Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[weststigerman]

Joseph Manu
Brandon Smith
Junior Paulo
Viliame Kikau

All available to negotiate from Nov 1

And all will laugh in our face if/when we make them an offer.

Yeah you're right. Why bother trying to sign anyone quality

Keep posting suggestions mate, some people just come on here to shoot everything down.

 

[TV Ted Ellery]

https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/tigers-considering-chasing-elliott-as-club-prepares-for-call-on-maguire-20210911-p58qsz.html

The title is misleading. Article only says that Madge is a fan of Elliot for his football, as opposed to his off-field hijinks.

 

[bathursttiger1]

Charlie Staines - can’t believe so many people rate him. He is pathetic

He was the Ferrari last year, but they have just discovered that he has a VW motor in it.

 

[cktiger]

Charlie Staines - can’t believe so many people rate him. He is pathetic

we picked the right one, Laurie >>Edwards, Burton, Staines!

I actually think they really missed Edwards tonight.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Joseph Manu
Brandon Smith
Junior Paulo
Viliame Kikau

All available to negotiate from Nov 1

Don’t rate Kikau. Good size but so many stupid errors in his game.

E.G. Late line break should’ve held it, had 4 tackles or so up their sleeve, spread the next play probably a try. Forced the pass to an already marked Burton and ball to ground turnover

Other 3 are quality though

Kikau is so weak.

Not a fan at all.

cheapshot merchant and a cat

 

[Tim Sheens]

A player who a lot on this forum have little time for Dylan Walker made a big difference for Manly when he came on against Storm would not be a bad pick up for WT'S especially with Douehi and Talau being out for the first few months of season 2022 and with Mbye gone would make a good bench player.Hope his learnt his lesson in regard to off field issues but surely his contract could be drawn up to cover


It would be impossible for me to want a bloke who allegedly beats up women at our club.I would hope we would have learned from the Lui experience

I switch off Manly matches when I see that poor excuse of a human takes the field.

 

[Jedi_Tiger]

Charlie Staines - can’t believe so many people rate him. He is pathetic

they let Laurie go for Staines bad move

 

[Demps]

Joseph Manu
Brandon Smith
Junior Paulo
Viliame Kikau

All available to negotiate from Nov 1

Don’t rate Kikau. Good size but so many stupid errors in his game.

E.G. Late line break should’ve held it, had 4 tackles or so up their sleeve, spread the next play probably a try. Forced the pass to an already marked Burton and ball to ground turnover

Other 3 are quality though

Kikau is so weak.

Not a fan at all.

cheapshot merchant and a cat

Yep, coward.
Loved Stefano flattening him.

 

[Properossi]

Joseph Manu
Brandon Smith
Junior Paulo
Viliame Kikau

All available to negotiate from Nov 1

Don’t rate Kikau. Good size but so many stupid errors in his game.

E.G. Late line break should’ve held it, had 4 tackles or so up their sleeve, spread the next play probably a try. Forced the pass to an already marked Burton and ball to ground turnover

Other 3 are quality though

Kikau is so weak.

Not a fan at all.

cheapshot merchant and a cat

Like all the Panfers will lay down milk a penalty and no effort unless the run of the green is going their way.
Shut Luai up you shut the team down, I bet they’re glad they paid all that money for Chrichton

 

[Ultimate Warrior]

Love seeing Cleary lose! Yes, go Bunnies!

 

[yeahcaz]

Jeez staines looks terrible Playing for a top 2 team in the comp, imagine how he would’ve looked playing for us.

 

[tony soprano]

Jeez staines looks terrible Playing for a top 2 team in the comp, imagine how he would’ve looked playing for us.

You'd think he'd be taking a fair chunk of their cap too.

 

[Aceshigh]

Wow how much did Broncos pay Reynolds , wish we could get him to renege and come to us

 

[wet tiger coloured bird]

luke kiery is better than renoylds

 

[Demps]

luke kiery is better than renoylds

Josh Reynolds? Definitely...

