Schirnack boys

R

redemption

New member
…...went excellent tonight!!!

Where were the "cronic" (sic) penalties magpiecol??????????????????

Jason was in everything when on & only missed Mannering after making three consecutive tackles!!!

Al was his typical no-nonsense self!!!!
 
I thought of you redemption when i was sitting in the crowd last night and both the Schirnack's names were announced. For the months that everyone has been raving about them i'm glad they finally got a chance. Neither of them looked out of place.
 
Jason didn't have the impact that I though he would however he was really involved. Al really impressed me though - he just kept going.

I think they should both be in the squad on a regular basis.
 
They were solid in defence tonight,but did very little in attack.I believe they can improve on this. with further first grade experience.
 
Both didn't disappoint. They are both honest toilers and worked hard off the ball.

They aren't Ellis or Fulton, but they both didn't look out of place or over their heads.
 
while they are great players and dont look out of place in the top team i dont know who you can say they should take the position of in the top 17 but if they put in some big performances over the next few weeks it's going to be a tough for call for tim and the rest of the staff to decide on who stays and who goes
 
@redemption said:
…...went excellent tonight!!!

Where were the "cronic" (sic) penalties magpiecol??????????????????

Jason was in everything when on & only missed Mannering after making three consecutive tackles!!!

Al was his typical no-nonsense self!!!!
Click to expand...

Al shaded Jason is all I'll say …outstanding depth we have....I believe Dwyer wider helped his game to would you agree RED...?
 
Both the brothers had good games… Al probably shun above Jason, but it was just great to see them get a run...

Geo, I enjoyed Dwyer playing wider, but his first half was average. Didn't he hit the line with some gusty in the second though? Well done, but he will still be used in Prop Rotation once the rest of the boys are back, so he still needs to work hard on this area of his game...

It was a good game by everyone for the record. I don't think anyone let us down, bar Archer and his brigade!
 
@Geo. said:
@redemption said:
…...went excellent tonight!!!

Where were the "cronic" (sic) penalties magpiecol??????????????????

Jason was in everything when on & only missed Mannering after making three consecutive tackles!!!

Al was his typical no-nonsense self!!!!

Al shaded Jason is all I'll say …outstanding depth we have....I believe Dwyer wider helped his game to would you agree RED...?
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

I do Geo - Dwyer was much improved on last week's poor showing!

His work-rate was good & his line-break before the Farah try was a beauty!!!
 
@magpiecol said:
Played ok. One penalty and one missed tackle which led to a try. But ok.
Click to expand...

Mate - the penalty was given by Al - yet it was Jason you referred to as the chronic penalty-giver!!!

Jase made 25 tackles and never came close to giving a penalty!!
 
@redemption said:
@magpiecol said:
Played ok. One penalty and one missed tackle which led to a try. But ok.

Mate - the penalty was given by Al - yet it was Jason you referred to as the chronic penalty-giver!!!

Jase made 25 tackles and never came close to giving a penalty!!
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

I said, he, they played ok. Still a penalty and a missed tackle which led to a try. Get over it.
 
And the penalty on Al was one of those joke penalties. He was off the man quicker than 90% of the tackles per game. The ref just decided that was a good moment to give NZ a penalty.
 
@MacDougall said:
And the penalty on Al was one of those joke penalties. He was off the man quicker than 90% of the tackles per game. The ref just decided that was a good moment to give NZ a penalty.
Click to expand...

Exactly Macca!!!

He was well off the tackled player when the whistle blew - and it was a dominant tackle!!

The suggestion that either of them is ill-disciplined is ill-conceived!!!
 
I'm a big fan of jasons however people Who are saying he was Great last night are letting their biasm get in the way. He was average, not great, not terrible, however in defence he was found wanting a bit.

Al on the other hand was awesome in defence
 
@fergiefurr said:
I'm a big fan of jasons however people Who are saying he was Great last night are letting their biasm get in the way. He was average, not great, not terrible, however in defence he was found wanting a bit.

Al on the other hand was awesome in defence
Click to expand...

Both were equally effective in defence - and statistically identical in attack!

Al just put on two shots that rightly got everyone's attention while Jason was a quiet achiever (despite his miss on Mannering after he'd just made 3 consecutive tackles)!
 
@redemption said:
@fergiefurr said:
I'm a big fan of jasons however people Who are saying he was Great last night are letting their biasm get in the way. He was average, not great, not terrible, however in defence he was found wanting a bit.

Al on the other hand was awesome in defence

Both were equally effective in defence - and statistically identical in attack!

Al just put on two shots that rightly got everyone's attention while Jason was a quiet achiever (despite his miss on Mannering after he'd just made 3 consecutive tackles)!
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

You are so biased it is not funny. They are a couple of average footballers who got a game because of injuries. There is no way they would be in the starting lineup if Gibbs, Ellis and Fulton were available.

Having said that, they played ok. Nothing outstanding but they did the job.
 
@magpiecol said:
@redemption said:
@fergiefurr said:
I'm a big fan of jasons however people Who are saying he was Great last night are letting their biasm get in the way. He was average, not great, not terrible, however in defence he was found wanting a bit.

Al on the other hand was awesome in defence

Both were equally effective in defence - and statistically identical in attack!

Al just put on two shots that rightly got everyone's attention while Jason was a quiet achiever (despite his miss on Mannering after he'd just made 3 consecutive tackles)!

You are so biased it is not funny. They are a couple of average footballers who got a game because of injuries. There is no way they would be in the starting lineup if Gibbs, Ellis and Fulton were available.

Having said that, they played ok. Nothing outstanding but they did the job.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Agreed.

I think add BMM and Moors to that unavailable list.
 
@redemption said:
…...went excellent tonight!!!

Where were the "cronic" (sic) penalties magpiecol??????????????????

Jason was in everything when on & only missed Mannering after making three consecutive tackles!!!

Al was his typical no-nonsense self!!!!
Click to expand...

2 questions Red -

What do you mean my (Sic) ???

Are you somehow connected to the Boys??
 
(sic) just makes refference to the quote about chronic penalties being quoted verbatim from magpiecol mate.

The grammar Nazi in me would suggest it is also pointing out the spelling error without being blatant about doing so
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 890 (members: 24, guests: 866)
Back
Top