Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Tucker]

Your letting recent form blind you, he has helped with team culture while he's been here.

But yeah it doesn't look like it at the moment with the season turning to shit.

He helped push the bro culture, big noting Dhead crap that derailed season 2025 and has run out of steam in 2026.
It is never sustainable as you are currently seeing.
He has played some decent games for us recently but we needed an experienced hard headed leader and he has failed that role spectacularly.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Resilience mate, resilience.

character building supporting the tigers

 

[Rock Hopper Steve]

He helped push the bro culture, big noting Dhead crap that derailed season 2025 and has run out of steam in 2026.
It is never sustainable as you are currently seeing.
He has played some decent games for us recently but we needed an experienced hard headed leader and he has failed that role spectacularly.

Can't disagree Tuck, hence my jab to move him for a year to the bears, not needed at that price tag next year, what we could do with that dosh, disappointing.

 

[mtd#2]

character building supporting the tigers

I used to think that, but the longer I follow them i am leaning more toward mental illness 😂😂

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

I used to think that, but the longer I follow them i am leaning more toward mental illness 😂😂

lol haha
geez it is depressing every year isnt it
at least we got to july this year before season over

 

[Halbrowne61]

I used to think that, but the longer I follow them i am leaning more toward mental illness 😂😂

What’s that old Dyvinals song,” it’s a fine line between pleasure and pain “ !

 

[Merlot]

Yes, I have really warmed to the culture over the past 2 weeks. No more high fiving try celebrations, AD pulled off a miracle yesterday and got the reception of a KKK who’d invaded an island hangi !

im starting to like AD his arm shot out to score that try yesterday ,fairly sure he buggered the other 1 doing exactly the same movement ,for his latest set back,but thats brave , he came out of his roll on of setbacks to be wanting more from himself

 

[Vicious]

I gotta tell ya..I’m tired of having low confidence outside backs with bad hands at this club …the money saved won’t matter to me if he is costing us results ,,,maybe he will be the one that turns it around …but they are traits that are hard to overcome …Skelton has played a lot for us this year , so if he is taking his spot we are going to see a bit of him …

It looks highly likely Benji’s first choice back 5 for 2027 will be;
1. Bula
2. Turuva
3. Averillo
4. Taylan May
5. Makasini
** Obviously we do not know how much Makasini will improve by the start of 2027, but I will say his yardage carries last night were as strong as they have been for quite a while and he was a danger with ball in hand, so he did show some good signs despite still missing a couple of tackles that he really should have made.
** The addition of Jake Averillo definitely makes us stronger, but there must be concern on whether Taylan May’s shoulder can stay healthy.
** You would hope we have a combination of at least 2 of Skelton, Junior Tupou and Sol Saukuru as big bodied players who can come in as a winger or centre if either Makasini or Taylan May are out injured or in Makasini’s case possibly not playing as well as expected and we then need to work on cover for Averillo and Turuva. I think we need another player with plenty of speed as an option. I keep saying James Schiller would be ideal as there are certainly not better fringe or back up attacking right sided centre/wingers than him currently available for 2027.

 

[Vicious]

Agree
I’d back D.Lucas to beat most of our outside backs over 100 metres.
Except
Bula and possibly To’a

I reckon he beats To’a comfortably over 10, 20, 30, 50 or 100m

 

[Dr_Ice]

Dylan Brown 1.3 million v Jarome Luai 1.2 million .....thoughts ??

Last week Brown was as bad as our guys

 

[Dr_Ice]

What’s that old Dyvinals song,” it’s a fine line between pleasure and pain “ !

Good old Chrissie. Our team does play like schoolgirls sometimes

 

[Vicious]

Benji has Api, May, KPP, Sam F, AD, Luai, Turuva and Bula.
Plenty of talent, comparable, if not more so than what Holbrook has.

I reckon the Knights 1-5 is significantly better than ours and significantly faster than ours.
Our halves are somewhat comparable to theirs and when we have Sam Fainu and KPP fit and healthy we have a very competitive back row, but in combination with Twal it is still a slowish back row in comparison to most other NRL teams. That is fine, but we should be adding a back rower with good leg speed off the bench to try and overcome the lack of speed in our starting back row.
Has Dylan Walker already signed for a UK Super League club ?
Someone like him or with a very similar playing style would add a an extra dimension to us as a 13 off the bench.

 

[crazycat]

Id be getting AD into the centres with a licence to roam. That puts turuva back on the wing. Then javon/laui rest of the year with latu at 9.

STOP!

Ok you have two choices:
1. You put AD in the Center. Great he goes there and he should STAY there.
OR
2. You give AD a 'License to roam'.

Center is the worst named position in NRL, really they are 'guards' the players that have to balance the edge defense as if they are out of position your winger now faces a 2-1 overlap.

What happened in the Dragons game? Our center's did not move with our Wingers on our edge defense. Turuva was left guarding a huge overlap and Boom, try!

Either your 5/8, Halfback or Fullback gets to roam and if they do then the team is watching...
Your Center's do not Roam. (case in point, us vs dragons.).

 

[crazycat]

What’s that old Dyvinals song,” it’s a fine line between pleasure and pain “ !

I... I honestly can't see the line anymore.

It's pretty much all pain here.
We gave up a winable game around the 70 minute mark.
Api goes down injured and suddenly we have no defense. Api will retire and we will honestly have a team that rivals the Bankstown Centerlink queue for motivation.



At the heart of it, if our team isn't going to train hard all year round. Why are us fans here?

 

[mtd#2]

I... I honestly can't see the line anymore.

It's pretty much all pain here.
We gave up a winable game around the 70 minute mark.
Api goes down injured and suddenly we have no defense. Api will retire and we will honestly have a team that rivals the Bankstown Centerlink queue for motivation.



At the heart of it, if our team isn't going to train hard all year round. Why are us fans here?

Even when we win, it's not pleasure, it's like a relief we didn't feel pain.

 

[AnonTiger]

STOP!

Ok you have two choices:
1. You put AD in the Center. Great he goes there and he should STAY there.
OR
2. You give AD a 'License to roam'.

Center is the worst named position in NRL, really they are 'guards' the players that have to balance the edge defense as if they are out of position your winger now faces a 2-1 overlap.

What happened in the Dragons game? Our center's did not move with our Wingers on our edge defense. Turuva was left guarding a huge overlap and Boom, try!

Either your 5/8, Halfback or Fullback gets to roam and if they do then the team is watching...
Your Center's do not Roam. (case in point, us vs dragons.).

Geeez... you on the schooeys? Roaming is in attack not defence

 

[balmain boy]

I can’t take you seriously, you are still full of praise for someone who stuffed the playing roster of the team you supposedly support.

The only person who stuffed the roster is Benji. Bebji gets his way.
And he's a crap judge of ability

 

[Wezt]

16 years with no finals, unbelievable

Knights get a wooden spoon and bounce back instantly with a top 8 finish. This club is cooked

 

[TigerBurnsy]

16 years with no finals, unbelievable

Knights get a wooden spoon and bounce back instantly with a top 8 finish. This club is cooked

I think a lot has to do with the club constantly overpaying underperforming players, like brooks on 1m before and now Luai on 1.2, how are we meant to build a sustainable roster with good depth when we constantly sink too much money into 1 player. This causes us to go shit so the club panicked and signs someone on big money to take the pressure off repeating the cycle

 

[Tom Shines]

16 years with no finals, unbelievable

Knights get a wooden spoon and bounce back instantly with a top 8 finish.

Some people here seem to think that reaching the finals is like walking up a flight of stairs where you move up one position ( step) at a time ..we are likely to be moving down the ladder this season at this stage