TurnStyle
Well-known member
Don't remember Garrick before Manly, but don't doubt you on his improvement. Laurie had a good first season at the tigers before falling out of favour and subsequently being usurped by a kid playing his first game who has imo already shown himself at least a far better investment, if not simply a better fullback.Garrick improved as a player when he went to Manly - playing outside some quality players. Not sure where Laurie's future lies, but we have done very little as a club to develop any players in recent times yet plenty leave and hold positions in other more successful clubs.
You can't change the past, you can't change the present and as it stands currently - whatever circumstances or mitigating factors there may be for Laurie - there is simply no comparison between the two.
But that's just my opinion. One of the interesting things about sport is differing views and favourite players; people just like how certain players go and aren't keen on others. I'm not a fan of Laurie, don't see much in Sam Walker either. Never liked DCE, but big fan of Jake T....