise Hoeter, Lamar Liolavave, Nathan (God of State Cup) Milone,
 
@harvey said in [Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?](/post/1407334) said:
@happy_tiger said in [Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?](/post/1406823) said:
@krammy said in [Mbye the worst player to ever play for Wests?](/post/1406325) said:
Mate, It was a long time ago, but there were some awful buys in the early 2000's. One that comes to mind was the really talented, but really lazy centre, come five eight from Newcastle. Just remembered - Owen Craigie. The current Sportsbet guy at fullback; Corey Patterson, Kyle Lovett, and who could forget Matt Groat. Yeh, we've had our share of shockers.

Nick Graham and Jason Cayless ......

Ryan O'Hara, Matthew Head, Chris McQueen.

Don't forget our great young future stars: Jacob Miller, Kurtis Rowe, Jack Buchanan, Delouise Hoeter, Lamar Liolavave, Nathan (God of State Cup) Milone,

Head and McQueen had at least one decent game ...Head won us a game ...McQueen had a good night when we flogged Penrith at Magic Round ....automatically excludes them .......Milone had a good game in NYC v Canberra
 
Just reading this last page.. Ohara was good enough once to play origin, Head was terrific at saints as was Mcqueen at south's, another origin rep.
Craigie had some awesome raps from legends at one stage

They come here and we turn them into duds
 
@geo said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407103) said:
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. **As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds?** he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

I never thought Ben T’eo would be topped

Well there you have it quoting James Bond.. Never say Never again

That was a lame attempt.

HOWEVER:
![3305f0b6-d75f-41ef-a223-5dcc06ccee29-image.png](/assets/uploads/files/1625473786848-3305f0b6-d75f-41ef-a223-5dcc06ccee29-image.png)

If he comes in on Reynolds, it is a 4 on 2. Souths spread the ball and the winger scores untouched.

That would have been Nofa's fault for leaving his winger unmarked.

**Lesson: It is always Nofa's fault. He can't defend**
 
watched the souths game with a friend that is not into league,friend was constintly remarking why oomby oomby was just standing around,personally thought he was a calming influence 4 a few games at 5/8 a few weeks back.but then we were winning.were got bigger problems then just him
 
@tilllindemann said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407109) said:
@fade-to-black said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407095) said:
@weststigerman said in [Do we keep Mbye?](/post/1407078) said:
I'd rather pay him 500k to play elsewhere next year than give him another year.

His performance and effort is a big part of what is wrong with Wests Tigers. Senior players that don't give a toss, why should the younger players care.

Yep. As soon as he put in that pathetic attempt on Reynolds? he should've been hooked from the field. That was as disgustingly disgraceful as it gets. He is of no use to us, would be happy to pay him his full salary to play for another club. Give someone a go who will at least have a bit of a dig. A peaheart setting the example/standards is not going to get you anywhere in this comp.

Yeah I've changed my mind on him after yesterday. If he can't even be bothered trying on his own milestone 150th match, he's never going to bother trying again. Get him out of here ASAP.

Yes, I'm afraid that one changed my mind too. ByebyeMbye
 
Back
Top