PETITION LINK External Review

Status
Not open for further replies.
Magpie_Magic said:
Fair enough your opinion.

But your petition is worded to include your biases.

As for accountability which successful club board answers to their customers in this way?

Canterbury may have a model which may appeal to you but it hasn't done them any good.
Click to expand...
Which personal biases have been included?
 
Magpie_Magic said:
Most fans wouldn't want this Hobbo.
Click to expand...

Not sure if you’re trolling but who do you think make up the majority of the WT fan base demographic? Rusted on pre merge fans longing for the glory days balmain gave them and hanging on to memory’s of their dads taking them to Lidcombe oval or a group that has got on Wests tigers over the last 20 years? I’d say the majority want success at all costs.
 
cochise said:
I wouldn't like a situation where members or fans vote for the board, I do believe a situation where there are rigorous criteria around selection of board member and separation of board members between Ashfield and the Tigers would be beneficial as that would give the Wests Tigers Board someone to be accountable to.

Again these thoughts are my personal opinion.
Click to expand...
Their might be some merit in this.

But wouldn't help our on field performances any quicker.

He had a plan till Cleary threw us under the bus. Being connected to Pascoe that probably shoudve meant he went with him but now thefe is a new plan in place we have to go with it.
 
Magpie_Magic said:
Don't like your petition.

What is independent anyway?

Why would the owners allow customers to call a review of their business.? If you don't like what is served up go elsewhere.

Board members are appointed at the discretion of the owners.

Isn't it done that way at your business?

We hired Brian Smith to conduct a review when this current ownership structure came into being.

Canterbury and St George Illawarra recently appointed Gus to conduct reviews and they are fighting it out for the Spoon with us.

Sounds like certain Balmain supporters looking to squeeze out the Magpies out of the JV hidden behind a facade of poor on field performances.

Many may wish to sign your petition with a misguided perception it will improve performance but it's really just a Trojan introduced by a certain Balmain faction to usher in subtle identity change.

Obviously, this forum is a tool for this project.

Most fans don't wish for this change.

You don't speak for them.
Click to expand...

I think you nailed the owners view here.

" If you don't like what is served up go elsewhere"
 
Magpie_Magic said:
Their might be some merit in this.

But wouldn't help our on field performances any quicker.

He had a plan till Cleary threw us under the bus. Being connected to Pascoe that probably shoudve meant he went with him but now thefe is a new plan in place we have to go with it.
Click to expand...
Except we undermined that plan, when we appointed a new head of recruitment without consulting the person we brought in to run the football side of the club.
 
Continue to accept the current situation without agitating for some accountability will only weaken the clubs strength/standing within the NRL.
Losing clubs do not generate more fans and if we don't generate fans we will become obsolete and those still hanging on to Magpies and or Balmain dominance will go down with them.
 
BAGNF05 said:
There have been far too many “he can’t survive this” moments in Justin Pascoe’s reign of losses, but he always does. Vote for a review which might finally uncover why there is a lack of accountability at our club. Whether you hated any of the below or not, don’t you wonder why he’s so bulletproof?

• Farah salary cap penalty
• Big 3 fiasco
• Matterson walks
• Aloiai walks
• Cleary walks
• Tiger town documentary
• Benji’s disrespectful farewell
• Fulton appointment
• Transit lounge of poor performing senior players e.g. Leilua’s
• Brooks million dollar contract
• Noffa’s inflated contract
• Inability to sign marquee players
• 2022 wooden spoon
• mid year NT trip at 0-5
• 0-7 the year after
• JAC released and his return butchered
• Not one halfback on the books for 2024
• Players who sign here only to get injured and not contribute (Ballin, Packer, Reynolds, Doueihi, Jet, Naden etc.)
• Anzac disrespect

Above all else, it’s never his fault. It’s an endless game of blame someone else.
Click to expand...

Tommy round debacle has to be on him too.

That wasn’t football specific and he had inspector gadget hand brooks a wests tigers jersey off a plastic garden chair.
 
BAGNF05 said:
There have been far too many “he can’t survive this” moments in Justin Pascoe’s reign of losses, but he always does. Vote for a review which might finally uncover why there is a lack of accountability at our club. Whether you hated any of the below or not, don’t you wonder why he’s so bulletproof?

• Farah salary cap penalty
• Big 3 fiasco
• Matterson walks
• Aloiai walks
• Cleary walks
• Tiger town documentary
• Benji’s disrespectful farewell
• Fulton appointment
• Transit lounge of poor performing senior players e.g. Leilua’s
• Brooks million dollar contract
• Noffa’s inflated contract
• Inability to sign marquee players
• 2022 wooden spoon
• mid year NT trip at 0-5
• 0-7 the year after
• JAC released and his return butchered
• Not one halfback on the books for 2024
• Players who sign here only to get injured and not contribute (Ballin, Packer, Reynolds, Doueihi, Jet, Naden etc.)
• Anzac disrespect

Above all else, it’s never his fault. It’s an endless game of blame someone else.
Click to expand...
You left off his greatest crime....dat moustache
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 345 (members: 3, guests: 342)
Back
Top