Robbie Hammers JT

[TieDye]

@GNR4LIFE that’s a fair comment, if that’s all Reddy was doing, he was a former employee of our club and in a week as important as this FOR ALL SUPPORTERS (not just Rob or JT)

The guy who cannot and does not have any kind of resume since become an ex-player shouldn’t be opening his mouth. Surely you jest saying Robbie threw mud... he answered a question truthfully and as I said- given I am on neither side and just hope we get the win, I have an absolutely foul taste in my mouth now with this flog’s comments... did he or did he not also confirm in his article that he thinks a former NSW and Australian player is still a reserve grader?

Interesting view

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Junior Pearce's only attempt at a punch on the field was directed at a certain St George forward who had the reputation of being a biter. Pearce claiming he had been bitten on the hand by this forward.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

@GNR4LIFE that’s a fair comment, if that’s all Reddy was doing, he was a former employee of our club and in a week as important as this FOR ALL SUPPORTERS (not just Rob or JT)

The guy who cannot and does not have any kind of resume since become an ex-player shouldn’t be opening his mouth. Surely you jest saying Robbie threw mud... he answered a question truthfully and as I said- given I am on neither side and just hope we get the win, I have an absolutely foul taste in my mouth now with this flog’s comments... did he or did he not also confirm in his article that he thinks a former NSW and Australian player is still a reserve grader?

Interesting view

None of us have played a game, so by that logic we shouldn't open our mouths either if that's how you want to measure it. You're splitting hairs by saying Farah didn't throw mud because he was asked a question. Who cares. He still chose to go on a rant about an issue this club has well and truly moved on from. He hasn't though, hence his response.

 

[TieDye]

@GNR4LIFE hahaha you are making an extremely poor straw man argument. I believe you’ve called people out on the threat for JT bashing? You cannot be that intelligent 🤓

When did he call a Reddy a shit bloke or infer the real truth that we all know JT and Reddy, along with Grant Mayer rode the place into the dirt? I will never agree with you, Gunner, not on this topic but I at least had respect for your opinion before... now I see how and where it comes from

Just straight dislike of our 300 gamer. You’ll be able to enjoy this weekend, no doubt

 

[GNR4LIFE]

@GNR4LIFE hahaha you are making an extremely poor straw man argument. I believe you’ve called people out on the threat for JT bashing? You cannot be that intelligent 🤓

Not quite. Someone pointed out how boring the Farah bashing was. I said the JT bashing wasn't exactly a new thing. I haven't directly responded to anyone bashing Taylor.

 

[Tiger_Steve]

Is it brain cancer week or ‘idiot explayer week’ First Krilich, now Reddy. Cue stupid, illiterate, nonsensical comment from bouncing brain dead Benny tonight!!

 

[TieDye]

And you believe, in your heart of hearts or even your best mate Taylor’s, that you have both moved on sufficiently?? Let alone the rest of us, JT did things still impacting DRASTICALLY on the club now, you’ll get 99% disagreement if you try to say that isn’t true... however Reddy was simply mentioned as a bit player and being the unemployed attention seeker he has become felt the need to grovel to some of his connections in the media... it doesn’t take a brain surgeon to see how this has played out. What’s the bet Robbie puts his actions out on the field and doesn’t mention any of it going on into the future... what’s the bet us fans still have a strongly, factual and opinion (you) based idea of what went on... and most likely never know the full truth to it, certainly, the likelihood JT never lives his coaching days at WT down. You seem to somehow have all of this inside information and more? I find it extremely hard to take your word at face value now especially after re-reading many of your posts that were attempting to convince us of Woods And Tedesco staying... have realised it’s fine being positive, even fine being a negative nelly

But thinking your own opinion carries more reality or weight than others, on a forum, is really and truly pathetic, GNR. You’ve brought this out of me as I said was never and will not ever take sides just know what’s been put to us by people in damage control and what the real info was coming out of HQ at the time... yes it was coach’s job to rid the club of Farah at the time.

He is no longer here and Ivan has since taken over my vote for the biggest douchebag ever involved with said club. There is literally nothing more for you to say . Nice try tho

 

[GNR4LIFE]

And you believe, in your heart of hearts or even your best mate Taylor’s, that you have both moved on sufficiently?? Let alone the rest of us, JT did things still impacting DRASTICALLY on the club now, you’ll get 99% disagreement if you try to say that isn’t true... however Reddy was simply mentioned as a bit player and being the unemployed attention seeker he has become felt the need to grovel to some of his connections in the media... it doesn’t take a brain surgeon to see how this has played out. What’s the bet Robbie puts his actions out on the field and doesn’t mention any of it going on into the future... what’s the bet us fans still have a strongly, factual and opinion (you) based idea of what went on... and most likely never know the full truth to it, certainly, the likelihood JT never lives his coaching days at WT down. You seem to somehow have all of this inside information and more? I find it extremely hard to take your word at face value now especially after re-reading many of your posts that were attempting to convince us of Woods And Tedesco staying... have realised it’s fine being positive, even fine being a negative nelly

But thinking your own opinion carries more reality or weight than others, on a forum, is really and truly pathetic, GNR. You’ve brought this out of me as I said was never and will not ever take sides just know what’s been put to us by people in damage control and what the real info was coming out of HQ at the time... yes it was coach’s job to rid the club of Farah at the time.

