Positives

@sideline eye said:
You'd seriously replace our captain who is also the NSW hooker and captain with a kid who is only just out of U20s and had his first grade debut last night? Just how bad do you want things to get here? Well, I can only say that I'm glad you two aren't coaching us.

I think we need some more spark out there and there is no reason not to give Cherrington a run for some time during every game.

I didn't mean to sack Farah and play Cherrington.

@sideline eye said:
There is very little maturity shown with calls like SACK TAYLOR NOW or BLAME THE CEO!

I disagree with this. JT has been terrible and the calls to sack him make a lot of sense. I think at this point we have to keep him but its a bad situation to be in.
 
@Geo. said:
Ok now for the game…watched it again

Lawrence was great in the back row...ran hard..tackled well and sat Dave Taylor one on one on his arse a couple of times....bagged a double...

Tedesco had his best attacking game in a while...looked dangerous in the opposition 20...scored a great TRY...

Moses is all heart.......did some really good things..the quick tap...earned our only repeat set...his passing was a lot better than it has been...the kid wants to win..

Cherrington was sharp on debut and should retain his spot whist ever Faff isn't there and even then should keep it as well..

Woods was massive as usual...

Taupau Sue and Ava need more minutes...we rolled upfield much better when these guys were on....

I honestly think this team needs a win and with that can go on a bit of a run...

Pretty well spot on, Geo, but I don't know where the win that you speak of is going to come from. It must be just so disheartening for the boys to have so many promising attacking raids fall agonisingly short of the try line or last passes go astray all the time! I know it nearly kills me, so it has to be affecting their confidence a bit. And this was against the Titans also, who are not really known as a particularly good defensive team.
 
@Love the WestsTigers said:
I know this thread is about positives BUT Don should have never been allowed to score that try.
It was the most disgraceful defense considering what was at stake for us.

If david kidwell doesnt address that then he should be punted

That try was diabolical. At one point Brooks and Tedesco had Don against the touch line and he stepped inside both of them. What the hell is up with that?
 
@diedpretty said:
@sideline eye said:
The second half is the way that they are being coached to play. When the team does this they are fairly formidable and will be even better when we get our full first grade side on the field, although the youngsters , I thought, were pretty good tonight. Cherrington is clearly up to first grade standard and I can see him rotating with Robbie from next year. Milone did a good job as a last minute replacement and the defence of our halves continues to improve with Moses defending James really well.

We didn't lose this game in the forwards, rather it was the left side defence in the first half. I see good things ahead and I'll be patient but I do expect finals football next year.

I would seriously consider playing Cherrington now. His work around dummy half was impressive and probably better than what Robbie has shown this year. Move Farah to lock - he still gets to defend in the middle and can be another playmaker behind the ruck. Kapow can move back to the edges where he causes more damage and Farah can move in to dummy half when Cherrington needs a rest.

The frightening thing with this assessment is that he's the best NSW has apparently, yet it's now suggested that a kid is possibly a better option at club level.
 
Moses and Brooks are improving one on one in defence. Both made some very good one on one tackles.

Agree re Lawrence. Gee I would love to see him succeed. He is still one of my favourite players (but not at centre).

Well done for starting the positive thread. We will get better…. I hope

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_
 
@wd in perth said:
@diedpretty said:
@sideline eye said:
The second half is the way that they are being coached to play. When the team does this they are fairly formidable and will be even better when we get our full first grade side on the field, although the youngsters , I thought, were pretty good tonight. Cherrington is clearly up to first grade standard and I can see him rotating with Robbie from next year. Milone did a good job as a last minute replacement and the defence of our halves continues to improve with Moses defending James really well.

We didn't lose this game in the forwards, rather it was the left side defence in the first half. I see good things ahead and I'll be patient but I do expect finals football next year.

I would seriously consider playing Cherrington now. His work around dummy half was impressive and probably better than what Robbie has shown this year. Move Farah to lock - he still gets to defend in the middle and can be another playmaker behind the ruck. Kapow can move back to the edges where he causes more damage and Farah can move in to dummy half when Cherrington needs a rest.

The frightening thing with this assessment is that he's the best NSW has apparently, yet it's now suggested that a kid is possibly a better option at club level.

He may be the best that NSW has ( and even that is debatable on form this year ) but he sure aint doing it for the Tigers this year. As some have said he may be under instructions to allow the halves to take control but from what I have seen this year his dummy half play is nowhere near as crisp and direct as previous years. It does seem as though he is playing to a pattern rather than what he is seeing.
 

Staff online

Back
Top