Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

jirskyr said:
I think as time progresses we will continue to think of Benji with more and more rose-coloured glasses and those highlight reels will stick out more and more.
Click to expand...
This is already in full affect. He was never the same player when he came back from rugby. That player that set up that Ayshford try was long gone. He was no longer one of the top players in the comp. Still scratch my head how a player could regress so much without injuries.
 
BAGNF05 said:
Not often I say this but I’m with GNR, he’s been average at best most weeks. We need to expect better than mediocre to climb the ladder.
Click to expand...

Even a broken clock gets it right twice a day.

Up until a handful of games last year (which was a contract year btw), Seyfarth has been one of the most ineffective forwards to ever put on a Tigers jersey. And that’s bloody saying something! Before that mini run, he was averaging barely 30m a game. And we’ve now had two spoons in years where he has featured regularly (obviously not all his fault, just one of many contributors).

The fact that you have posters like paws and Vicious singing his praises is enough of an indicator that he is a glorified plodder. Two of the worst judges of talent to ever grace this forum.
 
Batmans Parents said:
Even a broken clock gets it right twice a day.

Up until a handful of games last year (which was a contract year btw), Seyfarth has been one of the most ineffective forwards to ever put on a Tigers jersey. And that’s bloody saying something! Before that mini run, he was averaging barely 30m a game. And we’ve now had two spoons in years where he has featured regularly (obviously not all his fault, just one of many contributors).

The fact that you have posters like paws and Vicious singing his praises is enough of an indicator that he is a glorified plodder. Two of the worst judges of talent to ever grace this forum.
Click to expand...
Imo I think seyfarth should of never be used in the prop rotation and I think that this contributes to his poor numbers
Not saying he’s a world beater but just used incorrectly when the cupboard is bare
 
pawsandclaws1 said:
I believe he is a genuine NRL player but that is a decision for our coaches to make.
Click to expand...
Tiger Karen said:
Well you know my views on the topic.

That is to say, the most powerful and dominant player I’ve ever seen is Bobby Lindner.

And it takes skill to pose such an insurmountable threat to the opposition and suck the footy life out of them until they are an unrecognisable heaving mass of toxic sludge.

Skill kind sir, is not just “bears dancing on barrels.”

With the accompanying 20 years of living off a single pass!!
Click to expand...

Benji hasn’t been living off a single pass though.
His step & pass style is what made him.

People forget easily his impact because as fans we remember the performances (more bad than good - especially the passes in the stands)

Benji however did things no one else did at the time or prior really let alone even really thought of - was he consistent heck no but he imprinted on the game like no one has in the modern era.

Being involved in junior footy I have never seen the kids of all shapes/sizes have a player imprint like he did before or after - often nearly every kid would do the step and try the flick passes which we now see the steps and flick passes often during the season.

He made a very big imprint on the game attacking wise despite his record with us.
 
Does anyone know who is currently on our injured/unavailable list atm? I know a lot doesn't get released to the public but a good indication of where we are and who could potentially play in our trials would be good to know
 
How TF is Gus allowed 2 speak with Daniel Suluku
Fifita and let him tour the facilities when he's
still under contract until the end of 2025? He's
already freed up $2m with retiring Josh Jackson,
Tevita Pangai Jnr & getting rid of their old
captain Raymond Faitala Mariner. Not to 4get
they also got cap relief for Bailey Biondi-Odo
for last year as well & freeing up a roster spot
for him. Completely overhauled the top 30 in
the last few years, credit to him. Glad we have
new people running the show. The last CEO and
Football director seem even more incompetent
now than before they left. We need 2 keep making
these cutthroat moves we made with Nofa in
relation to the club & cap moving forward. Full stop
 
Kaito said:
How TF is Gus allowed 2 speak with Daniel Suluku
Fifita and let him tour the facilities when he's
still under contract until the end of 2025? He's
already freed up $2m with retiring Josh Jackson,
Tevita Pangai Jnr & getting rid of their old
captain Raymond Faitala Mariner. Not to 4get
they also got cap relief for Bailey Biondi-Odo
for last year as well & freeing up a roster spot
for him. Completely overhauled the top 30 in
the last few years, credit to him. Glad we have
new people running the show. The last CEO and
Football director seem even more incompetent
now than before they left. We need 2 keep making
these cutthroat moves we made with Nofa in
relation to the club & cap moving forward. Full stop
Click to expand...
Liking the new style 🤟

Who is
Daniel Suluku Fifita ?
 
Kaito said:
How TF is Gus allowed 2 speak with Daniel Suluku
Fifita and let him tour the facilities when he's
still under contract until the end of 2025? He's
already freed up $2m with retiring Josh Jackson,
Tevita Pangai Jnr & getting rid of their old
captain Raymond Faitala Mariner. Not to 4get
they also got cap relief for Bailey Biondi-Odo
for last year as well & freeing up a roster spot
for him. Completely overhauled the top 30 in
the last few years, credit to him. Glad we have
new people running the show. The last CEO and
Football director seem even more incompetent
now than before they left. We need 2 keep making
these cutthroat moves we made with Nofa in
relation to the club & cap moving forward. Full stop
Click to expand...
Jackson Topine has not been to pre season training someone was telling me the other day so maybe a trade
 
innsaneink said:
Liking the new style 🤟

Who is
Daniel Suluku Fifita ?
Click to expand...
Debuted for the Chooks a few years back, and was touted as a future star because of his size and athleticism, but he's had a rocky start to his career through poor on field discipline. I didn't really notice him for Souths this year.
He seems like a serviceable prop, with plenty of size and aggression, but needs to learn how to keep it in check before he can be of any use to a team. Very much a fringe 1st grader at this stage
 
