LIVE GAME Rd 10 NRL Discussion *spoilers*

[TheGreenWookie]

Cows should have put that match away. They could be in trouble, next 10 games they might only win 2-3 of them, maybe.
Roosters
Rabbits
Raiders
Phins
Wahs
Panthers
Manly
Phins
Broncos
Roosters

 

[innsaneink]

Ridiculous theyre talking about hip drop penalties being determined by the severity and injury
Ref asked Dearden 3 times if hes staying on...he had to stay on theyd used all their replacements
Theyre suggesting because he stayed on that no penalty was the result

Payten just contradicted what the commentators said ...it was their error not taking dearden off

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Cows should have put that match away. They could be in trouble, next 10 games they might only win 2-3 of them, maybe.
Roosters
Rabbits
Raiders
Phins
Wahs
Panthers
Manly
Phins
Broncos
Roosters

they probably lose all of those

 

[TheGreenWookie]

they probably lose all of those

Maybe Todd does join our coaching roster for '26

 

[Viva_Zapata]

Ridiculous theyre talking about hip drop penalties being determined by the severity and injury
Ref asked Dearden 3 times if hes staying on...he had to stay on theyd used all their replacements
Theyre suggesting because he stayed on that no penalty was the result

Says he's hurt, goes off free interchange because on report?

 

[innsaneink]

Says he's hurt, goes off free interchange because on report?

Yeah...stayed on because it was so close...dumb move obviously he was a passenger

 

[weststigerman]

What happens in that Parra game if the penalty goal hits the post and Cowboys score?

Parra had the golden point via field goal but technically could have still lost.

I think we found a loophole.

 

[RydeTide]

What happens in that Parra game if the penalty goal hits the post and Cowboys score?

Parra had the golden point via field goal but technically could have still lost.

I think we found a loophole.

Apparently game is over eels have chance add 2 point's

 

[Yossarian]

This makes sense for a field goal in normal time and a foul is committed, but the last part makes no sense for golden point and doesn’t apply (i.e play restarted from halfway)

But the logical extension of that is because it’s GP the game ends once someone is ahead. Play would otherwise start from a kickoff but because of GP it doesn’t. You need to think of it as a single play.

 

[Yossarian]

What happens in that Parra game if the penalty goal hits the post and Cowboys score?

Parra had the golden point via field goal but technically could have still lost.

I think we found a loophole.

Game is over as soon as the kick is unsuccessful

 

[Flippedy]

How very WTs that was cowboys

Right down to losing a milestone match at their home ground!

 

[happy_tiger]

NQ warming in to this game...i think Parra might get lapped

Or not

 

[tig_prmz]

Cowboys robbed.

Poor JT.

 

[innsaneink]

Bizaare game hap...cowboys snatched defeat from the jaws of victory
Keep dropping the ball you pay as we saw last week

 

[Merlot]

Maybe Todd does join our coaching roster for '26

not that rat

 

[TigerLove]

The two howlers from last night make me so frustrated comparing the two incidents that happened to Api.
The recent hip drop and the try from Api last year, where there was the tiniest bit of seperation but he regathered with a solid grounding. It went up as a try but overturned by the bunker after looking at it for 5 minutes.

'As tight a decision as you can get': Annesley backs call to deny Api try

NRL head of football Graham Annesley has confirmed that the Bunker made the right call to disallow a controversial try to Wests Tigers captain Api Koroisau in Saturday night’s loss to Brisbane.

www.nrl.com

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

Mitch Moses is such a Dog!....Anyone else notice how he reacted to the love tap on his big toe when he attempted the match wining field goal?...He went down screaming like a shot duck vying for a penatly, not knowing the field goal went in...Then to justify his actions, when he finally gets up he limps around like a rag doll for the next 5 minutes....

 

[hank37w]

I only like it when he gets rag dolled.

 

[tonza]

Ridiculous theyre talking about hip drop penalties being determined by the severity and injury
Ref asked Dearden 3 times if hes staying on...he had to stay on theyd used all their replacements
Theyre suggesting because he stayed on that no penalty was the result

Hard to fathom isn't it. Last week Radley did not even get penalised yet alone sinbinned for identical tackle to Appy.

 

[TheEnz]

The two howlers from last night make me so frustrated comparing the two incidents that happened to Api.
The recent hip drop and the try from Api last year, where there was the tiniest bit of seperation but he regathered with a solid grounding. It went up as a try but overturned by the bunker after looking at it for 5 minutes.

'As tight a decision as you can get': Annesley backs call to deny Api try

NRL head of football Graham Annesley has confirmed that the Bunker made the right call to disallow a controversial try to Wests Tigers captain Api Koroisau in Saturday night’s loss to Brisbane.

www.nrl.com

I was thinking the same thing about the try...the hip drop to me is probably a bit different to Apis one, however both should have just been penalties due to mitigating circumstances. Going for a try, body twisting other players in the tackle etc..