NRLW to get its first Transgender player next season -Updated

stryker 69 said:
I was questioning your statement of suicide?
Click to expand...
Yeh it was mentioned earlier by someone, your post was misinterpreted, that's the trouble with texts and emails, you can read it differently to what you mean.
All good mate.
 
stryker 69 said:
Kill themselves because they can’t play against women?
They are biologically men. If they want to play, there’s a comp for them.
Click to expand...
Idk if they are suicidal over that, but a lot definitely are over lack of acceptance in society and that’s a problem. Sadly most people are more outraged over a few playing sport and what sort of unfair advantage that creates. That issue is more important than people wiping themselves out because society thinks they are freaks.
 
How does it work in the change rooms, how does it work now in society with public toilets and change rooms?
Is there a chance a man dressed like a women can walk into a ladies toilet.
I'm not having a go at transexuals but I wouldn't like a man in my wife's, daughter's or grandchildrens change rooms or toilets.
 
GNR4LIFE said:
Idk if they are suicidal over that, but a lot definitely are over lack of acceptance in society and that’s a problem. Sadly most people are more outraged over a few playing sport and what sort of unfair advantage that creates. That issue is more important than people wiping themselves out because society thinks they are freaks.
Click to expand...
Not outrage, but it is a matter of fairness. If the floodgates open, and they are beginning to, womens sport will cease to exist as it does now. MTF transgender athletes are smashing women, not because they are more talented, but because they have male biology.
 
Cobarcats said:
How does it work in the change rooms, how does it work now in society with public toilets and change rooms?
Is there a chance a man dressed like a women can walk into a ladies toilet.
I'm not having a go at transexuals but I wouldn't like a man in my wife's, daughter's or grandchildrens change rooms or toilets.
Click to expand...
I believe they are transgender because they identify as female. I suspect they are more comfortable in a female change room for safety and privacy not for any other reason. I’ve seen a shift to gender neutral bathrooms now in public buildings. I think the change is here to stay.
 
Cobarcats said:
How does it work in the change rooms, how does it work now in society with public toilets and change rooms?
Is there a chance a man dressed like a women can walk into a ladies toilet.
I'm not having a go at transexuals but I wouldn't like a man in my wife's, daughter's or grandchildrens change rooms or toilets.
Click to expand...
Already happening
 
stryker 69 said:
Not outrage, but it is a matter of fairness. If the floodgates open, and they are beginning to, womens sport will cease to exist as it does now. MTF transgender athletes are smashing women, not because they are more talented, but because they have male biology.
Click to expand...
That may be true. But it’s not the most important issue when it comes to transgenders
 
My observations are that there is as much of a body mass difference in NRLW as there is in the NRL. Those girls don’t miss when they hit up and I wouldn’t want to be on the end some of those tackles. I think if there is a transgender player in the NRLW, it wouldn’t be such a mismatch. There clearly needs to be rules and they need to be applied objectively. It’s a bias and perception thing to get over and unless you make space for it and see how it plays out you won’t ever know. I have a feeling some of those girls would want to rip in and muscle up.
 
stryker 69 said:
Already happening
Click to expand...
Are you serious.
There is a guy who has tatts and looks like Steve Blocker Roach who puts on make-up and wears a skirt who frequents our local shops. His voice is deep.
Does that quality him as a transexual and use of female toilets? Where is the qualifying point.?
 
About 5 years ago I had the pleasure of playing golf in the Ladies pro am at Moss Vale,included amongst the LPGA players was a transgender player by the name of Mianne Bragger,she/he was pleasant and well spoken ..I had a conversation with the lady pro from our group and she said that it took a lot to accept he/she on the tour..
she didnt seem to out play the ladies and some of the female players out drove and out played her...just saying that in some sports the ladies can hold their own,however in my opinion trans sport players should be in a comp on their own...
Womens sport is for women...
Male sport is for men...
Trans sport is for trans....
just my opinion because there is only 2 genders as created by God...Male or Female...
 
TrueTiger said:
About 5 years ago I had the pleasure of playing golf in the Ladies pro am at Moss Vale,included amongst the LPGA players was a transgender player by the name of Mianne Bragger,she/he was pleasant and well spoken ..I had a conversation with the lady pro from our group and she said that it took a lot to accept he/she on the tour..
she didnt seem to out play the ladies and some of the female players out drove and out played her...just saying that in some sports the ladies can hold their own,however in my opinion trans sport players should be in a comp on their own...
Womens sport is for women...
Male sport is for men...
Trans sport is for trans....
just my opinion because there is only 2 genders as created by God...Male or Female...
Click to expand...
Respect for your opinion and not having a go at your faith, but as much as there is a question on whether there are really only two genders, is the question of whether there really is a God.
 
stryker 69 said:
Not outrage, but it is a matter of fairness. If the floodgates open, and they are beginning to, womens sport will cease to exist as it does now. MTF transgender athletes are smashing women, not because they are more talented, but because they have male biology.
Click to expand...
What if a big forward, say Papali, decides to be transgender and play in the womens NRL?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 870 (members: 2, guests: 868)
Back
Top