Kaito said:
How TF is Gus allowed 2 speak with Daniel Suluku
Fifita and let him tour the facilities when he's
still under contract until the end of 2025? He's
already freed up $2m with retiring Josh Jackson,
Tevita Pangai Jnr & getting rid of their old
captain Raymond Faitala Mariner. Not to 4get
they also got cap relief for Bailey Biondi-Odo
for last year as well & freeing up a roster spot
for him. Completely overhauled the top 30 in
the last few years, credit to him. Glad we have
new people running the show. The last CEO and
Football director seem even more incompetent
now than before they left. We need 2 keep making
these cutthroat moves we made with Nofa in
relation to the club & cap moving forward. Full stop
Click to expand...
I wonder how much of the dogs cap is absorbed in those terminations.

I don't rate their team compared to ours. Especially when we get luai next year. We're stronger on the park and stronger in depth. The only place they have our measure is the outside backs.
 
hammertime said:
I wonder how much of the dogs cap is absorbed in those terminations.

I don't rate their team compared to ours. Especially when we get luai next year. We're stronger on the park and stronger in depth. The only place they have our measure is the outside backs.
Click to expand...
Agree.

And I think everyone expected CC and Gus to lift their players but it hasn’t been forthcoming.

Then I think Gus fired a few warning shots over ccs bow last season.

My bet is that cc regrets his decision not to join us.

It’s become a graveyard for marquee. Their fans are very upset.
 
hammertime said:
I wonder how much of the dogs cap is absorbed in those terminations.

I don't rate their team compared to ours. Especially when we get luai next year. We're stronger on the park and stronger in depth. The only place they have our measure is the outside backs.
Click to expand...
Attaboy💪 🐅
 
Kaito said:
How TF is Gus allowed 2 speak with Daniel Suluku
Fifita and let him tour the facilities when he's
still under contract until the end of 2025? He's
already freed up $2m with retiring Josh Jackson,
Tevita Pangai Jnr & getting rid of their old
captain Raymond Faitala Mariner. Not to 4get
they also got cap relief for Bailey Biondi-Odo
for last year as well & freeing up a roster spot
for him. Completely overhauled the top 30 in
the last few years, credit to him. Glad we have
new people running the show. The last CEO and
Football director seem even more incompetent
now than before they left. We need 2 keep making
these cutthroat moves we made with Nofa in
relation to the club & cap moving forward. Full stop
Click to expand...
I actually had a feeling that Gus might be talking to Taulmalolo on the qt ?
 
balmain boy said:
That's also because he went for the all or nothing play almost every time. As a player he was incapable of being a steady headed tactical oriented player. If there was a 1/100 play available to him he'd pass/kick the ball every time and turn over the ball cheaply just as often as he set up points
Click to expand...
Horses for courses. Blake Green would not have elevated those Wests Tigers sides into finals contention.
 
Kaito said:
How TF is Gus allowed 2 speak with Daniel Suluku
Fifita and let him tour the facilities when he's
still under contract until the end of 2025? He's
already freed up $2m with retiring Josh Jackson,
Tevita Pangai Jnr & getting rid of their old
captain Raymond Faitala Mariner. Not to 4get
they also got cap relief for Bailey Biondi-Odo
for last year as well & freeing up a roster spot
for him. Completely overhauled the top 30 in
the last few years, credit to him. Glad we have
new people running the show. The last CEO and
Football director seem even more incompetent
now than before they left. We need 2 keep making
these cutthroat moves we made with Nofa in
relation to the club & cap moving forward. Full stop
Click to expand...
They are at 30 out of 30. Most likely will sign him to Development contract so that the cap is in tact.
A complete top 30 turn over since 2021.
Is that a good thing, or a sign of a horrible state of a club over the past 3 years?
 
Needaname said:
They are at 30 out of 30. Most likely will sign him to Development contract so that the cap is in tact.
A complete top 30 turn over since 2021.
Is that a good thing, or a sign of a horrible state of a club over the past 3 years?
Click to expand...
Zac Montgomery quit NRL so he's out of their 30.

Have heard a bunch of rumours that seem to suggest Jackson Topine is gone too.

So they're at 28 or 29.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
KingRobbie said:
Zac Montgomery quit NRL so he's out of their 30.

Have heard a bunch of rumours that seem to suggest Jackson Topine is gone too.

So they're at 28 or 29.
Click to expand...
Hmmm. Wait and see I guess.
Also wasn’t Topine part of the 2021 squad?
 
Needaname said:
They are at 30 out of 30. Most likely will sign him to Development contract so that the cap is in tact.
A complete top 30 turn over since 2021.
Is that a good thing, or a sign of a horrible state of a club over the past 3 years?
Click to expand...

Yeah, a lot of questions will be asked from coach
and team this year 4 the dogs. Don't like em lol
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 191 (members: 8, guests: 183)
Forever online: Tigergran, Geo
Back
Top