One home ground

[gallagher]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.

I take your point on crowd averages in the 50s. Doesnt apply to CSS though.

 

[Tiger5150]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

 

[cochise]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.

I take your point on crowd averages in the 50s. Doesnt apply to CSS though.

Comp wide crowd ave in 1987 was 9502 so would have had some impact.

 

[Tiger5150]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.

Eaxctly and clearly misleading (probably intentionally). This thread is 50 pages long, there is clearly a logical argument for one home ground (its not my preference) but this article is complete rubbish and does not support that argument.

 

[gallagher]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.

 

[diedpretty]

Newcastles home ground is in the middle of suburbia - no trendy cafes, no entertainment centres, no public transport hub - only Maccas and Hungry Jacks nearby and yet they rank 4th - sort of makes a mockery of NRL Economist.

 

[Tiger5150]

Very true @Tiger5150 , also the only stats used for Bankwest are going to be high crowd number as they've been going well and played big match-ups.
I get where this is coming from but as previously mentioned, stats can be used to get particular outcomes if you work them favourably.


The average crowd figure for Bankwest is ONLY for the first year. Bankwest is averaging 9880 for this year.

I saw that...Out of curiosity are there any covid restrictions for attendance atm???

I dont think so, mightbe wrong

 

[Tiger5150]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.

I take your point on crowd averages in the 50s. Doesnt apply to CSS though.

So you are picking which eras you choose from?

Wests Tigers average 12543 at CSS since inception, 13092 since we started using 3 or 4 grounds.

 

[Tiger5150]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.

If I use more simple words would you be able to string together an honest sensible argument or would you keep obfuscating when it doesnt suit?

 

[gallagher]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.


If I use more simple words would you be able to string together an honest sensible argument or would you keep obfuscating when it doesnt suit?

It would help.

 

[dazza65]

Typical example of the famous saying:
“Lies, damned lies, and statistics" particularly in the use of statistics to bolster weak arguments or to advance a particular agenda...... NRL Economist is employed by Manly, Brookie doesn’t rate a mention , nuff said.

 

[Tiger5150]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.


If I use more simple words would you be able to string together an honest sensible argument or would you keep obfuscating when it doesnt suit?

It would help.

Not you I dont think, jog on and let the grown ups talk.

 

[gallagher]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.


If I use more simple words would you be able to string together an honest sensible argument or would you keep obfuscating when it doesnt suit?

It would help.


Not you I dont think, jog on and let the grown ups talk.

werent you the sooky lala whinging a few weeks go about me making things personal? Have a look at your posts Mr adult.

 

[gallagher]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.


Eaxctly and clearly misleading (probably intentionally). This thread is 50 pages long, there is clearly a logical argument for one home ground (its not my preference) but this article is complete rubbish and does not support that argument.

*exactly

 

[cochise]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.


Eaxctly and clearly misleading (probably intentionally). This thread is 50 pages long, there is clearly a logical argument for one home ground (its not my preference) but this article is complete rubbish and does not support that argument.

I actually support the one home ground argument. That article was just poorly written.

 

[Tiger5150]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.


If I use more simple words would you be able to string together an honest sensible argument or would you keep obfuscating when it doesnt suit?

It would help.


Not you I dont think, jog on and let the grown ups talk.

werent you the sooky lala whinging a few weeks go about me making things personal? Have a look at your posts Mr adult.

Nothing personal champ. I showed mathematically why the article is complete rubbish, you challenged it, I asked you to show why you are right, you couldnt. Conversation is over, its done.

You want to now have a crack at the words I use, instead of making your case, we are clearly done. If you have nothing to add with respect to backing up proving the article is correct, I have no motivation to continue a discussion with you.

Couldnt be more simple or less personal.

Edit.....very grown up pulling up spelling errors. Further proof.

 

[gallagher]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.


"***Wests Tigers** must move from Leichhardt Oval and Campbelltown*"

is the name of the article, that may give you a clue.......more pointless obfuscation because it doesnt match your agenda. Clearly you are incapable of having an actual discussion about something, so I'll allow you to jog on and Ill chat with the grown ups.

I like your word of the day.


If I use more simple words would you be able to string together an honest sensible argument or would you keep obfuscating when it doesnt suit?

It would help.


Not you I dont think, jog on and let the grown ups talk.

werent you the sooky lala whinging a few weeks go about me making things personal? Have a look at your posts Mr adult.


Nothing personal champ. I showed mathematically why the article is complete rubbish, you challenged it, I asked you to show why you are right, you couldnt. Conversation is over, its done.

You want to now have a crack at the words I use, instead of making your case, we are clearly done. If you have nothing to add with respect to backing up proving the article is correct, I have no motivation to continue a discussion with you.

Couldnt be more simple or less personal.

You said all that last time too. But you always come back wanting to chat.

 

[Elderslie_Tiger]

Newcastles home ground is in the middle of suburbia - no trendy cafes, no entertainment centres, no public transport hub - only Maccas and Hungry Jacks nearby and yet they rank 4th - sort of makes a mockery of NRL Economist.

One team town strikes again

 

[BalmainJnr]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.


Eaxctly and clearly misleading (probably intentionally). This thread is 50 pages long, there is clearly a logical argument for one home ground (its not my preference) but this article is complete rubbish and does not support that argument.

I actually support the one home ground argument. That article was just poorly written.

If we ever move I am still keeping my seats.

 

[cochise]

The numbers don’t lie.


NOt knocking you Lauren, but that article is complete rubbish. They make a big deal of taking out semis, rep games and COVID as if it is levelling the playing field, but make no mention of the fact that WT play all the out of town/low crowd teams (Cant explain Souffs this year) at LO & CSS.

Based on this report if we played ALL of our games at LO we would be a better drawing ground than Shark Park, Win, Kogarah & Brooky.

Ramy works for Manly so you caaarn't mention Brookvale..

Anyway..Liverpool has a good case for a Stadium..NRL wants hubs..more people more catchment..

Could V'landys convince Gladys..

Liverpool will be a disaster

I don't think so

Don't even mention Liverpool. That REALLY scares them.


Can you explain to me what those stats prove again?

That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds.

Not for Wests Tigers.


Wests Tigers average 12882 at LO so LO is better than Parra Stadium, SFS, GIO, Brooky, Kogarah, Shark Park, Belmore & Penrith, by your logic. Is that what you are trying to say with your "unfobbable" stats?

Well if we're just talking wests tigers then LO is worse than Homebush. So let's play there.


Thats an entirely different conversation, which has some merit obviously, but that is not what you said.

I was asked about the stats in the article. I gave my opinion on that article. You then provided your own stats on wests tigers games only, which brings Homebush into the conversation.


Actually I asked what those stats prove and you said that "That LO and CSS are the worst grounds for getting crowds."

I have clearly shown that the stats dont prove that, so you obfuscate.

for west tigers games. I didnt mention west tigers.


What was the article about? More obfuscation.

it was about shit footy fields.

But the data it used to support that claim was misleading.


Eaxctly and clearly misleading (probably intentionally). This thread is 50 pages long, there is clearly a logical argument for one home ground (its not my preference) but this article is complete rubbish and does not support that argument.

I actually support the one home ground argument. That article was just poorly written.

If we ever move I am still keeping my seats.

Me too