My reasons to why Moltzen plays 7 for the rest of season:

Geo do you really think that play was sensational? Parra came out of the line and basically made Tim's decision for him. It was a smart little kick but dont get carried away.

This is my problem with the Moltz for HB cheerleaders. Making small achievements out as if they are genius.
 
No…... I do not think it was a sensational play......We scored a well constructed try..did you notice that the 2 plays before where the normal hit right , hit right for the spread to Benji on the left. ....which gave us Lortay's try earlier..caught Parra napping....I'll take that from Moltzen......than the gazzillion poor 4th and 5th tackle options that I've seen from the tigers over the years.....
 
Naaaaaah….It had the perfect amount of side backspin....

Or put it down to one of those times the bounce of the ball favoured the Wests Tigers.....either way-------->Look at the scoreboard
 
Southern I think you need to understand you and I are in the minority. Whilst we both think moltzen is playing well and have no problems with him being 7, we both just don't understand why moltzen is playing the same game as Lui yet he gets praised and lui gets bagged. It mystifys me. I think both you and I are going round in circles trying to explain this point.

For the record I dont care whether its moltzen or Lui at half, as long as they are given a go by the fans. Either are a good option, and neither are a true halfback, but if it works for the team then I have no problem.
 
I have no problems with your reasons, I think they are fine and mostly valid, and moltzen is playing well enough for me to stay there. I wasn't refering to you YOTT, I was more refering to other fans who have refered to Lui as being the worst first grader to wear the tigers jersey (big call considering some of the stinkers we have had), and calling for his sack since he debuted last year.

@southerntiger said:
Yep. Thats what mystifies me. I do know we are in the minority but my perverse nature prevents me from keeping silent on this one.
Click to expand...

I've commented on it a few times but I don't think I have the persistence you have haha.
 
Who's bagging Lui…...

It's a problem and a nice one to have,,,,, cause they're all 5/8th's....

What are you going to do punt Bunji....
 
Not keeping silent is what makes this forum ST. Good work, I'm getting addicted. FYI Im outside on wifi in a Fijian resort (girlfriend asleep) and hope we keep it up :stuck_out_tongue: But you are in Beijing so whos talkin … :laughing:
 
@Geo. said:
Who's bagging Lui…...

It's a problem and a nice one to have,,,,, cause they're all 5/8th's....

What are you going to do punt Bunji....
Click to expand...

A few crazies have called for the man at FB … :exclamation: :question:
 
@Geo. said:
Who's bagging Lui…...

It's a problem and a nice one to have,,,,, cause they're all 5/8th's....

What are you going to do punt Bunji....
Click to expand...

Do you really need to ask? There have been at least 3 different threads calling for his sack or eventuating into that. He is injured anyway so who cares. Its not that I think Lui is a better player than moltzen (I'm more than happy to finally have some depth in the club), its just that I dont like to see players unfairly attacked.
 
hahaha ill wait to see if a lazarus or taumata supporter comes out..they seem to have a few fans who are desperate to see them play ( I can't judge as I havent seen a state cup game this year).
 
@simonthetiger said:
Hmmmmm…...peeps are whackin on about Lui......wtf???

Moltzen on a bad day>Lui.

Its as plain as day.
Click to expand...

Not sure I agree, not sure i disagree either. I think both have played about the same in the 7 in the first few games. Solid (except Lui's defense against the Roosters) but not sensational. Both can be accused of not dominating/organising enough.
 
@Illek said:
@Geo. said:
Who's bagging Lui…...

It's a problem and a nice one to have,,,,, cause they're all 5/8th's....

What are you going to do punt Bunji....

Do you really need to ask? There have been at least 3 different threads calling for his sack or eventuating into that. He is injured anyway so who cares. Its not that I think Lui is a better player than moltzen (I'm more than happy to finally have some depth in the club), its just that I dont like to see players unfairly attacked.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

This topis was not intended as a space to bag any player at all, only to discuss who is the most suitable halfback, and most importantly, why.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 715 (members: 43, guests: 672)
Back
Top