InBulaWeTrust
Well-known member
dislike this suggestion, why trade a young centre who is injury prone but isnt bad, for an old winger who is injury prone and problematic?
Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion
- Thread starter MacDougall
- Start date
TurnStyle
Well-known member
Good one. Let's move on.
He had the number 6 on his back but Sheens would have him defend on the wing at times. If my memory serves me correctly, on the play in question he was back deep for a kick in the wing position. Hodgo fielded the kick and then passed it to Benji before he took off down the field and threw the flick pass.
innsaneink
Well-known member
They were talking about JWH on. 360 last night and said every premiership team has a forward leader just like him
Roosters JWH
Storm - NAS
Penrith JFH and Leota
WTs = position vacant
Roosters JWH
Storm - NAS
Penrith JFH and Leota
WTs = position vacant
really hope we bring in an assistant other than Brett Hodgson.
Love him as a player and person and probably a great coach -- but we need to have someone there next to Benji who is not his mate.
It's either Morris or Hodgo and an independent super experienced assistant for me.
Otherwise again -- just a 2005 old boys reunion which hasnt worked so far.
Love him as a player and person and probably a great coach -- but we need to have someone there next to Benji who is not his mate.
It's either Morris or Hodgo and an independent super experienced assistant for me.
Otherwise again -- just a 2005 old boys reunion which hasnt worked so far.
hank37w
Well-known member
Just tall for his age. 🤣
bigsiro
Well-known member
Yep.
Papalii and Stef were established first-graders, but not inspirational leaders. We need to recruit at least one of these in the forwards now. It would be a shame to go into 2025 only pinning hopes on second year guys or juniors with potential.
(I can’t count Klemmer and Bateman. Which is also a shame, because during their careers they each did have a kind of leadership/inspirational aura, but nowadays, as players they aren’t impactful enough to warrant that kind of respect, that is, if they even warrant their spots on a roster at all).
A marquee forward would be a dream, but perhaps unrealistic, especially as they’re tied up.
Are there any other such forwards on the market? Or coming on in 2026?
I put three names down, who are all worse than the player we'd get....that's right, mediocre is the Wests Tigers way.
He's faster than all three as well
InBulaWeTrust
Well-known member
Anymore To'o rumours doing the rounds at the moment? I want a good laugh
BlackWhiteGold
Well-known member
Inspirational forward hmmm a forward who can pick up his team mates & say follow me boys ... Leo Thompson only one I can think of, maybe Ethan Bullemor in terms of his effort & energy.
EDIT: I should add NAS to the list if he does become available.
Last edited:
weststigerman
Well-known member
I don't think Leota is a forward leader, but he's probably Penrith's best prop. Stef was ours, but only showed up 3-4 games a year.
We've tried to recruit those before and it hasn't gone well - Packer, Tamou, Klemmer etc. Pole offers a lot in attack but doesn't offer much in the way of leading the line speed in defence etc. As it stands, 2025 it's most definitely vacant.
Hopefully this is priority 1 when November 1st comes around.
BlackWhiteGold
Well-known member
Just putting this out there as a suggestion given lack of activity atm. I don't mean this as a joke as he has been a joke for Dragons fans this year.
Blake Lawrie
Could he be revitalised at a new club and find the form that had him win Dragons POY last year and in leadership group?
Personally haven't watched much of him, just putting it out there.
Blake Lawrie
Could he be revitalised at a new club and find the form that had him win Dragons POY last year and in leadership group?
Personally haven't watched much of him, just putting it out there.
Bigscreentv
Well-known member
Unlikely. He's overweight and lacks discipline.
We need more mobility, power in my opinion.
The Chad
Well-known member
This is a list of intimidating forwards. Roosters are done dirty as you can add Radley, Collins & Crieghton to JWH.
Tigers are as tough as ice cream sitting on the kitchen bench for an hour.
Bateman & Klemmer are our best for it, Seyfarth has some potential. But the idea of getting a more intimidating presence in our middle was shouted down for calls for 'impact forwards' like Hunt. Horsburgh would have been a good add. Unless someone from within develops an attitude of no longer allowing the team to get bullied, we will still suffer from "intimidating" packs.
Strider
Well-known member
Tigers are clearly going for another prop, after Hunt. Have been in talks with a few. I don't think anyone at the club are not aware they need one. It will be a matter of if they can get a good one for next year.
Who cares? What he learns at Penrith he brings to the tigers.
Tomorrow.
Staff online
-
DempsModerator