Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Tigers_Wests said:
Might just be me, but I don't think Terrell would add much to our roster. A young middle with potential and we already have plenty. It would also block one of those guys we already have. Taylan is the one I would be interested in, but he wouldn't come without Terrell and worse Tyrone.
Click to expand...
Why do we just automatically make the assumption that another club will sign all 3? I know that’s what they would like, but it’s probably not going to happen.

I’d be more than happy to make an offer to Taylan and Terrel, if they don’t come no great loss.
 
Not a huge fan of signing "brothers"just because ONE of them is what we need.Done it already,and jury remains out
If Nofa is truly gone,we can take our time ..get thru half a dozen games or so..see whats on the market..and remain opportunistic
We have little idea of what we need atm...it will be clearer in April
 
Player movement throughout the year is not uncommon. I would be more inclined to keeping the spot open and assess what the area of need is throughout the first part of the season, and who is available to fill that need. Whoever gets the nod in the 2 and 5 to start the year could both have blinders. Taylan May would be a good pick-up, but I don't think we should be making a decision too quickly on who to fill the vacancy Nofa creates.
 
clontarfkid said:
Not a huge fan of signing "brothers"just because ONE of them is what we need.Done it already,and jury remains out
If Nofa is truly gone,we can take our time ..get thru half a dozen games or so..see whats on the market..and remain opportunistic
We have little idea of what we need atm...it will be clearer in April
Click to expand...
Taylan & Terrel straight into the 17

The other bro can stay in France
 
rusted-on said:
I would rather cop that than either of the other 2. Anasta wasn't exactly known for his toughness, and he didn't even take a knee. Like I said previously, it's not something that should go without punishment, but it is not comparable to the other 2 incidents.
Click to expand...
Not comparable only in outcome. Flower hit Hohaia while he was standing. That was bad enough, but then he followed it up with the second punch on the ground.

Granted, Williams hit O'Neill from the side and he did't see it coming, but I doubt Anasta did either. There was no warning at all.

You are only looking at the knockouts, not the act.
 
weststigers said:
Not comparable only in outcome. Flower hit Hohaia while he was standing. That was bad enough, but then he followed it up with the second punch on the ground.

Granted, Williams hit O'Neill from the side and he did't see it coming, but I doubt Anasta did either. There was no warning at all.

You are only looking at the knockouts, not the act.
Click to expand...

I'm looking at the individual acts as a whole (Flower went on to hit Hohaia again when on the ground, and WIlliams attacked someone completely unprepared and unaware he was even in sight), and both Williams and Flower knocked out their opponents. The difference in outcome is often due to the difference in the action when it comes to these type of incidents. That being said, I'm happy to agree to disagree.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
rusted-on said:
And you're entitled to. I just don't think the tap put on Anasta can be compared to a hit from someone coming out of the line and clocking someone like Williams did, or hitting someone when they are already on the ground like Flower did. Each to their own :)
Click to expand...
They were all.ar the Ruck... Williams.didnt come.out of the line,.he.played the ball... Oneill. Was at marker... Same with faalogo (had t g r ball) anasta marker
They're as bad as each other imo
 
rusted-on said:
I'm looking at the individual acts as a whole (Flower went on to hit Hohaia again when on the ground, and WIlliams attacked someone completely unprepared and unaware he was even in sight), and both Williams and Flower knocked out their opponents. The difference in outcome is often due to the difference in the action when it comes to these type of incidents. That being said, I'm happy to agree to disagree.
Click to expand...
A fully loaded punch to the face is a fully loaded punch to the face. The only difference is the outcome of the force. Anasta could count himself lucky. The force was there to knock him out. So was the intent.

But yes, let's agree to disagree.
 
innsaneink said:
They were all.ar the Ruck... Williams.didnt come.out of the line,.he.played the ball... Oneill. Was at marker... Same with faalogo (had t g r ball) anasta marker
They're as bad as each other imo
Click to expand...

Anasta was directly in front of Faalogo, whereas O'Neill retreated from 2nd marker, and was at least 10 away from Williams. Williams went out of his way to get at O'Neill, Faalogo hit someone right in front of him. Like I said previously, none of these incidents should escape punishment, but they are not all the same in severity.
 
rusted-on said:
Anasta was directly in front of Faalogo, whereas O'Neill retreated from 2nd marker, and was at least 10 away from Williams. Williams went out of his way to get at O'Neill, Faalogo hit someone right in front of him. Like I said previously, none of these incidents should escape punishment, but they are not all the same in severity.
Click to expand...
Ok mate 👍
 
weststigers said:
A fully loaded punch to the face is a fully loaded punch to the face. The only difference is the outcome of the force. Anasta could count himself lucky. The force was there to knock him out. So was the intent.

But yes, let's agree to disagree.
Click to expand...

Look at the video again. Faalogo didn't have the space to deliver a "fully loaded" punch to the face, Williams had 10m to load up and deliver to someone looking the other way, and Flower delivered his 2nd blow to someone unable to defend themselves due to being knocked out already. Faalogo may have intended to knock Anasta out, but intent means little if you can't execute. Have a good night :)
 
rusted-on said:
Look at the video again. Faalogo didn't have the space to deliver a "fully loaded" punch to the face, Williams had 10m to load up and deliver to someone looking the other way, and Flower delivered his 2nd blow to someone unable to defend themselves due to being knocked out already. Faalogo may have intended to knock Anasta out, but intent means little if you can't execute. Have a good night :)
Click to expand...
I thought we agreed to disagree? I still disagree. Your analysis is flawed. But I won't change your mind, so I left it. Why haven't you?
 
Manly’s one was more creative, getting players to draw the logo’s of opposition clubs.
 
weststigers said:
I thought we agreed to disagree? I still disagree. Your analysis is flawed. But I won't change your mind, so I left it. Why haven't you?
Click to expand...

You raised a point on your way out, I just responded to that point. Agreeing to disagree is not raising further points while critiquing my analysis at the same time. That's just asking to continue the discussion 🙄
 
Tiger_Yoshi said:
Alex Lobb to be given top 30 contract
Click to expand...
It may end up happening but definitely won't be first choice. He is locked on a dev contract until end of 25 and hasn't even made his first grade debut. We also had very little room to move with our 2025 top 30 spots so that would be another reason I don't see us just upgrading Lobb at this point. We already have around 10 that don't have 20 first grade games combined.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 517 (members: 38, guests: 479)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top