Player ratings against the broncos

W

Westie

Well-known member
I missed tonight's game,I was busy banging my head at the Sabbath concert :righton: :righton:

So I cant make any judgement of the boys..

Can you please rate their form….

Cheers
 
1\. Tedesco - started shaky, finished ok
2\. Reddy[ - Quiet but solid
3\. Ayshford - Ok, Strong hard to tackle - A few bad decisions - Injured, Booooo!
4\. Lawrence - Looked slow out classed & out of sorts - Feel guilty but i was glad when he cam off He's finished
5\. Utai - Strong - Really good tonight, but is a confidence player 1 mistake & he falls apart. Not a solution.
6\. Curtis sironen - Who? Just kidding - Didn't do anything wrong just not involved enough
7\. Moltzen - Was good, has been good all year but looked most comfortable tonight - Tragic injury
8\. Woods - Was good. Manned up (didn't quite dominate though but got the best of thaiday
9\. Farah - Ok - Makes dumb decisions
10\. Buchanan - ok bit soft but not too bad
11\. Fulton - Has lost it completely - Woeful this year. Only in the team to tackle and cant anymore.
12\. Thompson - Too quiet for my liking nothing bad just did not notice him.
13\. Blair - ok -solid but quiet - Dumb penalties
 
Farah…ok?? He was far and away the best we had out there. In fact, i thought it was one of his best games for us. Without him it would have been 50 - 0\. He was light years ahead of anyone that ran out in Tigers colours last night. Blair...?? Solid?????? Huh? Were you there, man? You were watching the same game as me, weren't you??
 
Your kidding farah was ok, he was our best by a mile along with woods the rest are terrible even with Marshall and Galloway we are one terrible looking side, the only positive we never gave up.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Farah and Woods where our best by far.Moltzen and lawrence the worst,the defensive reads by the 2 of them at the begining cost us 8 points
 
I don't know where all this negativity is coming from. The boys played their hearts out tonight. We came into the game with both our halves, our most experienced prop and our dangerous attacking winger missing, and we finished the game with twelve on the field, without both centres and our replacement half. Despite this, it took the Broncos 75 minutes to put us away.

There are some good signs under Potter, and I think our future is very bright. Forwards were good today. Especially Woods and Buchanan. Siro looks more and more like a backrower every time he plays. Played very direct and looks dangerous when he hits the line. Dwyer-esque, I thought

The positives are there, it's just the players aren't.

If there's anything we can improve on though, it's our left side defence. However, I very much doubt Lawrence or Moltzen will be there next week so we'll have to see how our new left side looks.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
11\. Fulton - Has lost it completely - Woeful this year. Only in the team to tackle and cant anymore
\
\
You must have been seriously drunk watching the game. He played about 60 min or less and got through 38 tackles. If he plays for 80 he'd clock up 50 tackles, what more do you want from him?
 
@Frank the tank said:
11\. Fulton - Has lost it completely - Woeful this year. Only in the team to tackle and cant anymore
\
\
You must have been seriously drunk watching the game. He played about 60 min or less and got through 38 tackles. If he plays for 80 he'd clock up 50 tackles, what more do you want from him?
Click to expand...

Be nice if he made some sort of impact to the game and the team.

_Posted using RoarFEED 2013_
 
Farah and Woods had good games again and were the standouts, what concerns me about this is they will both more than likely be missing during state of origin then there will be problems.
 
@Frank the tank said:
11\. Fulton - Has lost it completely - Woeful this year. Only in the team to tackle and cant anymore
\
\
You must have been seriously drunk watching the game. He played about 60 min or less and got through 38 tackles. If he plays for 80 he'd clock up 50 tackles, what more do you want from him?
Click to expand...

Fulton was great. Woods was our best followed by Farah and then I think Fulton & Utai.

I miss Utai's runs. He just belts it up. If he could catch a bomb he would be the best winger in the world.
 
Yeah the boys played with heart…......for the final 25mins,we looked crap from the start crap in the middle and crap at the end bottom line, my ratings differ a bit feel free to give your thoughts im a big boy
Teddy- solid 1st game back in the 1 just needed to get involved threw the back line a bit more- 6.5
Reddy- made a few breaks was solid got involved but as a senior player did bugger all-6.5
Ashford- Until injured was 1 of our best ran hard and defended quite well-7.5
Lawrence-had a shocker blind freddy can see this,needs to get the hip 100% to play again-4
Utai- As usual ran the ball strong defence was his problem solid-6.5
Sironen- the next big thing ??? did he play last night this kid is not up to 1st grade yet-3
Moltzen- Solid but lets get serious here he is a utility not a halfback, until injured 5
Buch- ran it up all night that was it from him-6
Farah- without him it would have been 50 plus-9
Woods- nothing great from him was needing back up from the other forwards,didnt get it-7
Blair- 1
Thompson- where was the aggression BO, very quite game-5
 
@Frank the tank said:
11\. Fulton - Has lost it completely - Woeful this year. Only in the team to tackle and cant anymore
\
\
You must have been seriously drunk watching the game. He played about 60 min or less and got through 38 tackles. If he plays for 80 he'd clock up 50 tackles, what more do you want from him?
Click to expand...

I dont care how many second or third man in tackles he makes. I care about the ones he misses and the fact that they have been running around him like an old man standing still all year. not the sam player as the last few years. Luckily he has a brand new three year deal!
 
@Frank the tank said:
11\. Fulton - Has lost it completely - Woeful this year. Only in the team to tackle and cant anymore
\
\
You must have been seriously drunk watching the game. He played about 60 min or less and got through 38 tackles. If he plays for 80 he'd clock up 50 tackles, what more do you want from him?
Click to expand...

I dont care how many second or third man in tackles he makes. I care about the ones he misses and the fact that they have been running around him like an old man standing still all year. not the sam player as the last few years. Luckily he has a brand new three year deal!
 
whatever you do,don't watch a replay.
totally inept performance on every level.
\
\
tigers should be fined for allowing the broncos to get 2 points.
they were crap as well.

horrible display by pro athletes.
 
Also the young guns Sue & Spence had a dig.
Few good touches and seized the opportunity.
 
Wests Tigers played the first half as if they all had an inferiority complex. Why can't Potter fire them up during the week and before they run out for the match?
 
Didnt you watch us play manly or storm? 6 all at the half against storm and 4-0 down vs manly. Solid effort against top 4 sides in the first 40.

But the last two weeks its been the opposite, probably takes them longer to get into a good rythym since theres no gelling in the halves and back line.
 
I thought playing at C/Town would have had them all fired up, score early and have the crowd on your side. Maybe they thought they only need to win one half, not sure. Dissapointing night all round with the injuries.
 
First half was a disaster except for the try we managed to get but then Moltz i thought missed an easy conversion attempt (But then again Prince missed 2 and Parker 1 as well)

Moltz was the worst player on the field followed closely by CL and a few others.

Teddy was playing on ice first few touches, sliding and falling all over the place but he did well later.
Fulton was a tackling machine when he came on, bit like Thompson when he played against storm.

my points went to Farah, Woods, Utai, Fulton. Everyone was ok at the best.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 609 (members: 38, guests: 571)
Back
Top