NRL best 17 players
- Thread starter happy_tiger
- Start date
gold_on_black
New member
1\. Slater
2\. Uate
3\. Inglis
4\. Lawrence
5\. Vatuvei
6\. Marshall
7\. Thurston
8\. Scott
9\. Smith
10\. Civoneciva
11\. Blair
12\. Ellis
13\. Gallen
14\. Lewis
15\. G Stewart
16\. Thaiday
17\. Moi Moi
My list is based on every player playing to their potential
-I think that hodges has an edge in attack over lawrence but lawrence kills him in defence
-Moi Moi is about as devestating as they come when you look at an inform prop
- Lewis is a fantastic player and i would have him on the bench even if i didnt choose him as my utility
2\. Uate
3\. Inglis
4\. Lawrence
5\. Vatuvei
6\. Marshall
7\. Thurston
8\. Scott
9\. Smith
10\. Civoneciva
11\. Blair
12\. Ellis
13\. Gallen
14\. Lewis
15\. G Stewart
16\. Thaiday
17\. Moi Moi
My list is based on every player playing to their potential
-I think that hodges has an edge in attack over lawrence but lawrence kills him in defence
-Moi Moi is about as devestating as they come when you look at an inform prop
- Lewis is a fantastic player and i would have him on the bench even if i didnt choose him as my utility
B
blocka
Guest
1\. Moltzen
2\. Tuqiri
3\. Lawrence
4\. Reddy
5\. Ryan
6\. Marshall
7\. Miller
8\. Galloway
9\. Farah
10\. Woods
11\. Ellis
12\. Blair
13\. Heinington
14\. Groat
15\. Fulton
16\. Murdoch masila
17\. Ayshford
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
2\. Tuqiri
3\. Lawrence
4\. Reddy
5\. Ryan
6\. Marshall
7\. Miller
8\. Galloway
9\. Farah
10\. Woods
11\. Ellis
12\. Blair
13\. Heinington
14\. Groat
15\. Fulton
16\. Murdoch masila
17\. Ayshford
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
innsaneink
Well-known member
17 ayshford - no no no no no
1\. Slater
2\. Yow Yeh
3\. Hodges
4\. Lawrence
5\. Uate
6\. Marshall
7\. Thurston
13\. Gallen
12\. Watmough
11\. Ellis
10\. Civinoceva
9\. Smith
8\. Scott
14\. Hannant
15\. Blair
16\. Thaiday
17\. G. Stewart
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
2\. Yow Yeh
3\. Hodges
4\. Lawrence
5\. Uate
6\. Marshall
7\. Thurston
13\. Gallen
12\. Watmough
11\. Ellis
10\. Civinoceva
9\. Smith
8\. Scott
14\. Hannant
15\. Blair
16\. Thaiday
17\. G. Stewart
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@Cultured Bogan said:
CB you rate Hodges more highly than Inglis ?? Especially with all Hodges hamstring issues
@happy tiger said:
I can't give Inglis the nod over either Hodges or Lawrence this year. He's been shown up a little since he had poor service from his halves for a large part of the season, plus he was injured also.
