Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[sparci]

gotta give it to him, no matter what he's never short of a contract extension at the mighty wests tigers. comedy

 

[old_man_tiger]

Think I need to visit the forum less for the next, I dunno 3 years or so

 

[Tigers_Wests]

He must be 19 at best though. He'll have to come on like Nanai and the injuries are a concern. Look at Blore.

I think he looks much more like an edge backrower than Blore does.

If though Kautoga is considered to be an NRL edge player by the club it puts Sheens comments about Blore moving to the middle in context.

Yeah definitely a worry that he hasn't put many consecutive games together. Need some luck on the injury front here and we could see something special.

 

[The SHADOW]

What is the latest contract details about Tommy Talau. Appears the forgotten person.

Played 35 NRL games but I think he has not played a game in 2022.

If he stays with WT is he still considered a back or has he bulked up and needs to be moved to Second Rower/ Lock in 2023.

I really like this kid.

 

[851]

We miss Geo.

In more ways than one mate

 

[weststigerman]

Yeah definitely a worry that he hasn't put many consecutive games together. Need some luck on the injury front here and we could see something special.

Hopefully he can put some games together and help get the flegg side deep into finals.

Like O'kane he has a lot of work to do in defence but that will come with time.

I have our edge back rowers in this order (Not including Matamua because he should never play on an edge):
1. Tumeth
2. Kautoga
3. O'Kane

 

[BlackWhiteGold]

If he accepts the offer, he gets some of it now in this year, prior to the new contract which is what the Nofa/Gildart move is about. He has to accept the deal first though

Thanks for the info @CloudyGlock .

I do wonder whether this is a tactic to get Newcastle to offer more than us for Brooks thus we won't have to add much more next season if he does depart.

High risk but maybe not if Sheens is happy for him to stay on that amount or depart & we resign Madden without paying Brooks too much more at Newy.

 

[Dino]

Tbh it doesn't seem like sheens rates any of our potential halves that much

 

[weststigerman]

If he accepts the offer, he gets some of it now in this year, prior to the new contract which is what the Nofa/Gildart move is about. He has to accept the deal first though

Why not restructure his existing deal to pay him the 400-500k saved this year, reducing next year's payment to 600ish? That's a win for both parties, and worry about 2024 and beyond later.

 

[Leichardt61]

Why not restructure his existing deal to pay him the 400-500k saved this year, reducing next year's payment to 600ish? That's a win for both parties, and worry about 2024 and beyond later.

What you've said makes too much good sense, we are talking about Tigers admin after all.

 

[Lauren]

Despite where we are on the ladder, the Knights future looks less promising than ours, so why would Brooks or Madden entertain going there?
Plus they're on the verge of sacking their coach.

 

[Calbremic]

Let's hope Brooks management rejects that.

It's a terrible contract for us and that contract is heavily inflated.

Brooks and Doueihi in the halves just doesn't work. Neither of them have a long kicking game.

It just beggars belief. Brooks is at his lowest ebb in his career. His confidence is shattered, he's a very pale immitation of the Brooks from a few years ago. Can he recapture his form? Maybe, but at his age it may be unlikey.

I'd expect his management to sign with another club for 2024 come November and then push for a release in 2023. So long as they communicate this to the club and we can plan accordingly i'm fine with this.

Could not agree more. Please move on LB, please 🤦🏻‍♂️

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

Wests Tigers have put an offer to Brooks management for $2.3M for the next 3 years including the final year on his current contract. Tiger for life.

That's 766k a year.
I get the logic is to cover part of an existing deal but geez
Sheens/Benji must see something most of us don't.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

If he accepts the offer, he gets some of it now in this year, prior to the new contract which is what the Nofa/Gildart move is about. He has to accept the deal first though

Ok so by doing this we offset 500k shift before Nov 1 plus restructured his deal for next year at a lower rate then = alot more cash to spend on retention & recruitment.

That then brings his average year on year for 3yrs down to 600k roughly.

 

[jrtiger]

Tbh it doesn't seem like sheens rates any of our potential halves that much

I'd argue the opposite. he keeps talking about how the spine for 2025 is currently in the pathways. Koroisau's and Brooks's potential contracts both finish up at the end of 2024. I get the feeling we're going to see an entirely different spine with guys like Da Silva and Galvin there when these deals finish up.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

In March we were apparently chasing Francis Pele from Sharks for next year.
He's only young and a big lad. What's happened with him I wonder?

Also Angus Crichton would have to be a target again surely.

Bulldogs. Fitness is his biggest issue but he is one heck of a talent.
Wished we hit him harder and nabbed him. Would offer impact off the bench bigtime even for 10-15min spurts.

 

[Mighty_Tiger]

I'd argue the opposite. he keeps talking about how the spine for 2025 is currently in the pathways. Koroisau's and Brooks's potential contracts both finish up at the end of 2024. I get the feeling we're going to see an entirely different spine with guys like Da Silva and Galvin there when these deals finish up.

Both Api (MO) and Brooks proposed deal would take them through to the end of 2025, Benji's 1st season.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Bulldogs. Fitness is his biggest issue but he is one heck of a talent.
Wished we hit him harder and nabbed him. Would offer impact off the bench bigtime even for 10-15min spurts.

Fitzgibbon would be an excellent judge of a good forward. The Sharks have just re-signed two very good young props in Jesse Colqhoun and Hazelton. Plus they have signed Marty Tapau's younger brother and according to an article the "next big thing" in 17 year old prop Josh Finau.

Sharks snap up teen giant who weighs 112kg and runs like Andrew Fifita. Watch the video

‘Where’s he come from?’: 112kg teen giant runs like Fifita, and tears teams apart

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[TheDaBoss]

Lol glock

 

[pawsandclaws1]

V’landys set to scrap controversial signing deadline as top clubs ‘troubleshoot’ mid-season

V’landys set to scrap controversial signing deadline as top clubs ‘troubleshoot’ mid-season

www.foxsports.com.au