Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Red88_Tiger]

Reynolds wouldn't have chosen to come to play under Madge. Word is he's filthy he has to play under his again now

I wouldn’t believe that
His preference is to stay at the broncos next year
Can’t be too filthy

 

[TigerNeddyK]

Was.

He retired in the off season....

They just don’t get it .. I’m with you , on his day Hymel reminded me a lot of Andrew Johns.. 😎😉

 

[user118245]

Burns is a Temu version of good back rowers.

Teig Wilton should be the target from the Sharks. Or Colquin.

Their cap is tight apparently

 

[Oldman]

May is a top 3 prop in the game at the moment, so lets move him?

Haas plays big minutes, so I guess he should be moved to lock to. I don't know what everyones obsession is with moving players for the sake of it. The best thing for the team is keep a top 3 front rower in the front row. If we need a lock, go get a lock. One of the reasons we're having issues is because we have two props already playing out of position (Twal at lock and Seyfarth at second row).

Seyfarth has been playing second row but can fill both spots. If we end up with 7-8 first grade props on the roster of 30, it means we are going to be lacking somewhere else.

We need to upgrade our team and right now our biggest weaknesses are left centre, right backrow and lock. Once we upgrade those positions, the prop depth will fix itself as we will get two more first grade props from the two guys currently playing in other positions.

Most teams only run out with 4 props on game day, we are currently running out with 6 props (two out of position). That in itself should tell you we have more than enough props and not enough in other positions...

I don’t see Seyfarth as a Prop,
Gets held up and pushed back most runs due mainly because of his physical limitations (not bulky enough)
The main issue I see with him is he has the body for a 2nd rower but hasn’t the speed to worry opposition defenders.

 

[Fish88]

Yes 2 more teams coming in 60 players needed the talent in NRL 1st grade is thin already, grab what you need now we might have to pay 650/700k.

Don't wait and have to pay 200k overs down the track when other teams are desperate for players, If Terrell doesn't like it upgrade him to keep him happy.

This is it. We are perennially losers trying to turn a corner. We don’t deserve bargains, pay them what we need to and lock them down before we are forced to pay real overs.

 

[TigerNeddyK]

No way to Reynolds...he is a great half but he is broken.

We also sold to Luai that this was his team and his next phase legacy can be dragging WT off the bottom. How does that work with Reynolds too...

Bringing him here to mentor Latu for 2 seasons would be an incredible plan especially of Latu had been made aware that he is our long term 7 partner with Jarome .. Reynolds could really take Latu to the next level

 

[TigerNeddyK]

I don’t see Seyfarth as a Prop,
Gets held up and pushed back most runs due mainly because of his physical limitations (not bulky enough)
The main issue I see with him is he has the body for a 2nd rower but hasn’t the speed to worry opposition defenders.

He also runs straight at the opposition shoulder and not at the gap between defenders .. a lot of our players think you have to run at the defence to make it easy for them . LOBB made an art form of it

 

[liltiger]

I will be happy if he is available to play for WTs during SOO. I am sure he will be selected for Samoa.

MSN

Daley isn't picking him because he's a tiger, surely he gets a chance even on an extended bench. He's been the form prop all year, apart from last week's disaster where the whole team were on another planet he's had a stellar start to the season. In saying that Daley has coached how many series, how many has he won. Personally think the guys a moron.

 

[BBTF]

Daley isn't picking him because he's a tiger, surely he gets a chance even on an extended bench. He's been the form prop all year, apart from last week's disaster where the whole team were on another planet he's had a stellar start to the season. In saying that Daley has coached how many series, how many has he won. Personally think the guys a moron.

I agree....but I do think May's extra minutes may hurt him. The last two weeks I have noticed him a bit more tired and last week in particular melbourne exploited him late. Against the Dragons there were a few times I also noticed him struggling to get back onside due to excessive minutes. I know everyone says trust the coach bla bla, but I think it is hurting him a bit, and I also really only think we play him that much because our depth quality is poor.

 

[Darty the winger]

They just don’t get it .. I’m with you , on his day Hymel reminded me a lot of Andrew Johns.. 😎😉

Wally Lewis maybe

 

[Ecto-1]

I’m thinking the delay in announcing KPP is because it went from him coming next year to an immediate transfer.

 

[Tigers_Wests]

I’m thinking the delay in announcing KPP is because it went from him coming next year to an immediate transfer.

Hope you are right. Depends how badly Knights want Dom Young. Otherwise they might not entertain an early release....if of course KPP signs for next year regardless.

 

[Groundup]

I’m thinking the delay in announcing KPP is because it went from him coming next year to an immediate transfer.

Seems like there are moving parts that could include DCE, Galvin, and whoever else is collateral. Big moves before June 30
I reckon

 

[Buttface]

But so far this year he has not missed a match.

Contract year.

 

[Vicious]

Hope you are right. Depends how badly Knights want Dom Young. Otherwise they might not entertain an early release....if of course KPP signs for next year regardless.

I thought KPP and Dom Young were good mates and ideally want to play for the same club ?

 

[Buttface]

The biggest issue with what buzz said was “the way he spoke to me on the phone gave me insight into why the playing groups go off him”
I’m no Madge fan as a coach , as I think the young players don’t sync up with that aged hard edged coach , but buzz is dead set off his head comparing the 2 things because he was told to go F himself by someone he’s been writing negative articles about since his days at Souths 10 years ago.
And like Gordy was saying there’s only one Bellamy . I’m not even sure the Bellamy style works for him outside of Melbourne .
Everyone knows you go to melb , you’re going into the nrl version of the army , for good and bad . The system , the coach , the reputation , are all part of the package when you’re weighing up a Melbourne contract .
I just don’t think that type of coaching works outside of places like melb , and even Canberra where you’re away from thr 24/7 of nrl media.

I’m not defending Madge, he could be on the nose, I just don’t wanna give any air to BS artists who only print with an agenda to get more clicks.

 

[hank37w]

Barry Toohey (Newcastle's mouthpiece) reporting that Kai Pearce-Paul has a significant offer from a rival club worth more than the contract Newcastle have offered him.

you'd assume a deal is close.

I hope it is not significantly more than what he is currently on and that the latest Newcastle offer is a mere pittance.

 

[BrissieTiger67]

Wally Lewis maybe

I can't get over Hymel as a name...just immediately sounds like Hymen 😐

 

[Buttface]

I feel badly for May. Perhaps the club should ask for a copy of this "report" and who wrote or complied it.

They are dead set kidding themselves.
Do they not wanna win?

 

[pawsandclaws1]

They are dead set kidding themselves.
Do they not wanna win?

The "report" should be confidential and not find its way into the media.