Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[2005magic]

We had a few qrl cup players already , kurtis Rowe , Pat Politoni , Delouise Hoeter 😂

Your point being? We have had a lot more nsw cup or whatever iteration it's up to now that haven't made the grade.

 

[yeahcaz]

The stocks of Penrith defensive coach Cameron Ciraldo continue to rise. The Panthers have clearly been the best defensive side over the past two seasons. He can now sit back and wait for the right head coaching offer, which most rookie coaches don't usually get the chance to do.

He’ll still be our number 1 choice should Madge get the sack. He’s off contract at the end of next season

 

[GNR4LIFE]

The stocks of Penrith defensive coach Cameron Ciraldo continue to rise. The Panthers have clearly been the best defensive side over the past two seasons. He can now sit back and wait for the right head coaching offer, which most rookie coaches don't usually get the chance to do.

He’ll still be our number 1 choice should Madge get the sack. He’s off contract at the end of next season

We’re probably his number 16 choice. It’s obvious he didn’t want the job and the only thing that saved Madge is the fact no one wanted the job.

 

[weststigerman]

The stocks of Penrith defensive coach Cameron Ciraldo continue to rise. The Panthers have clearly been the best defensive side over the past two seasons. He can now sit back and wait for the right head coaching offer, which most rookie coaches don't usually get the chance to do.

He’ll still be our number 1 choice should Madge get the sack. He’s off contract at the end of next season

We’re probably his number 16 choice. It’s obvious he didn’t want the job and the only thing that saved Madge is the fact no one wanted the job.

No, it’s not obvious. You’re speculating. Madge was never getting sacked, you just fell for the media spin.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

The stocks of Penrith defensive coach Cameron Ciraldo continue to rise. The Panthers have clearly been the best defensive side over the past two seasons. He can now sit back and wait for the right head coaching offer, which most rookie coaches don't usually get the chance to do.

He’ll still be our number 1 choice should Madge get the sack. He’s off contract at the end of next season

We’re probably his number 16 choice. It’s obvious he didn’t want the job and the only thing that saved Madge is the fact no one wanted the job.

No, it’s not obvious. You’re speculating. Madge was never getting sacked, you just fell for the media spin.

You can’t know for sure, but I think it’s a safe assumption. Penrith’s CEO even said that Ciraldo would wait for the right opportunity instead of walking into a mess (us)

 

[rihannafan1]

So is munster getting the flick from Melbourne ??

I would suggest no, he's not.

Don’t be to confident of that … Bellamy and the Storm are not happy campers at present , someone will be shown the door I reckon.


Apparently Bellamy was livid a few years ago when Bromwich had a little snort of coke.
So he would be really pissed a Smith and Munster.

Its funny how people say madge is too intense and yells at his players, etc
But Bellamy does it more so

Only difference is WT culture

Difference is Bellamy has set up an elite system that gets the best out of almost every player that plays there

Madge gave us the worst defensive structures we've ever had

Madge set up an elite system also.... they just played in a GF

You think Maguire is responsible for this Souths team playing in the finals? Is he also responsible for Wigan's average Superleague season this year too?

 

[rihannafan1]

@Demps exactly my point as to why we should look at getting some Q cup players in

We got Pauga.

 

[Curaeus]

Unless they've done nothing at all while the Madge saga played out and with the season now over, now would be a real good time for the club to give the members some idea what is happening regarding recruitment.

 

[avocadoontoast]

The stocks of Penrith defensive coach Cameron Ciraldo continue to rise. The Panthers have clearly been the best defensive side over the past two seasons. He can now sit back and wait for the right head coaching offer, which most rookie coaches don't usually get the chance to do.

He’ll still be our number 1 choice should Madge get the sack. He’s off contract at the end of next season

We’re probably his number 16 choice. It’s obvious he didn’t want the job and the only thing that saved Madge is the fact no one wanted the job.

No, it’s not obvious. You’re speculating. Madge was never getting sacked, you just fell for the media spin.

Do you know that for sure, or are you speculating?

 

[frullens]

So is munster getting the flick from Melbourne ??

I would suggest no, he's not.

Don’t be to confident of that … Bellamy and the Storm are not happy campers at present , someone will be shown the door I reckon.


