Most Underrated and Overrated players in the NRL?

[tigerap]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
Underrated: Munster

 

[Speed2burn]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
**Underrated: **Munster****

I’d say Munster definitely gets a fair wrap. Best player in the game in my eyes

 

[hobbo1]

Overrated ..Ramjet
Underrated...Chee Kam

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
**Underrated: **Munster****

I’d say Munster definitely gets a fair wrap. Best player in the game in my eyes

Yeah I hardly think Munster is underrated, same with Finucane, Radley & Staggs. All are very highly rated by everyone in league.

Those underrated are the ones who are very good players, but they never seem to make rep teams or get the plaudits from commentators or fans. One who comes to mind is Justin Olam, another is Mitch Aubusson.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Underrated Victor Radley - the steel in the. Roosters' team
Overrated Josh Hodgson - runs around in ever decreasing circles at dummy half

 

[Speed2burn]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
**Underrated: **Munster****

I’d say Munster definitely gets a fair wrap. Best player in the game in my eyes

Yeah I hardly think Munster is underrated, same with Finucane, Radley & Staggs. All are very highly rated by everyone in league.

Those underrated are the ones who are very good players, but they never seem to make rep teams or get the plaudits from commentators or fans. One who comes to mind is Justin Olam, another is Mitch Aubusson.

I put Radley as my underrated player, has not made any rep teams as of yet (that I can think of off the top of my head). Rorters fell in a heap towards the back end due to his absence..unsung hero in their 2 premiership winning seasons aswell.

I’d compare him to Murray who gets a ton of wraps, more than him...but if I had to choose between the two I’d go for radley 100%

 

[clontarfkid]

I actually rate tupou...reliable defender,good finisher,,unbeatable in the air..and does a lot of dirty work out of his own 20.
Cronulla has some of the most over-rated players in the comp..Fifita/Dugan/Moylan are every bit as underperforming and overpriced as our "big 3"..which is a credit to the coach to carry that team into the 8

 

[Tigercrb]

Over rated: tatau moga (injured alot yes, but somehow keeps getting contracts), Felise kaufusi

Under rated: Joseph tapine, Joel Thompson

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

over rated Clint Gutherson
underrated James tamau

 

[WT2K]

Plenty to name... Here's a few

Overrated; Gutherson, Mitch Moses, Felise Kaufusi

Underrated: Brimson, Luai, Kenny Bromwhich

 

[Fade.To.Black]

I actually rate tupou...reliable defender,good finisher,,unbeatable in the air..and does a lot of dirty work out of his own 20.
Cronulla has some of the most over-rated players in the comp..Fifita/Dugan/Moylan are every bit as underperforming and overpriced as our "big 3"..which is a credit to the coach to carry that team into the 8

Absolutely agree on Tupou, he is tougher than many give him credit for. Would love him at WT.
He'd make a huge difference to our team. Hopefully Kepoa can be our Tupou.
Underated: Cam McInness
Overrated: Moses, Matteson, Latrell

 

[InBenjiWeTrust]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
**Underrated: **Munster****

I’d say Munster definitely gets a fair wrap. Best player in the game in my eyes

Tedesco, Papalii, and Taumalolo say hi:blush:

 

[hank37w]

Hopefully Kepoa can be our Tupou.

I see a fair bit of Tupou in young Kepoa.
I think he will go okay despite what a lot of others may think.

 

[Speed2burn]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
**Underrated: **Munster****

I’d say Munster definitely gets a fair wrap. Best player in the game in my eyes

Tedesco, Papalii, and Taumalolo say hi:blush:

I would take Munster over all of them still. Got to remember Munny was just as good a fullback as he is 5/8...essentially mastered two positions. He’s a freak

Just my opinion though.

 

[Fade.To.Black]

Overrated: Mitch Moses, Mitch Pearce, Nathan Cleary, Latrell Mitchell
**Underrated: **Munster****

I’d say Munster definitely gets a fair wrap. Best player in the game in my eyes

Tedesco, Papalii, and Taumalolo say hi:blush:

Yep. Those 3 have it all over him for consistency.

 

[Tigerlily]

Overrated = Daly Cherry-Evans, C.Gutherson

Underrated = Roger Tuivasa-Sheck, Conner Watson

 

[BAGNF05]

On 2020 form

Over rated: Ponga
Under rated: jahrome Hughes

Tigers

Over rated: Nofa
Under rated: Talau

 

[bbobb]

Underrated: Justin Olam; Raymond Fatali Mariner; Patrick Carrigan; Zane Musgrove; Brian To’a; Adam Doueihi; Liam Knight; Lindsay Collins

Overrated: Mitchell Moses; Nathan Cleary; Moses Mbye; Coen Hess; Adam Reynolds;

 

[Fade.To.Black]

On 2020 form

Over rated: Ponga
Under rated: jahrome Hughes

Tigers

Over rated: Nofa
Under rated: Talau

Wow that is interesting. On 2020 form Nofo, along with Luciano were head and shoulders our best players (notwithstanding Harry who isn't ours to worry about anymore). And IMO Talau was pretty disappointing considering the hype. What do you think TT is underrated in regards to? Serious question mate, not trying to take the mickey.

 

[BAGNF05]

On 2020 form

Over rated: Ponga
Under rated: jahrome Hughes

Tigers

Over rated: Nofa
Under rated: Talau

Wow that is interesting. On 2020 form Nofo, along with Luciano were head and shoulders our best players (notwithstanding Harry who isn't ours to worry about anymore). And IMO Talau was pretty disappointing considering the hype. What do you think TT is underrated in regards to? Serious question mate, not trying to take the mickey.

Nofa - got our big award despite being a winger and having three or four guys out perform him. Chasing money that he isn’t worth.

Tommy Talau - for his age played well in a beaten side most weeks, good try scoring record playing out of position. When Melbourne want you at that age, you have some upside.