W
weststigercraig
Guest
1\. Slater
2\. Uate
3\. Inglis
4\. Lawrence
5\. Vatuvei
6\. Marshall
7\. Thurston
8\. Scott
9\. Smith
10\. Galloway
11\. Blair
12\. Ellis
13\. Gallen
14\. Thaiday
15\. Watmough
16\. Civoniceva
17\. Moimoi
2\. Uate
3\. Inglis
4\. Lawrence
5\. Vatuvei
6\. Marshall
7\. Thurston
8\. Scott
9\. Smith
10\. Galloway
11\. Blair
12\. Ellis
13\. Gallen
14\. Thaiday
15\. Watmough
16\. Civoniceva
17\. Moimoi
tig_prmz
Well-known member
1\. Slater
2\. Uate
3\. Inglis
4\. Hodges
5\. Yow- Yeh
6\. Benj
7\. Thurston/ Cronk (can't split em)
8\. Scott
9\. Smith ©
10\. Moi Moi
11\. Ellis
12\. Thaiday
13\. Gallen
14\. Luke Lewis
15\. Galloway
16\. Matulino
17\. G. Stewart
2\. Uate
3\. Inglis
4\. Hodges
5\. Yow- Yeh
6\. Benj
7\. Thurston/ Cronk (can't split em)
8\. Scott
9\. Smith ©
10\. Moi Moi
11\. Ellis
12\. Thaiday
13\. Gallen
14\. Luke Lewis
15\. Galloway
16\. Matulino
17\. G. Stewart
J
Jimmy_Cage
Guest
1.Billy Slater
2.Jharal Yow Yeh
3.Chris Lawrence
4.Benji Marshall
5.Manu Vatuvai
6.Keiran Foran
7.Daly Cherry-Evans
8.Matt Scott
9.Cam Smith
10.Paul Gallen
11.Gareth Ellis
12.Feleti Mateo
13.Glenn Stewart
-
14.FuiFui MoiMoi
15.Sam Thaiday
16.Anthony Watmough
17.Sam Burgess
To Be Honest Hodges is past his best there is better options
2.Jharal Yow Yeh
3.Chris Lawrence
4.Benji Marshall
5.Manu Vatuvai
6.Keiran Foran
7.Daly Cherry-Evans
8.Matt Scott
9.Cam Smith
10.Paul Gallen
11.Gareth Ellis
12.Feleti Mateo
13.Glenn Stewart
-
14.FuiFui MoiMoi
15.Sam Thaiday
16.Anthony Watmough
17.Sam Burgess
To Be Honest Hodges is past his best there is better options
Alf_Duguid
New member
1\. Carney
2\. Ryan
3\. Best
4\. Lewis Brown
5\. Plowman
6\. Seymour
7\. Sandow
8\. Laurie
9\. Watts
10\. Fifita
11\. Gower
12\. Peats
13\. Tongue
14\. Carlaw
15\. Anasta
16\. Mannah
17\. Sutton
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
2\. Ryan
3\. Best
4\. Lewis Brown
5\. Plowman
6\. Seymour
7\. Sandow
8\. Laurie
9\. Watts
10\. Fifita
11\. Gower
12\. Peats
13\. Tongue
14\. Carlaw
15\. Anasta
16\. Mannah
17\. Sutton
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Fraze23
Well-known member
1\. Slater - I can't speak for everyone, but this bloke is the best fullback I have ever seen and most likely ever will see.
2\. Yow Yeh - Since playing for Australia and Queensland he's improved out of sight, big, strong can leap a mile in the air, will be one of the best outside backs in the game.
3\. Inglis - Pretty well picks himself.
4\. Lawrence - Had an unfortunate year, without the injury you can only think what if…
5\. Uate - Continues to improve, I'd hate to have to tackle him.
6\. Marshall - You guys know Benji.
7\. Thurston - I think next years state of origin series and how he handles life without Lockyer will define how great Thurston will be in the game.
13\. Gallen - I like Gallen at lock, not front row. To me its a waste picking him in the front row. He plays the exact same game regardless of what number he has on his back, so to me it makes sense to have him in the 13 jumper and have 2 props out there as well.
12\. Lewis - One of my favourite players, plays hard but fair and always gives 100%. Would love to have him in the backrow with Ellis and Blair.
11\. Ellis - IMO one of the greatest players to pull on the Wests Tigers jersey. My generations Paul Sironen.
10\. Blair - Out of position, but you make room for the best. Looking forward to having him in tigers colours.
9\. Smith - Its hard to admit this but he is better than Robbie...
8\. Scott - Where did this bloke come from? I'm not sure how or when he came into the scene but i can't remember a rep side being picked without him being in it.