😉

 

[Ultimate Warrior]

Jeez staines looks terrible Playing for a top 2 team in the comp, imagine how he would’ve looked playing for us.

You'd think he'd be taking a fair chunk of their cap too.

I remember people saying we should sign him and break the bank - Wrong. Wrong.

 

[Geo]

Interesting @chiranth first endorsement I’ve heard of Stains featuring some knowledge of his early playing years as a fullback.

#4 Charlie Staines: Seen this kid play throughout his juniors! Extremely fast and powerful, great goal kicker and a tremendously skilful FLB. Just an allround class act! Would be an amazing pickup.

Most of us have just heard the Phil Gould endorsements and have seen the Ferrari hit top gear on the wing for Penrith.
One thing, he doesn’t look powerful. Was he a bigger fullback in his juniors comparatively?

As Gus says, speed is power. Paps ain’t a strong guy but being so fast makes you hard to handle.

I didn’t know Staines was a goal kicker makes me want him even more

Pass on Stains…

 

[JC99]

Interesting @chiranth first endorsement I’ve heard of Stains featuring some knowledge of his early playing years as a fullback.

#4 Charlie Staines: Seen this kid play throughout his juniors! Extremely fast and powerful, great goal kicker and a tremendously skilful FLB. Just an allround class act! Would be an amazing pickup.

Most of us have just heard the Phil Gould endorsements and have seen the Ferrari hit top gear on the wing for Penrith.
One thing, he doesn’t look powerful. Was he a bigger fullback in his juniors comparatively?

As Gus says, speed is power. Paps ain’t a strong guy but being so fast makes you hard to handle.

I didn’t know Staines was a goal kicker makes me want him even more

Pass on Stains…

Not sure why you found this post from a year ago but I'm happy to admit I get some wrong, never claimed to be an expert haha. Least it gave you something to do this morning

Definitely agree lol. Has never looked as good as those first couple games, been rubbish ever since ?

 

[finnzo]

Interesting @chiranth first endorsement I’ve heard of Stains featuring some knowledge of his early playing years as a fullback.

#4 Charlie Staines: Seen this kid play throughout his juniors! Extremely fast and powerful, great goal kicker and a tremendously skilful FLB. Just an allround class act! Would be an amazing pickup.

Most of us have just heard the Phil Gould endorsements and have seen the Ferrari hit top gear on the wing for Penrith.
One thing, he doesn’t look powerful. Was he a bigger fullback in his juniors comparatively?

As Gus says, speed is power. Paps ain’t a strong guy but being so fast makes you hard to handle.

I didn’t know Staines was a goal kicker makes me want him even more

Pass on Stains…

To be fair he is a fullback playing on the wing I would like to see him have a few games at fullback before making judgment but he has definatly been a failure on the wing they should have played Bret naden he would have done a far better job

 

[Demps]

Interesting @chiranth first endorsement I’ve heard of Stains featuring some knowledge of his early playing years as a fullback.

#4 Charlie Staines: Seen this kid play throughout his juniors! Extremely fast and powerful, great goal kicker and a tremendously skilful FLB. Just an allround class act! Would be an amazing pickup.

Most of us have just heard the Phil Gould endorsements and have seen the Ferrari hit top gear on the wing for Penrith.
One thing, he doesn’t look powerful. Was he a bigger fullback in his juniors comparatively?

As Gus says, speed is power. Paps ain’t a strong guy but being so fast makes you hard to handle.

I didn’t know Staines was a goal kicker makes me want him even more

Pass on Stains…

To be fair he is a fullback playing on the wing I would like to see him have a few games at fullback before making judgment but he has definatly been a failure on the wing they should have played Bret naden he would have done a far better job

Had a good debut and game or two after.

Has some speed but looks uncoordinated and very weak + light.

Probably not ready for grade and yeah, probably wouldn't make the team if Edwards played.

How bad was his game though, as an individual? Last night. Probably worst on field.

I just love seeing Penrith lose, sorry guys ?