Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[mikey]

The only shadow of a doubt about Liddle being a very, very good hooker is injury. He has shown what he can do this year in the brief appearances he has made. I don't want to lose him and watch him become like others we have let go.
Yes I want Grant but think we can have both.

 

[happy_tiger]

I'm still wondering where the 800 -1 million is actually coming from.....people say clear the decks and I agree ...but we have a lot on St Vinnie's cast off's

 

[finnzo]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

 

[fibrodreaming]

I don’t understand how people could possibly think us signing grant long term and liddle going to bulldogs is a bad thing? He’s the next Cameron Smith

It's not a bad thing. But I would be sorry to see Liddle go.

After all the injuries, all the rehab and nurturing, he is fully fit and playing well, with who knows how much improvement there is in him and, after all that, we let him go.

 

[tiger05premier]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

 

[Furious1]

Didn't somebody on here state ages ago if Grant stays here Simpkin will leave? So we won't have both. Personally i'll be very surprised if Cam Smith is at Storms next year.

 

[Spud_Murphy]

Would love to have Jack Wighton in my team. Absolute goer.

We had ago at him a few years ago. I thought he would have been a brilliant buy, but most people thought I was brain dead. Anyway once again we came up empty in the recruitment stakes

He has improved out of sight! I remember he was pretty average for a few years there running around at fullback. I honestly never thought he would turn into the player he is now. Maybe there’s hope for Brooks yet! ??

 

[JC99]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

We started 2018 5 wins 1 loss with Godinet at hooker including beating Storm twice and Roosters lol. Maybe he was the key to it all

 

[finnzo]

I personally think storm will win the comp and smith will retire this year

 

[beachtiger]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

Liddle can’t sign with dogs unless we let him as he has a contract with us.

 

[bathursttiger1]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

We started 2018 5 wins 1 loss with Godinet at hooker including beating Storm twice and Roosters lol. Maybe he was the key to it all

That’s when Packer was having a go.

 

[frullens]

I'm still wondering where the 800 -1 million is actually coming from.....people say clear the decks and I agree ...but we have a lot on St Vinnie's cast off's

2022 we have a lot of money freed up.
2021 offer him Liddle's salary plus a little bit on top, 2002 800k-1m

 

[tiger05premier]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

Liddle can’t sign with dogs unless we let him as he has a contract with us.

When is his contract up?

 

[tiger05premier]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

Liddle can’t sign with dogs unless we let him as he has a contract with us.

When is his contract up?

All good I just saw it was up at end of 21

And all this will probably get sorted after season over

So Nov 1 will be one week after season finishes and dog's will be free to sign him than

 

[beachtiger]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

Liddle can’t sign with dogs unless we let him as he has a contract with us.

When is his contract up?

All good I just saw it was up at end of 21

And all this will probably get sorted after season over

So Nov 1 will be one week after season finishes and dog's will be free to sign him than

Yep so your prediction could still happen, geez I hope not tho.

 

[tiger05premier]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

Liddle can’t sign with dogs unless we let him as he has a contract with us.

When is his contract up?

All good I just saw it was up at end of 21

And all this will probably get sorted after season over

So Nov 1 will be one week after season finishes and dog's will be free to sign him than

Yep so your prediction could still happen, geez I hope not tho.

I hope not either but it would be the standard wests tiger's way of having it all right there and ready to go for the next decade in terms of quality hooker options than losing it all and starting from scratch

 

[westy81]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

They were saying that about Liddle when he was coming through and look what has happened to him you just don’t know these days what can happen to a player

Who knows simpkins could get home sick next year and want out, and if we happen to keep Harry and lose Jacob

Won’t be good for us then

 

[TheDaBoss]

I personally think storm will win the comp and smith will retire this year

Sooner smith goes the better

Storm would be my 2nd club if smith wasnt there, he is a cheat

 

[JC99]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

We started 2018 5 wins 1 loss with Godinet at hooker including beating Storm twice and Roosters lol. Maybe he was the key to it all


That’s when Packer was having a go.

Robbie Rochow and Tui Lolohea were playing good too. No idea how we even won games with that team - lot of it had to do with the refs crackdown, they actually penalised teams like storm and roosters for being offside and wrestling until the commentators whined about it.

 

[beachtiger]

We have Simpkins aswell but and he is ment to be the next big thing we are sorted in the hooking role for years to come

If they stay that is

True to wests tigers form it will play out like this

Liddle will get sick of waiting on Grant to decide his future who is sick of waiting for Cam to sort his future

So Liddle will sign with dog's

Cam will than retire or head to Queensland

Grant will than end up at storm

Than simpkin who has been forgotten through all this commotion will get homesick and head back to Queensland

We will than sign old favorite Pita Godinet to a 4 year deal

Liddle can’t sign with dogs unless we let him as he has a contract with us.

When is his contract up?

All good I just saw it was up at end of 21

And all this will probably get sorted after season over

So Nov 1 will be one week after season finishes and dog's will be free to sign him than

Yep so your prediction could still happen, geez I hope not tho.

I hope not either but it would be the standard wests tiger's way of having it all right there and ready to go for the next decade in terms of quality hooker options than losing it all and starting from scratch

Can’t argue with you on that, unfortunately it’s not just the hooker position it’s happened to either.