Round 16 Discussion *SPOILERS*

[sheer64]

Kelly is lifted off the ground and the tackle is allowed to continue so he is taken towards the sideline. Would never happen to the Rorters.

What did you make of the tackle in the disallowed try?

Technically a tackle.

Technically yes. But i find it interesting because the Kelly tackle into the sideline was technically a tackle also.
It’s like they made the call due to size of the player and difficulty in the opposition being shifted in the tackle.

Issue is he was lifted off the ground and then they tried to take him out.

 

[Needaname]

Kelly is lifted off the ground and the tackle is allowed to continue so he is taken towards the sideline. Would never happen to the Rorters.

What did you make of the tackle in the disallowed try?

Technically a tackle.

Technically yes. But i find it interesting because the Kelly tackle into the sideline was technically a tackle also.
It’s like they made the call due to size of the player and difficulty in the opposition being shifted in the tackle.

Issue is he was lifted off the ground and then they tried to take him out.

I guess he was lifted just before being taken out so the tackle momentum was continuing. Thought a lifted player was held.
If kelly resisted fighting and threw his hands in the air would of been a penalty.

 

[sheer64]

Kelly is lifted off the ground and the tackle is allowed to continue so he is taken towards the sideline. Would never happen to the Rorters.

What did you make of the tackle in the disallowed try?

Technically a tackle.

Technically yes. But i find it interesting because the Kelly tackle into the sideline was technically a tackle also.
It’s like they made the call due to size of the player and difficulty in the opposition being shifted in the tackle.

Issue is he was lifted off the ground and then they tried to take him out.

I guess he was lifted just before being taken out so the tackle momentum was continuing. Thought a lifted player was held.
If kelly resisted fighting and threw his hands in the air would of been a penalty.

Ref should of called held when Lomax continued to take him towards the sideline and yes should then have been penalised.

 

[Aesopian]

Taller halfback and CT wouldn't have touched that

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Souths are no chance of winning the comp.

I wouldn't say that
With Mitchell out now Johnston will slot into the fullback position
He will be playing for his future at souths
It will be interesting to see how he goes
If he kills it his price goes up
If he is a dud we will sign him up
Probably already have

I’ll say it. Mark my words. They are Buckley’s of beating the top sides. And no Parra are not a top side.

 

[sheer64]

Sammy and Kelly would look good in Tigers colours

 

[Aesopian]

Sammy and Kelly would look good in Tigers colours

Kelly's a ball hog. Stiff's his winger several times a game.

Didn't we have a go at sammy 12 months ago?

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Ash Taylor is the most disappointing player of the last 5 years.

He's ousted Brooks for the title

Especially for the price!

 

[Aesopian]

Ash Taylor is the most disappointing player of the last 5 years.

He's ousted Brooks for the title

Especially for the price!

If someone offered Brooks or Taylor, you'd wack them across the head and ask what the third option is

 

[sheer64]

Go the TITans

 

[sheer64]

Great try TITans

 

[Geo]

Papali would have stopped Fogarty..

 

[Strider]

Titans are playing well, bette than our boys 👍

 

[izotope]

nice seeing a team that care about their performance

 

[sheer64]

Dragoons nothing has changed

 

[Aesopian]

Papali would have stopped Fogarty..

Is Fogarty's pace over-rated? or is Papalii's pace under-rated?

 

[Needaname]

Papali would have stopped Fogarty..

Is Fogarty's pace over-rated? or is Papalii's pace under-rated?

Got up to 34km an hour in the chase so I’d say so to the latter.

 

[innsaneink]

So JWH holds onto the defender and dopey gives 6more

 

[sheer64]

Papali would have stopped Fogarty..

Is Fogarty's pace over-rated? or is Papalii's pace under-rated?

Got up to 34km an hour in the chase so I’d say so to the latter.

I would be checking the equipment

 

[Aesopian]

Papali would have stopped Fogarty..

Is Fogarty's pace over-rated? or is Papalii's pace under-rated?

Got up to 34km an hour in the chase so I’d say so to the latter.

Impressive if true. That's a lot of mass moving fast