14\. Farah - How could you not have him in your side? The utility always comes on to play hooker anyways so it just makes sense.
15\. Matulino - One of the best developing forwards in the game.
16\. Williams - Tony that is, i never rated him til seeing him play in the four nations. It'll be interesting to see if he can back it up next year. I wish i was as big as him.
17\. Thaiday - I Too good not to have in the side. I don't like him but gee he can play the game.
2\. Yow Yeh - Since playing for Australia and Queensland he's improved out of sight, big, strong can leap a mile in the air, will be one of the best outside backs in the game.
3\. Inglis - Pretty well picks himself.
4\. Lawrence - Had an unfortunate year, without the injury you can only think what if…
5\. Uate - Continues to improve, I'd hate to have to tackle him.
6\. Marshall - You guys know Benji.
7\. Thurston - I think next years state of origin series and how he handles life without Lockyer will define how great Thurston will be in the game.
13\. Gallen - I like Gallen at lock, not front row. To me its a waste picking him in the front row. He plays the exact same game regardless of what number he has on his back, so to me it makes sense to have him in the 13 jumper and have 2 props out there as well.
12\. Lewis - One of my favourite players, plays hard but fair and always gives 100%. Would love to have him in the backrow with Ellis and Blair.
11\. Ellis - IMO one of the greatest players to pull on the Wests Tigers jersey. My generations Paul Sironen.
10\. Blair - Out of position, but you make room for the best. Looking forward to having him in tigers colours.
9\. Smith - Its hard to admit this but he is better than Robbie...
8\. Scott - Where did this bloke come from? I'm not sure how or when he came into the scene but i can't remember a rep side being picked without him being in it.
14\. Farah - How could you not have him in your side? The utility always comes on to play hooker anyways so it just makes sense.
15\. Matulino - One of the best developing forwards in the game.
16\. Williams - Tony that is, i never rated him til seeing him play in the four nations. It'll be interesting to see if he can back it up next year. I wish i was as big as him.
17\. Thaiday - I Too good not to have in the side. I don't like him but gee he can play the game.
WestsSupporter
New member
1 Slater
2 Uate
3 Inglis
4 Hodges
5 The Beast
6 Benji
7 JT
8 Hannant
9 Cam Smith
10 Matt Scott
11 Ellis
12 Blair
13 Gallen
14 Cronk
15 Mateo
16 Fuifui
17 Galloway
2 Uate
3 Inglis
4 Hodges
5 The Beast
6 Benji
7 JT
8 Hannant
9 Cam Smith
10 Matt Scott
11 Ellis
12 Blair
13 Gallen
14 Cronk
15 Mateo
16 Fuifui
17 Galloway
Tiger_Watto
New member
LMAO…. Moi Moi - The guy can only play in 10 minute bursts!!!
@Alf Duguid said:
I see what you did there.
1 - Slater
2 - Yow Yeh
3 - Ingliss
4 - Lawrence
5 - Uate
6 - Marshall
7 - Thurston
8 - Scott
9 - Smith
10 - Petro
11 - Ellis
12 - Watmough
13 - Gallen
14 - Cronk
15 - Thaiday
16 - Burgess
17 - Blair
Unbelievably cant find a spot for Lewis who deserves to be there. If we were just talking about 2011, Ellis would make way for him. Overall though Gareth is the superior player.
2 - Yow Yeh
3 - Ingliss
4 - Lawrence
5 - Uate
6 - Marshall
7 - Thurston
8 - Scott
9 - Smith
10 - Petro
11 - Ellis
12 - Watmough
13 - Gallen
14 - Cronk
15 - Thaiday
16 - Burgess
17 - Blair
Unbelievably cant find a spot for Lewis who deserves to be there. If we were just talking about 2011, Ellis would make way for him. Overall though Gareth is the superior player.
happy_tiger
Well-known member
@stryker said:
I suppose we could of put the Qld side in but that would of been a bit biased (However true)
Staff online
-
DempsModerator