New kick contest rule.change

Don't know about anyone else but I've got no problem with that one.

If there is a contest for the ball in the air, whoever lands back on the ground with the ball gets possession and play on from there.

Saves countless looks by the bunker to determine whether the ball was caught clean or if there is the slightest hint of a knock on somewhere in the contest for the ball.
 
Nero fiddled while Rome burned.The only rule change PVL should be thinking about is getting rid of the 6 again rule and reducing the fatigue factor in the game which is actually leading to lazier and more dangerous tackles imho.
 
Not for me this one. A "knock on" is part of the fundamental rules of Rugby League. Leave the bloody game alone. Whats next? Allow 1 metre forward passes so we don't have the ref stopping the game in the middle of an attacking raid for a "minor" forward pass.
 
No need to change the rule, just let the on field call stand. No bunker interference
This is the truth . Whatever the ref decides is what happened . I will say this though , that possession should be taken in account . Like if you’re not sure who did what and the only way to see is frame by frame, at extremely high pixelation , then whatever ends up with the ball should be given , not so much the benefit of the doubt , , but the initiative .
The only problem with PVLs rule is guys will go up , and deliberately look to manoeuvre the ball in a direction knowing there’s no rules . It will be AFL like .
 
This is the truth . Whatever the ref decides is what happened . I will say this though , that possession should be taken in account . Like if you’re not sure who did what and the only way to see is frame by frame, at extremely high pixelation , then whatever ends up with the ball should be given , not so much the benefit of the doubt , , but the initiative .
The only problem with PVLs rule is guys will go up , and deliberately look to manoeuvre the ball in a direction knowing there’s no rules . It will be AFL like .
I still think players will attempt to catch it clean...only Markymark could pull off a mid air intentional billiards cannon with a footy and have it go backwards into a team mates waiting arms
 
Peter V’landys has conceded that the NRL’s proposed new kick-off rule does not have the support of fans, as coaches prepare to discuss changes for 2027.

Several NRL coaches and players will meet on Monday to discuss the state of the game and any possible rule adaptations for next year.

One that is unlikely to have widespread support is the kick-off rule trialled in dead rubbers at the end of last season, where teams that conceded points had the option on who kicks off.

The idea was heavily driven by Wayne Bennett with the support of V’landys, but was met with criticism from other coaches.

Among the concerns raised included that it could stop late comebacks, given a leading team that concedes can opt to receive the kick-off.

V’landys has not closed the door entirely, but conceded it was not backed heavily by fans, who he often uses as a go-to for any changes.

“I know it’s a polarising one, but what difference was there?” the NRL executive chairman said of last year’s trialled rule compared to the traditional one.

“The teams that wanted to kick off still kicked off and then some decided to receive. It adds a bit of unpredictability. That’s what I like about it.

“But, again, we have to act what the fan wants. And at the moment, there’s not an overwhelming appeal to it.”

Another item confirmed to be on the agenda is whether tries should be pulled back when two players compete for a high ball and both make contact with it.

Sydney Roosters coach Trent Robinson highlighted that point in commentary during the World Cup final when New Zealand were denied a try.

V’landys also gave every indication there would be no repealing of the set-restart rule, after last year’s extension for it to be used across 80m of the field.

That change resulted in a dramatic increase in set restarts at the start of the year, coinciding with record-breaking high margins and points scoring, but it slowed down mid-season.

V’landys went as far as to claim players were “not the truth” with their concerns and confusion over the rule at the start of the finals, before stating days later he would welcome input from players on the matter.

But the NRL boss this week used the set-restart rule as an example of a change that had made the game less predictable and more entertaining.

“The six again, in my view, has brought fatigue into the game, which has sped the game up and brought your great players to the fore,” V’landys said.

“Like your Reece Walshes, your Kalyn Pongas, your Clearys. They’re the entertainers.

“Like it or not, when you’re glued to the TV for 80 minutes you want to be entertained.

“You don’t want to be bored and be able to predict what’s going to happen in the game.”

 
“Like it or not, when you’re glued to the TV for 80 minutes you want to be entertained.

“You don’t want to be bored and be able to predict what’s going to happen in the game.”


Nothing wrong with a tight 80 minute defensive arm wrestle with no inch given either way
 
Back
Top