RL World Cup 2017 Thread...* SPOILERS

I was surprised they even have rugby in Holland, Argentina and other far out countries. RL is 50 years behind, maybe because it was just a working class off shoot that became the majority rugby game in Australia and mostly got spread through Catholicism in the colonies and islands. But RL is not even Australia wide. If USA dedicated some of their top gridiron players to RL they would be world champs - we are lucky in a way it is only a parochial game.
 
@ said:
I was surprised they even have rugby in Holland, Argentina and other far out countries. RL is 50 years behind, maybe because it was just a working class off shoot that became the majority rugby game in Australia and mostly got spread through Catholicism in the colonies and islands. But RL is not even Australia wide. If USA dedicated some of their top gridiron players to RL they would be world champs - we are lucky in a way it is only a parochial game.

The gridiron players would not be able to play - no helmets in RL.

Not sure about the Netherlands =- but Argentina have been playing Rugby Union for years and have a pretty good side.
 
@ said:
@ said:
I was surprised they even have rugby in Holland, Argentina and other far out countries. RL is 50 years behind, maybe because it was just a working class off shoot that became the majority rugby game in Australia and mostly got spread through Catholicism in the colonies and islands. But RL is not even Australia wide. If USA dedicated some of their top gridiron players to RL they would be world champs - we are lucky in a way it is only a parochial game.

The gridiron players would not be able to play - no helmets in RL.

Not sure about the Netherlands =- but Argentina have been playing Rugby Union for years and have a pretty good side.

As one whom got a pretty bad head knock (yes that is what happened to me) in high school RL I think some sort of head protection should be compulsory - like Thurston and Ennis wears.
 
@ said:
@ said:
To grow the international game players need to be encouraged to play for second tier nations.
Fiji, Tonga, Samoa and PNG should face off in a series that coincides with State of Origin.
As for the World Cup maybe there should be 2 separate comps. The main comp with 8 teams with the likes of Australia, England, NZ and determined by international ranking and then a secondary comp. The secondary comp would then showcase some of the nations like USA who lets be honest are there as novelty value.

not a bad idea as does no good these minor teams getting thrashed. The winner of the minor event should have the opportunity to qualify for next World Cup top grade by a play off with the last team in top grade.

Virtually every world cup has a mix of good sides and also rans but only RL fans seem to get worried about it. It's not like Angola have any chance of beating the US or Spain in basketball or Namibia is going to beat NZ or England in union.

I would like to see a tournament for emerging teams such as USA, Serbia, Canada etc
 
@ said:
@ said:
I was surprised they even have rugby in Holland, Argentina and other far out countries. RL is 50 years behind, maybe because it was just a working class off shoot that became the majority rugby game in Australia and mostly got spread through Catholicism in the colonies and islands. But RL is not even Australia wide. If USA dedicated some of their top gridiron players to RL they would be world champs - we are lucky in a way it is only a parochial game.

The gridiron players would not be able to play - no helmets in RL.

Not sure about the Netherlands =- but Argentina have been playing Rugby Union for years and have a pretty good side.

Not just that, very different skillset.

If US had been playing Rugby League for 100 years like us, then yes, they would have a fantastic side and all our best players would play in America.

But NFL players rarely pass backwards (apart from hand offs), then handle a differently shaped ball, they have more players on the field and those players are job-specific, they get breathers between each down, they never have to meet an advancing line, there's no tactical short kicking, no grounding of the ball etc etc

Even the world's best NFL players would get murdered by seasoned rugby league players, but if they spent millions and trained for a few years with the best athletes, then maybe they could get a good national side.
 
@ said:
Realistically, growing the game internationally is a tall stretch… To grow the game in developing nations, there needs to be 2 major changes.

1\. A serious increase in financial commitment from each nations governing body, who in turn receive grants from their own governments.

2\. Development of local/grass-roots football within those countries.

While its a nice gesture that countries like Australia, England & New Zealand support and help these countries, it is not their responsibility and at some stage they need to reduce/limit their involvement if it is going to be truly successful.

**The embarrassing part of all this, is NZRL cant even get a local competition which can match the Q Cup & NSW Cup to ensure internal pathways within their own country.**

Not really an embarrassment, just shows how much of a minor sport RL is in NZ. 500 juniors are taken out of Auckland by Aussie clubs every year (Auckland RL report). Minor sports don't thrive on those numbers.
 
@ said:
@ said:
Realistically, growing the game internationally is a tall stretch… To grow the game in developing nations, there needs to be 2 major changes.

1\. A serious increase in financial commitment from each nations governing body, who in turn receive grants from their own governments.

2\. Development of local/grass-roots football within those countries.