He is no longer here and Ivan has since taken over my vote for the biggest douchebag ever involved with said club. There is literally nothing more for you to say . Nice try tho

That escalated quickly

 

[TieDye]

@GNR4LIFE as it usually does when somebody tries to claim their opinion, is more truthful, than somebody else’s or is somehow serving a morally correct, heavenly purpose?

I don’t get your point-of-view and am sure many others feel the same. That’s what makes this place so awesome, have a good 1

 

[GNR4LIFE]

@GNR4LIFE as it usually does when somebody tries to claim their opinion, is more truthful, than somebody else’s or is somehow serving a morally correct, heavenly purpose?

I don’t get your point-of-view and am sure many others feel the same. That’s what makes this place so awesome, have a good 1

Not sure how you interpreted our interaction here as me thinking my opinion matters more than yours. Just giving you my view. Try not to take it so seriously ✌️

 

[TieDye]

@GNR4LIFE that ^ was only semi-srs 😉 TBH I’m fine with the opinion you hold you just don’t need to convince or even try, with every second person that joins the forum. We will both be as equally pleased I have no doubt when Madge’s mighty men storm home to finals this year ! (Sarcasm)

 

[Geo]

What I find odd is Cammy's 400 Benji's 300 and Cooper's 300 last week was all about their contribution to the game of RL and dominated social media and the lead up..

Now we come to Farah and instead of talking about his great contributions to our Club and the game it's dominated by feuds...started by him which he admitted last night on 360 as throw away line to gee up to a jurno ..now that is all that is dominating the talk..it's telling

 

[TieDye]

@Geo very telling... still comes back to what is mediocre? Will be anything but a win this weekend as the boys and boys alone have responsibility for our season now

The judgement of others surrounding the club; I’m happy for to be after rd. 1 next year

Can we as fans not all accept the man that our #9 is and just get on with things to show our gratitude, or at the very least a positive attitude going into a massive weekend for the future. He’s all but admitted these will be his last few games and I’d like to judge on that

Not whatever ‘gee’ up line he threw like a bone to a rookie journalist dog

You know 360 is complete crap *usually* geo , Time will tell I guess who handled themselves better from the two . Me personally? Care less

 

[Newtown]

Robbie i think its time to retire.

 

[Geo]

@Geo very telling... still comes back to what is mediocre? Will be anything but a win this weekend as the boys and boys alone have responsibility for our season now

The judgement of others surrounding the club; I’m happy for to being after rd. 1 next year

Can we as fans not all accept the man that our #9 is and just get on with things to show our gratitude, or at the very least a positive attitude going into a massive weekend for the future. He’s all but admitted these will be his last few games and I’d like to judge on that

Not whatever ‘gee’ up line he threw like a dog to a bone some rookie journalist

You know 360 is complete crap usually geo , Time will tell I guess who handled themselves better from the two . Me personally? Care less

The show is probably one of the better league shows IMO beats the crap out of the show on 9...

But those were the words from Farah's own mouth...nothing to do with the show

 

[Tim Sheens]

I still have trouble believing that after all the initial blood had been spilt and whilst there was still some value attached, one of the early actions of our CEO was to reverse the situation and get the the coach to apologise in front of the playing group. That he and his traitor mate then brought the problems back to the club astounds me even more.

WT will still be paying a penalty next year for such foolishness, oddly seems quite deserved given what has transpired. The gift that keeps on giving.

For those that want a bit of balance, he had a few good games since returning was a very good player, but that was a while back and the other areas have long outweighed that good.

 

[Jock Koss]

@formerguest for mine it was benji that has long outweighed the good

 

[TYGA]

Via the mole, quoting Rod Reddy tweet.

But former St George and Test legend Reddy has now fired back, posting on social media:

“Well we were right he went to Souths and played reserve grade and that Wests Tigers team at the moment is a reserve grade team with 4/5 nrl players in it and Farah is not 1 of them.

“Most selfish player I have ever been involved with while either playing the game or coaching bar none.”


Good hopefully it fires up the team. Reddy was a great player but he and JT possibly the worst coaching combo in the history of the NRL. I’d take Terry Lamb and Hoppa over them.

Who was Langmack's assistant at souffs? They'd be in the running ?

Arthur Ktinas? Great bloke.

 

[Tim Sheens]

@formerguest for mine it was benji that has long outweighed the good

Nah, I can't cop the kicks on early tackles, just like Farah does as well, but one of them, being Benji, creates positive interest and corporate attention, whilst with the other, trouble seems to surround him.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

@formerguest for mine it was benji that has long outweighed the good

Nah, I can't cop the kicks on early tackles, just like Farah does as well, but one of them, being Benji, creates positive interest and corporate attention, whilst with the other, trouble seems to surround him.

They were both as bad as each other once upon a time. One of them grew up. The other didn’t.