Robert Lui Incident/Contract Thread

@willow said:
Great. After a very good season for the club and a solid end to the season for Lui, this happens. :brick:
Click to expand...

i hope this is just a bit more steam then substance otherwise given the way the tigers like no off field nonsense i would hate to think we might loose this young talent!

Bloody drinking! Cause of too many problems!
 
Sorry but there should be a zero tolerance policy towards any violence towards women from its players.

If this is proven than the club should put him in to counselling along with his partner if that is viable and than out the door he goes
 
Should be dealt with the same way as Daine Laurie.

Could be an easy way to solve the #7 battle between himself and Moltzen.

Such an unfortunate thing to happen after an incredible year for him.
 
not a good start to the offseason but in my eyes he is innocent until proven guilty. i dont believe anything that comes from the telecrap. i hope he is innocent. i think he has alot of potential in the game. we would also need to look for another halfback for depth.
 
Ive met him on several occassions and he always seemed like such a nice bloke.

At the fan day he was just about the only player to actually approach the fans without waiting for them to come to him. And he was always more than happy to talk to people.

I agree with what the club spokesperson said about it being out of character.
 
@smeghead said:
Sorry but there should be a zero tolerance policy towards any violence towards women from its players.

If this is proven than the club should put him in to counselling along with his partner if that is viable and than out the door he goes
Click to expand...

I agree, it could be a very hard, but valuable lesson.
.
would not be suprised if in future the NRL have a policy written into players contracts dealing with this type of incident.
.
 
@smeghead said:
Sorry but there should be a zero tolerance policy towards any violence towards women from its players.

If this is proven than the club should put him in to counselling along with his partner if that is viable and than out the door he goes
Click to expand...

Out the door? No thanks.

He is what, 20 years old? There are far less drastic yet more beneficial avenues the club can take to ensure Lui has learnt his lesson.
 
@alien said:
not a good start to the offseason but in my eyes he is innocent until proven guilty. i dont believe anything that comes from the telecrap. i hope he is innocent. i think he has alot of potential in the game. we would also need to look for another halfback for depth.
Click to expand...

Agree 100%. But if he ends up being sacked by the Tigers I have this terrible thought in my head of him disappearing for a year or so and then being signed by another club when "all has been forgiven", just like Greg Bird.
 
@Centaur said:
@smeghead said:
Sorry but there should be a zero tolerance policy towards any violence towards women from its players.

If this is proven than the club should put him in to counselling along with his partner if that is viable and than out the door he goes

Out the door? No thanks.

He is what, 20 years old? There are far less drastic yet more beneficial avenues the club can take to ensure Lui has learnt his lesson.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Assaulting your pregnant girlfriend…what less drastic avenue would you suggest?
 
There was no one more depressed than him when the game ended. He just had the best game of his career and then this happened. He clearly looked a lot lot depressed after the game!

Hopefully, it's not that much of a deal. When they say assaulted, I have no idea what they mean. It can be very bad or very good.
 
I was thinking maybe this thread should be closed until the legal process has run it's course, as was the case with Laurie's assault charge.
 
STATEMENT FROM WESTS TIGERS
>
Wests Tigers have today been made aware of police allegations against NRL player Robert Lui including domestic violence matters.
>
Lui has told the club that he will vigorously contest charges laid against him today as result of those allegations.
>
The matter is now one for the Police and the courts to manage. The club will respect the legal process and respect the rights of everyone involved by not entering into any further comment.
>
Robert Lui has been relieved of his club duties until further notice so that he can properly concentrate his attention on the matters in question.
>
Wests Tigers has an inclusive and family orientated culture and does not condone violence against women.
>
The club will do everything in its power to respect the rights of all parties involved in this matter and to offer appropriate support.
>
Wests Tigers will continue to monitor this situation.
 
@TigersFan4Life said:
Agree 100%. But if he ends up being sacked by the Tigers I have this terrible thought in my head of him disappearing for a year or so and then being signed by another club when "all has been forgiven", just like Greg Bird.
Click to expand...

"All was Forgiven" with Greg Bird, because he got off in court, therefore he was not guilty (although not proven innocent). I think that is the lesson to learn here for the Tigers. Need to bide our time until proven guilty or otherwise but at the same time offer support both verbal and otherwise to the girl.

No good can come from this.

Glenn
 
@hybrid_tiger said:
@Centaur said:
@smeghead said:
Sorry but there should be a zero tolerance policy towards any violence towards women from its players.

If this is proven than the club should put him in to counselling along with his partner if that is viable and than out the door he goes

Out the door? No thanks.

He is what, 20 years old? There are far less drastic yet more beneficial avenues the club can take to ensure Lui has learnt his lesson.

Assaulting your pregnant girlfriend…what less drastic avenue would you suggest?
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

As smeg already suggested, counselling is one of them - help him understand why he did it, does he think it is ok, why he shouldn't do it, what will he do to make sure he doesn't do it again. As I said he is young, perhaps poorly educated and perhaps poorly guided (who knows?).

Another issue is, we don't even know what he did. After all, the Greg Bird incident was an 'accident'…

And before people start questioning my morals - I have not at any stage suggested that what he has been charged with is anything but completely unacceptable and sickening.

Regardless, I think we should wait for a few more facts before we start calling for heads.

_Edit: if it is in fact serious, then obviously my opinion on this matter would change._
 
In my post I only called for action if it was indeed a proven allegation.

Of course there is a process that must be followed.

Again it shows the importance of everyone knowing their limits in regards to alcohol. Even if found to have not acted in a criminal manner it shows how dangerous putting yourself in a drunken situation can prove. Despite the spotlight that will be focussed on Rob he is in a decent position as far as legal representation and support systems. The average person is not so lucky
 
The matter is before the courts….The club has issued a statement....I suggest we leave the accusations and speculation out of it.....

The Forum does not wish to lock the thread but ask that discussions to be kept to facts not speculation..

Cheers..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 447 (members: 34, guests: 413)
Back
Top