not a true reflection

[weststigers]

Also based on everything we've seen since Magic Round, Sivo should have been sent off.

It's as bad a high shot as I've seen during that period; even if you consider the silly Coby Hetherington one as not a good baseline for comparison, all the other ones were players were marched were as bad as the Sivo one - very high facial contact, stiff arm, blood drawn from player's face, player removed for and fails HIA.

Now I'm fine if NRL decides the Sivo contact is sin-bin and not send-off, but that's not how they've been reffing it the past month.


Sivo is facing suspension (MRC) for his grub act as he should be.Brooks and Amone getting fines only.

Isaiah Papali'i (Parramatta Eels) Grade 1 Contrary Conduct $1,150 fine.

Now that is a joke, right. Drop your full weight via your knee on a player's head (Lucy) and all you get is a fine. Absolute joke.

I think the Forum could take up a collection of $2300.00 and next time we play them - get someone to drop their knee on the "Tanker" and a knee on "the King of Crap."

The punishments don't fit the crimes do they?

Players suspended for high tackles that aren't intentional, yet a blatant and deliberate knee drop to the face gets a $1,000 fine. Crazy...

Definitely deserved a send off - Sivo deserved one too.

 

[MarySt]

I stopped watching as soon as blore got sent to the bin

Just watched our last 10 minutes now because I wanted to see the amone/RCG altercation


I gotta say.. we tried hard.. probably too hard, but we kept up the fight. And I can't take anything away from the team that stepped on the field for that

Sure they had some blunders, but I'm proud of the effort

Does effort = finals? Not always, I just hope they stay in it. They can still afford a couple of losses.. but need to have at least 14 wins this season.. prob more, so that means 8 of their final 10.........

(No small feat ha)

 

[happy_tiger]

Take out Little Walters and Seyfarth and the sin binning and we were in it up to our eyeballs

A bet a heap of teams watched Seyfarth getting caught out around the ruck because his lack of lateral speed

You don’t rate Seyfarth?

You watched the same game yesterday .....he gets caught out really badly twice yesterday and Parra score ..he has improved a heap ....but being slow around the ruck and laterally is going to be his downfall ..especially against top quality opposition

 

[Fraze23]

This thread has not aged well

 

[BAGNF05]

Can we blame the refs this week too

 

[WT2K]

Can we blame the refs this week too

#refsfault

 

[TheDaBoss]

true reflection

 

[Saturnalia]

dudded by Atkins, Mikaele and M'Bye out, Roberts out of position, and Laurie not at his best. not entirely worried after this performance, we'll be ok.

P.S. Adam Doueihi, find your shoulders son.

How so?

This team scraped a win against the Panthers reserves side, and then they got showed up by a an actual NRL side.

I don't ever get tired of being wrong.

 

[gallagher]

I thought last week was a true reflection, how wrong was I?