Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Tigerdazz2 said:
Staines doesn't get enough good ball, he is under utilised in my honest opinion. He takes the ball up strongly when he comes infield to give the forwards a break.

He is lightning fast, if he could get his hands on the ball more often and I mean good ball not hospital passes or passes below his knees or above his shoulders (like he seems to cop a lot) he and the team would be a lot more potent in attack.
He is also a damn good defender for his size especially considering he suffered that perforated bowel, others coming back from injuries haven't been as "brave" as he has, Adam Douehi is a good example.
Click to expand...
In addition to this post, can someone explain what Bula does as a fullback that Staines could not do better ?
 
Last edited:
jirskyr said:
I think any of these journos talking about some kind of "transformation" of Brooks must have never watched him play footy. He's playing more or less the same output as at the Tigers, he just has some much better players around him to take up his slack.

For example The Mole here says it's great that Brooks can take pressure of DCE, but actually the opposite is true, that DCE takes pressure of Brooks who can focus on the strengths of his running game.

Mole then talks about Blore, which is really the same deal. Always been a willing player who had a terrible run of injuries at Penrith and Tigers, never really got enough game time to max out his performances. I still think he's rather average at Storm but he does his job and Storm aren't looking for stars, they are looking for willing contributors to an already excellently-coached system. Mole says "Tigers may regret letting him go" which is a massive oversight of the fact that actually Panthers were the first to let Blore go.

The problem with Tigers is we can't only recruit and hold onto average honest first-graders. We need game breakers to help convert those willing performances into wins. For many games of the past few rounds Tigers have been well in contention for the win, to be let down by inexperience, ill-discipline and dumb play. We have a lot of guys who haven't played much first grade. Shawn Blore doesn't change that equation at all, which is why at least I think the signings of Luai and Turuva are very encouraging for Tigers.
Click to expand...

I do laugh a little bit that all the ex Tigers doing well at Manly is because they are playing in some super team or something … they came 12th last year … and i still think they are likely to be one and done this year …

the most frustrating thing I found with Brooks at the Tigers was his kicking game … his bombs were ineffectual …land in the in goal or didn’t have enough height so the chasers couldn’t provide pressure … he also can’t put a grubber in without it hitting the back fence … he doesn’t need to worry about that now with DCE who is still one of the best general kickers in the game

It’s still an issue for him..as we saw a few weeks ago when DCE was on origin duty …

I think he is playing better this year … not that he is going to win the Dally M otr anything … maybe he just needed to be more relaxed …

Blore is playing well…Bellamy ain’t going to be starting duds …I actually thought he played well here when he wasn’t injured … why they let him go when he wanted to stay here I’ll never know … Benji was all over that call too..

But the biggest improvement I have seen is Talau …. Not that Madge is going to be picking him in Origin next year …. But he is a solid competent first grader …. Never saw that side of him here ..and neither did Sheens or Benji last year apparently …
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
Ravalawa would walk into our 17, he'd be the best winger at the club by a country mile. But he's still not good enough for almost every other club. That's how atrocious our roster management is. Rava is stupid, and he can't defend to save himself, but neither can any of our players. At least he's big, fast and strong which is why he craps all over our tiny, slow and weak babies.
if we can offload Naden, Toa, Feledy, Lobb and possibly Staines, as well as release Faatape and Alaimalo then there might be spot for him
 
balmain boy said:
Ravalawa would walk into our 17, he'd be the best winger at the club by a country mile. But he's still not good enough for almost every other club. That's how atrocious our roster management is. Rava is stupid, and he can't defend to save himself, but neither can any of our players. At least he's big, fast and strong which is why he craps all over our tiny, slow and weak babies.
if we can offload Naden, Toa, Feledy, Lobb and possibly Staines, as well as release Faatape and Alaimalo then there might be spot for him
Click to expand...
Keep To’a and I would give Staines one last crack playing NRL as a winger before pulling the plug on him, but it seems like Benji has written him off already.
The rest of them can’t help us be any better in 2025 so we might as well offload them ASAP.
 
Vicious said:
Keep To’a and I would give Staines one last crack playing NRL as a winger before pulling the plug on him, but it seems like Benji has written him off already.
The rest of them can’t help us be any better in 2025 so we might as well offload them ASAP.
Click to expand...
Staines is an NRL winger and with Luai he will see more and better ball. I am unsure as to why Staines attracts so much enfilade fire as he is a genuine first grader who doesn't lack courage.
 
Fish88 said:
Sad reading isn’t it that Naden, Toa, Feledy, Lobb, Faatape, Alaimalo are all taking up too 30 spots! There’s 6 players from the backline alone taking up nrl spots without even looking at the forwards. Our roster is putrid.
Click to expand...

It’s a horror story… and add paying Klemmer and Bateman $1.5 m next year …. They are massively behind the 8 ball already
 
Vicious said:
In addition to this post, can someone explain what Bula does as a fullback that Staines could not do better ?
Click to expand...
Staines gets smashed in the middle, doesn't have the evasion of Bula. I think Turuva takes Staines' spot next year. I just hope we find a metre eating winger for the other side. Ravalawa would be a good option, but he's about as dumb as Naden so that's a worry.
 
Tom Shines said:
It’s a horror story… and add paying Klemmer and Bateman $1.5 m next year …. They are massively behind the 8 ball already
Click to expand...
Thank you Tim Sheens.

That is a much bigger concern than some fringe backs, mainly because they are contracts that are impossible to move.

At least Alaimalo off this year and Naden off next year.
 
Wearyfan22 said:
Staines comes in for a disproportionate amount of heat on this forum. Not perfect but as you say he is an NRL quality winger.
Click to expand...

I thought he had his best game of the season last weekend…

I’m not a massive fan to be honest …he re-signed pretty late in the offseason … assuming the alternative market for him wasnt great …

Still …not the biggest problem in the squad ..
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 421 (members: 30, guests: 391)
Back
Top