Apparently Bellamy was livid a few years ago when Bromwich had a little snort of coke.
So he would be really pissed a Smith and Munster.

Its funny how people say madge is too intense and yells at his players, etc
But Bellamy does it more so

Only difference is WT culture

Difference is Bellamy has set up an elite system that gets the best out of almost every player that plays there

Madge gave us the worst defensive structures we've ever had

Madge set up an elite system also.... they just played in a GF

You think Maguire is responsible for this Souths team playing in the finals? Is he also responsible for Wigan's average Superleague season this year too?

In the 7 years after Madge left wigan won 3 premierships under his former assistant coach. Wigan have been hit by injury this year, still played finals.

At south's read the link below about the GF 17 and see how often madges name is specifically mentioned.

Madge bought into the team:
Alex Johnson
Dane Gagai
Campbell Graham
Cody Walker
Adam Reynolds
Damien Cook
Cam Murray
Tom Burgess

https://www.nrl.com/news/2021/09/28/1-17-souths-signings-the-gambles-bargains-and-local-lads-in-rabbitohs-rise/

 

[Newtown]

Unless they've done nothing at all while the Madge saga played out and with the season now over, now would be a real good time for the club to give the members some idea what is happening regarding recruitment.

I agree. They owe the wests tigers supporters some respect instead of leaving them out in no man's land. A statement like "Wests Tigers are currently involved in recruitment process" would at least provide some glimmer of hope. But there is no chance of that happening if those responsible for recruitment are currently on holidays, sleeping on the job or stuck somewhere in Great Britain..

 

[Curaeus]

Unless they've done nothing at all while the Madge saga played out and with the season now over, now would be a real good time for the club to give the members some idea what is happening regarding recruitment.

I agree. They owe the wests tigers supporters some respect instead of leaving them out in no man's land. A statement like "Wests Tigers are currently involved in recruitment process" would at least provide some glimmer of hope. But there is no chance of that happening if those responsible for recruitment are currently on holidays, sleeping on the job or stuck somewhere in Great Britain..

Lee mumbled something a while back about the possibility of some announcements soon after but unsurprisingly, nothing happened!

 

[WT46]

What happened to the 'big signing' that was meant to happen last week?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

What happened to the 'big signing' that was meant to happen last week?

Another baseless rumour.

 

[Eyeofthetiger 0]

What happened to the 'big signing' that was meant to happen last week?

Have a feeling it will be announced either today or tomorrow. Another 24 to 48 hours but don’t hold your breath

 

[avocadoontoast]

Unless they've done nothing at all while the Madge saga played out and with the season now over, now would be a real good time for the club to give the members some idea what is happening regarding recruitment.

I agree. They owe the wests tigers supporters some respect instead of leaving them out in no man's land. A statement like "Wests Tigers are currently involved in recruitment process" would at least provide some glimmer of hope. But there is no chance of that happening if those responsible for recruitment are currently on holidays, sleeping on the job or stuck somewhere in Great Britain..

They don't care about supporters.

 

[Needaname]

What happened to the 'big signing' that was meant to happen last week?

Have a feeling it will be announced either today or tomorrow. Another 24 to 48 hours but don’t hold your breath

Any chance it is a assistant coaching announcement?

 

[Pascoes_barber]

What happened to the 'big signing' that was meant to happen last week?

Have a feeling it will be announced either today or tomorrow. Another 24 to 48 hours but don’t hold your breath

Any chance it is a assistant coaching announcement?

You'll need to wait another 23-47 hours I'm afraid.

 

[Aubanon]

The stocks of Penrith defensive coach Cameron Ciraldo continue to rise. The Panthers have clearly been the best defensive side over the past two seasons. He can now sit back and wait for the right head coaching offer, which most rookie coaches don't usually get the chance to do.

He’ll still be our number 1 choice should Madge get the sack. He’s off contract at the end of next season

We’re probably his number 16 choice. It’s obvious he didn’t want the job and the only thing that saved Madge is the fact no one wanted the job.

No, it’s not obvious. You’re speculating. Madge was never getting sacked, you just fell for the media spin.

Madge was every chance of being sacked had the club secured his replacement.

They've just sacked both his assistance.

 

[Demps]

What happened to the 'big signing' that was meant to happen last week?

Another baseless rumour.