While its a nice gesture that countries like Australia, England & New Zealand support and help these countries, it is not their responsibility and at some stage they need to reduce/limit their involvement if it is going to be truly successful.

**The embarrassing part of all this, is NZRL cant even get a local competition which can match the Q Cup & NSW Cup to ensure internal pathways within their own country.**

Not really an embarrassment, just shows how much of a minor sport RL is in NZ. 500 juniors are taken out of Auckland by Aussie clubs every year (Auckland RL report). Minor sports don't thrive on those numbers.

of course its an embarrassment… Its why your attempting to justify the NZRL piss poor attempt in promoting the game in their country.
 
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater
 
Wests Tigers on World Cup Stage Week 3..

Fiji Bati
Kevin Naiqama
Taane Milne

Italy
Nathan Milone

Tonga
Tuimoala Lolohea

Kiwis
Russell Packer

Lebanon
Alex Twal
Andrew Kazzi
 
@ said:
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater

Cant believe your favourite Winger is playing Fullback :smiley:

That starting Forward Pack looks good. I'd expect that to be the same next week baring injury.
 
@ said:
@ said:
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater

**Cant believe your favourite Winger is playing Fullback** :smiley:

That starting Forward Pack looks good. I'd expect that to be the same next week baring injury.

:unamused:
 
i'm liking watching the Fijian backline at the RLWC.
Fiji
1 Kevin Naiqama ©
2 Suliasi Vunivalu
3 Taane Milne
4 Akuila Uate
5 Marcelo Montoya
6 Jarryd Hayne
7 Henry Raiwalui

V
Italy

1 James Tedesco
2 Mason Cerruto
3 Justin Castellaro
4 Nathan Milone
5 Josh Mantellato
6 Terry Campese
7 Ryan Ghietti
 
@ said:
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater

Why play Holmes (a winger) at fullback, Gagai (a centre) on the wing and Trbojevic (a fullback) at centre? Swap them back to their rightful positions for God's sake!
 
@ said:
@ said:
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater

Why play Holmes (a winger) at fullback, Gagai (a centre) on the wing and Trbojevic (a fullback) at centre? Swap them back to their rightful positions for God's sake!

Any chance Robbie invites them around to Tiger Tiger and they all mysteriously get tummy aches?
 
@ said:
@ said:
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater

Why play Holmes (a winger) at fullback, Gagai (a centre) on the wing and Trbojevic (a fullback) at centre? Swap them back to their rightful positions for God's sake!

Gagai is very good on the wing, just look at how he goes there for Queensland.
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Australia Team to v Lebanon

1 Valentine Holmes
2 Dane Gagai
3 Tom Trbojevic
4 Cameron Munster
5 Joshua Mansour
6 James Maloney
7 Cooper Cronk
8 Aaron Woods
9 Cameron Smith ©
10 David Klemmer
11 Boyd Cordner
12 Matt Gillett
13 Felise Kaufusi
14 Ben Hunt
15 Jordan Mclean
16 Reagan Campbell-Gillard
17 Wade Graham

18 Joshua McGuire
19 Michael Morgan
20 Joshua Dugan
21 Billy Slater

Why play Holmes (a winger) at fullback, Gagai (a centre) on the wing and Trbojevic (a fullback) at centre? Swap them back to their rightful positions for God's sake!

Gagai is very good on the wing, just look at how he goes there for Queensland.

Not to mention playing a half in the centres…

1\. Trbojevic
2\. Holmes
3\. Gagai
4\. Dugan
5\. Mansour
6\. Maloney
7\. Hunt

14\. Munster
 
Good to see justice done with the biting allegation. When will Robbie ever learn? Perhaps he should be charged with bringing the game into disrepute.

England's Jermaine McGillvary labelled allegations of him biting Robbie Farah as outrageous, before being found not guilty by the Rugby League World Cup judiciary.
>
Not even Farah attended the hearing, as it took a panel just three minutes to clear McGillvary's name and left him free to play on Sunday against France.
>
McGillvary turned the tables on Farah, accusing him of grappling and choking him as he fell to the ground early in the second half of England's 29-10 second- round win.
>
Appearing via video link from Perth, McGillvary argued Farah had pressed his forearm against his nose and mouth, forcing him to gasp for air.
>
He then claimed Lebanon hooker Michael Lichaa had also pushed his head down in the tackle, eventually forcing his mouth onto Farah's forearm.
>
http://www.canberratimes.com.au/rugby-league/league-news/england-winger-jermaine-mcgillvary-found-not-guilty-of-robbie-farah-bite-20171108-gzhjxu.html
 

Members online

Back
Top