Sheens replacing Madge

[Yossarian]

Has anyone asked if Timmy is even interested?

Matt Groat probably. I’m sure he eyes a comeback.

 

[matchball]

I'd be happy if Dad came back to coach. He has the smarts and maybe a bit wacky in selections it can't be worse than this lot.

I reckon Madge will survive the season so we don't look like a complete Chernobyl meltdown but won't be here 2022.
Tim is keen to coach don't rule out the old guy.
Melt my heart if Royce dusts of the witches hats to join in too.

 

[Demps]

It constantly amazes me that the fans still haven’t moved on from sheens and our ex players. the good ol days I suppose.

I guess team list Tuesday will be interesting again

Daniel Fitzhenry for 5/8?

A couple of wingers on the bench as well.


There is a reason the term Sheenius was coined and it’s not because we were winning.

And 90kg backrowers at prop. Scrum moves should be good. You need a good assistant on the witch’s hats though.

In the modern game, this may even work...
Yas are pointing out some Sheens negatives.

What about Madges?
Talau played every game this year and he's not even a NSW cup player.

Twal at lock and Offa at prop.

Yeah Sheenius was a flop ayyy
And Madge is even worse.

 

[Tigrrs]

Madge needs to go,it’s not rocket science

 

[Sco77y]

Sheens didn’t agree to take up a role here as the head coach. Are we going to screw around with his contract, and him, before he’s even arrived? Lol.

 

[TigerWest]

Madge needs to go,it’s not rocket science

Who replaces him?

How many years do we give them, while he brings in his players?

 

[Yossarian]

Madge needs to go,it’s not rocket science

Is he good at the rocket science?

 

[Demps]

Sheens didn’t agree to take up a role here as the head coach. Are we going to screw around with his contract, and him, before he’s even arrived? Lol.

Desperate times...

Sheens can do cross words and sip tea in the coaches box, counting down the minutes till they take him back to the nursing home.

Still do a better Job than Madge.

 

[Demps]

Madge needs to go,it’s not rocket science

Who replaces him?

How many years do we give them, while he brings in his players?

Ben Gardiner,
Robbie Farah
Brett Kimmorley
John Morris

Overseen by King coach Tim Sheens.

 

[TigerWest]

Madge needs to go,it’s not rocket science

Who replaces him?

How many years do we give them, while he brings in his players?

Ben Gardiner,
Robbie Farah
Brett Kimmorley
John Morris

Overseen by King coach Tim Sheens.

All of them together, or one at a time?

Do you not remember the Sheen years? We did win a premiership, but he was disaster in the end?

 

[CarltonDry]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire 🤷‍♂️

 

[Demps]

Madge needs to go,it’s not rocket science

Who replaces him?

How many years do we give them, while he brings in his players?

Ben Gardiner,
Robbie Farah
Brett Kimmorley
John Morris

Overseen by King coach Tim Sheens.

All of them together, or one at a time?

Do you not remember the Sheen years? We did win a premiership, but he was disaster in the end?

Yep, coaching consortium.
Sheens is the director.
Gardiner, head coach.
Farah, Kimmorley and Morris. Assistants.

While we're at it, bring over Edddie Farah from South's. Keep it in the family.

 

[TigerWest]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire ?‍♂️

So when do we make the players accountable for going out onto the field and producing the rubbish they presented?

 

[BZN]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire ?‍♂️

So when do we make the players accountable for going out onto the field and producing the rubbish they presented?

:clap: :clap: :clap: :clap: :clap:

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

I've seen a few people mention this in other threads. That we should sack Madge and replace him for the year with Sheens as Tim is coming on board in an advisor role
Surely this would have to be the ultimate humiliation for the club and board. Going back to the guy we blamed for missing the 8 in 2012, were so desperate to remove, it ended up in court as we couldn't afford to pay him out. Yet here we are now employing him in advisor role, we need him to turn the club around?
If Sheens ended up in the head job, like some are suggesting it would be confirmation the last 10 years was the biggest waste of time.

It would be a self fulfilling prophecy though.

 

[matchball]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire ?‍♂️

So when do we make the players accountable for going out onto the field and producing the rubbish they presented?

Who's job is it to make them accountable?
I thought that's the coaches job.

 

[TigerWest]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire ?‍♂️

So when do we make the players accountable for going out onto the field and producing the rubbish they presented?

The news this morning was Kevin Walters has lost the dressing room at the Bronc’s, to me, it is a cop out because the players are not up to it.

Understanding a player on $350,000 a year is on $6730 a week, surely they got to NRL because they could play? Do they not realise what council labourers get a week?

Unfortunately all clubs are bound to pay a player a contract for a predetermined time period and some seem to be content just to be in FG and there is not much a club can do about it? Unless he is reasonable, no one wants a bludger, so are stuck with him, though some come good in contract year?

Bring back, sign on fee and win and lose payments? that will sort them out.

 

[TigerWest]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire ?‍♂️

So when do we make the players accountable for going out onto the field and producing the rubbish they presented?

Who's job is it to make them accountable?
I thought that's the coaches job.

Once they are on the field, it’s there own job. They are FG players.

 

[bigsiro]

Sheens coming back to the club in an advisor role is a positive move but surely we aren’t stupid enough to put him in as head coach. As you said it just means we’ve been running on a treadmill for 10 years

We were stupid enough to extend Maguire ?‍♂️

So when do we make the players accountable for going out onto the field and producing the rubbish they presented?

:clap: :clap: :clap: :clap: :clap:

I agree.
But if he picks players like Talau again (and again) then you can hardly blame the players that are simply not first grade standards and just living their dream. The coach needs to make the relatively simple call to drop players or it will him who is dropped.

 

[GCfan]

Can't see Sheens taking over, but it does feel like the club knows Madge needs all the help he can get as he is struggling... Tamou seems to know it too

Im indifferent as to whether Madge should be kept or punted at this stage. Probably leaning toward him staying due to the debacle that we’ve been time and again with moving coaches on and the message to the playing group in doing so that the results are not your fault boys. What I do feel is sorry for Madge on a human level as the guy looks broken and devoid of answers. I think Hartigan and Pascoe taking the reins and saying Madge, you need more help, we’re going to get the best attacking and defensive assistant coach
Available.