Tweed_Tiger
Well-known member
Brooks is now the Leader of the Dally M 2018 leaderboard
Should Brooks be NSW 7?
- Thread starter teddy23
- Start date
- Status
teddy23
Well-known member
James Maloney at 6
Luke Brooks at 7
That’s the way I see it
With Keary at 14
Luke Brooks at 7
That’s the way I see it
With Keary at 14
westTAHger
Well-known member
No for origin. James Maloney and Brett Hodgkinson, would be better suited for NSW halves.
This may appear to be selfish, don't care, he Luke Brooks is **needed** at wests tigers.
This may appear to be selfish, don't care, he Luke Brooks is **needed** at wests tigers.
WestsBenTigers
New member
@ said:
6\. Maloney
7\. Brooks
9\. Koroisau
14\. Cook
Cosimo_Zaretti
New member
Not this year, although Brooks is a shot at a Daly M if he keeps this up.
Watching at Brookvale yesterday though, I realised DCE is a much better origin chance than Brooks, and seeing them head to head that seemed ridiculous.
Watching at Brookvale yesterday though, I realised DCE is a much better origin chance than Brooks, and seeing them head to head that seemed ridiculous.
sheer64
Well-known member
@ said:
spine most likely will be
1\. Tedesco
6\. Maloney
7\. Pearce
9\. McInnes
17\. Cook
teddy23
Well-known member
Just listened to the Inside NRL podcast
Soward reckons he should be selected with Maloney, also Reynolds backed him up and agreed
A lot of interest for Brooks to play, if he keeps this up for the next 5-6 weeks I can’t see him not getting picked
If Pearce is selected for NSW I won’t watch
Soward reckons he should be selected with Maloney, also Reynolds backed him up and agreed
A lot of interest for Brooks to play, if he keeps this up for the next 5-6 weeks I can’t see him not getting picked
If Pearce is selected for NSW I won’t watch
teddy23
Well-known member
@ said:
According to Paul Kent, Teddy will not play origin and Tommy Turbo is penciled in to play fullback
upthetigers
Well-known member
@ said:
Pearce won't get picked. It will be either Maloney and Keary or Maloney and Blake Green.
Four good games to start the season doesn't make you the front runner for Origin when you've shown no consistency up until that point.
teddy23
Well-known member
@ said:
The funny thing is that Blake Green falls under the same reasoning…..
That bloke was never regarded a chance for NSW but these past few games he’s been playing well.
Keary maybe but I see him being selected as a 14
Luke Brooks is the form 7 in the NRL
He’s leading the Daily M
He’s been instrumental with our rise this season
He’s kicking game to acquire resets has improved massively, along with his running game.
We should be basing it on form, and as I said if he keeps it up for another 6 weeks he deserves it... atm it’s just about him showing consistency
Just my opinion
upthetigers
Well-known member
@ said:
Brooks is going so well would hate to seem him get thrown in the Origin arena too early and have that dent his confidence.
I think Blake Green has been a much more consistent footballer.
teddy23
Well-known member
@ said:
I can understand that but we’re more going against him playing not cause he isn’t good enough, but cause we’re scared of origin maybe hurting his confidence if they don’t go well and also cause we want him playing during that period for the tigers
Blake Green has been consistent in a sense, but consistently average no where near Origin level
If he does get selected I guess we can see J Rey play in the halves so it’s not too much of a negative in that regard
happy_tiger
Well-known member
Look you'd want to see this form continue through to SOO time before considering it
If Fittler was to pick him I'd hope that they give him 2 series to get acclimatised to SOO , different kettle of fish
Biggest concern for me if I was a NSWmen would be the possibility of having 3 SOO debutants in your spine with McInnes and Turbo
If Fittler was to pick him I'd hope that they give him 2 series to get acclimatised to SOO , different kettle of fish
Biggest concern for me if I was a NSWmen would be the possibility of having 3 SOO debutants in your spine with McInnes and Turbo
Cairnstigers
New member
Not this year
Luke needs to show consistency throughout the whole year and take us deep into the finals first
If he can do that and start next year like he has this year then he will get his shot
Until then he is ours
Imo
Luke needs to show consistency throughout the whole year and take us deep into the finals first
If he can do that and start next year like he has this year then he will get his shot
Until then he is ours
Imo
momo_amp_medo
Well-known member
Nooooooooooooo!
Tigerdave
Well-known member
can I be selfish and say no?
- Status
