Move Moses to 7 and dominant Play caller?
- Thread starter Eddie
- Start date
Luke Walsh needs a new home. Granted his kicking game is about all he's good for though.
Black_n_White
New member
Brooks is ok…. though I do agree he can go missing, there is also a difference between being invisible and doing your job well, and going missing altogether.
I dont see the need for the swap in jumpers, because although Moses seems to read the game better, they do seem to understand each other well enough for Brooks to play the first receiver role and push the team down the park to Moses' direction, all the while giving Mitchell more time to evaluate the line, and having the pigs work wider of the ruck.
Brooks stats bar his tackling are actually pretty good, which seems to play into the invisible scenario... Melbourne won comps off the back of invisible type playmakers. Brooks just needs to find consistency in his game is all.
I dont see the need for the swap in jumpers, because although Moses seems to read the game better, they do seem to understand each other well enough for Brooks to play the first receiver role and push the team down the park to Moses' direction, all the while giving Mitchell more time to evaluate the line, and having the pigs work wider of the ruck.
Brooks stats bar his tackling are actually pretty good, which seems to play into the invisible scenario... Melbourne won comps off the back of invisible type playmakers. Brooks just needs to find consistency in his game is all.
Brooks needs to take the line on more. His tackling can be better, but it's a damn sight better than last year. There is effort in most tackles he makes now, last year he was shirt grabbing and afraid to put his body on the line.
I think it comes down to the fact that we can't afford to pay them both $700000-$800000 per season.
Agree with most on here that Moses should be the one to throw the dollars at and then have a halves partner that is a workmanlike footballer. Get someone who has a good short and long kicking game and is a good defender
We can't afford to pay both of them the big dollars…...
Agree with most on here that Moses should be the one to throw the dollars at and then have a halves partner that is a workmanlike footballer. Get someone who has a good short and long kicking game and is a good defender
We can't afford to pay both of them the big dollars…...
Byron_Bay_Fan
New member
@Cultured Bogan said:
I assure you this year he has pulled shirts, skirts, sleeves and shorts - like a butterfly without any bite or harm.
Tiger_Watto
New member
Nothing wrong with Luke's contributions… If you are expecting them to be as good as Cronk & Thurston, you have another 3 years to wait.
Luke & Mitchell are a very good Halves combination. Their stats are very similar for the role they are playing and that is a great sign. As a combination based on contribution, they are second to the Hunt/Milford combo.
How much would you pay those two?
Luke & Mitchell are a very good Halves combination. Their stats are very similar for the role they are playing and that is a great sign. As a combination based on contribution, they are second to the Hunt/Milford combo.
How much would you pay those two?
