Moses Mbye Super Duper Thread

[Geo]

This is the scoop of the year and Brooks at the same time , watching him run and pass to anyone around him is pathetic!

Gotta laugh. We are being smashed in the forwards, and can't complete a set to save ourselves and you guys want to get rid of the Brooks and Mbye.

Mbyes first 3 significant contributions in the first half were a dropped ball and 2 missed tackles, one for a try under the posts. He's a disgrace.

And it was further downhill from there

 

[ElleryHanley]

Look, he comes across as a decent bloke...but your leader sets your tone. I think, if he is being honest, his heart is not in it. He displays zero passion for it.

 

[Fraze23]

thanks ivan

Ivan didn't make him captain. It's clear Maguire rates him too for some unknown reason.

 

[Fraze23]

Look, he comes across as a decent bloke...but your leader sets your tone. I think, if he is being honest, his heart is not in it. He displays zero passion for it.

He never wanted it in the first place. Madge talked him into it.

 

[Chaos]

Whole team played crap, but I agree, Mbye needs to go... sooner rather than later.

 

[Tigrrs]

Mbye, Marshall and Brooks all have to go ASAP , Mbye is possibly a 14 only ever again,

 

[hugggarz]

Unfortunately with Walters out, he will probably be starting again next week, even if Liddle plays.

 

[tiger05premier]

Never seen a captain so flat...he barely even goes through the motions.

Has to go.

Madge needs to explain the captaincy....he has to go.

I guess Madge just doing what he feels is beat with the cattle he has

Don't worry I agree with you

But I don't blame Madge

After watching the performance tonight I still think Maybe is the man but now see the job ahead of him is bigger than I think any of us believed

Knights were missing as many players as we were but had a go

We dogged it totally

Just makes Madge jobs easier and the players jobs harder

When Mbye contract is up what happens?

Tiger's don't offer a contract and than every other club says well I've got this amount in the cap

Sign on or rack off

150k from 950k

That's reality Mbye get used to it

Marshall too though

Always loved but for God sake

Can't tackle can't kick

Do I sound like Shane Warne

Sorry about that

But Jesus

A good attacking game every 4th or 5th week keeps him in the team

Just tell him to retire

1st time I've said that but he was so Damn poor tonight

Rant over for now but I'm sure there will be more to come

And that bloke from the rorters

No I'm not going to bag him

At least he tried

Just saying he would be wondering what he has walked into

We put some pressure on him by playing so badly

He may be too scared to even show back up at concord after that disaster

 

[Tiger_heart]

Assured of a place next week, no doubt...

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

He is apart of our problem.
To have a captain who doesn’t motivate, talk & steer the team & can’t even cement a normal position says it all for us. He wouldn’t be captain at any other club & probably wouldn’t be a starter either these days.

Madge showed his cards and after tonight he should be punted - I lost count of the restarts at crucial times, he was the only one giving them and it was stupid holding the ball ones as well.

 

[hobbo1]

Mbye on $800k
Brooks on $550k

I’d rather be 1.35m down in the cap next season than play these nuffies

 

[Hangonaminute]

We looked great without Grant 😳

 

[weststigerman]

How may set restarts did he give away? Would have to be close to a record

 

[CocaCola]

Mbye should only make 1 call as captain, and that is to demote himself of the role.

 

[boonboon]

To give him some credit - he is a centre/fullback playing at hooker and he made 59 tackles and only missed 1 all be it one that lead to a try.

 

[getagrip]

Must be his turn to get dropped. Hope it is from a great height

 

[Tcat]

3 certain things in life.

Death
Taxes and
Mbye not playing in the NRL ever again when his contract with us is finished.

 

[Hangonaminute]

To give him some credit - he is a centre/fullback playing at hooker and he made 59 tackles and only missed 1 all be it one that lead to a try.

The thing is, he's neither a centre or a fullback or a half or a hooker.

Name another captain that doesn't have a position.

When you realise that you can't, you'll understand why the Tigers are a shipwreck

 

[Fade.To.Black]

To give him some credit - he is a centre/fullback playing at hooker and he made 59 tackles and only missed 1 all be it one that lead to a try.

That is fair enough. Didn't realise he made that many tackles.
Make him number 14, take the captaincy off him and also the goalkicking duties as well though.

 

[Harvey]

He should be playing fullback or in the halves. Based on his form this year it would be in reserve grade, but outside of those positions (and maybe even there) he is a stop gap.