Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Vicious said:
I believe quite a few values I noted are likely less than what they are actually being paid, I can’t see which ones would be likely to be higher than their true contract value, can you ?
Click to expand...
That's the point though; we don't know their true contract value.

The only thing 'close' to knowing their value is what is speculated in the media, but even then, even when they have inside knowledge, oftentimes it is different from platform to platform.

If someone is out even 50k on each contract, which would be a fair guess, that would equate to $1.5 million they would be out over the Top 30 squad.

It's a redundant exercise.

I appreciate what you're doing and it can be fun to play Supercoach recruitment manager, but if we're using our own estimates in order to make bold statements about the state of our cap, when we have literally no actual way of verifying the numbers, then those statements mean 2/5ths of bugger all in terms of the reality of Wests' cap situation.
 
Tom Shines said:
Possibly …. Doobie hasn’t signed next year either …so there is $800k there that you have over estimated already….

they can also move on Latu as he will be surplus to requirements
Click to expand...
Ummmm, I beg every last one of your pardons?

Cart -> Horse

^You.
 
Tom Shines said:
Like it or not ..Brown’s deal is the new benchmark ….he is not much more than an above average player ..hardly close to elite … but he is on $1.3m from next year … Burton’s contract is old news

The salary cap is going to going to go up considerably in the next 3 years ….PVL is predicting the new TV deal to be 3 billion which is 50 percent more …the elite players salaries will increase at a similar clip …
Click to expand...
Wait

We ranted about Luai being on 1.2 and Newcastle sign brown on 1.3!!!

But I take the point. If it's Galvin, 1.3 sets a new landmark. If it's Latu, were not going to get away paying him 500k. The market has risen.

All said and done, I would rather Burton at 5/8.
 
Vicious said:
I don’t think Shane Flanagan is every players cup of tea as their coach.
As an example Flanagan has openly criticised Tuipolutu for getting in the face of his opposition after scoring a try, I don’t think Benji has a problem with Turuva doing it and nor should he, we need to be a team who back each other and celebrate all the small wins throughout each game.
Blake Lowrie seems like someone with a bit of attitude and someone who needs his ego to be fed to get the best out of him.
My intel tells me Jack Bird is very similar and so far is loving life and his time in the current Wests Tigers environment, so who knows it could also be the tonic Blake Lowrie needs to rediscover his best form.
Shane Flanagan loved Jack Bird when he was helping him win a premiership with the Sharks, but didn’t like his joker attitude when things were not going so well at the Dragons. Make of that what you will, but players generally want consistency from their coach throughout the good and the bad and are more likely to get that from Benji.
Click to expand...
The whole Jack Bird thing has me stumped.

Flanno punts Lomax, the only talent the Dragons have had in ages. I mean punts with him taking unders at Parra.

Then Flanno punts Bird for Val Holmes. Now I trust Flanno's judgement, in him knowing which player is better... IMHO I think they are closer in ability. That said even if you don't put Bird in at Center, you could still play him as a utility. Obviously cap space matters and he may have just needed the cash for Gutho, etc. ... It still seems like a mystery to me as you had someone who was really performing...

Unless ofcourse Flanno wants the decks clear for Kyle.
 
Tom Shines said:
I think he will stay …but I never put much stock in answers like this to mediia questions …what is he going to say ? I can’t wait until my deal is up so I can get out of here?
Click to expand...
True I know all players say the same thing just tow the company line, " I leave it up to my manager " blah blah blah. But unlike most he grew up a supporter so actually believe him, if someone offers him a contract that is massively over what we offer then he might go, I couldn't see him leaving if we are 100k below the best offer.
 
hank37w said:
Reports I saw was saying it was just for this year which some would say was a bit of a risk, but as you say, it looks like St.George will be utilising him in first grade so he will still be in the shop window.

Wish him luck and hope he goes okay and manages to pick up another season or 2 somewhere even if the dollar amount is coming down in comparison to what it once was.
Click to expand...
That's why I reckon he took it, at least while he's in the shop window clubs can see that he can offer something at his age, he can't do that in reserve grade so it would have ment retirement.
 
Kelce68 said:
Not only that, he's got a seemingly straightforward path to the starting hooking role by the time he's 21. There is then Haywood behind him. Even if Api goes around for another year, I don't think that affects a whole lot of anything.

I'll be highly, highly surprised if he entertains going anywhere.
Click to expand...
He seems to have a good head on his shoulders, apart from having a laugh at the spoonbowl and getting chipped for it by Richo on the night, he has openly said he is more than happy to wait behind api and learn cause he's the best hooker in the game. Not a lot of young guys do that today, like Latu telling Benji I'll play wherever the team needs me. Normally the up and coming players are trying to dictate where they play to the coach.
 
The Chad said:
Blake Lawrie, as the 5-6th middle option at the club, is a good depth option. He can come into the side, do a job & not cost you a game.

Not many starting spots available in the middle at the moment.
Click to expand...
The thing is our current 5 and 6 prop are Kit and Vaha Ako - so Lawrie is a big upgrade on those esp given his experience. In reality he would be our number 4 prop with Sione Fainu at 5 and Kit at 6.
 
crazycat said:
The whole Jack Bird thing has me stumped.

Flanno punts Lomax, the only talent the Dragons have had in ages. I mean punts with him taking unders at Parra.

Then Flanno punts Bird for Val Holmes. Now I trust Flanno's judgement, in him knowing which player is better... IMHO I think they are closer in ability. That said even if you don't put Bird in at Center, you could still play him as a utility. Obviously cap space matters and he may have just needed the cash for Gutho, etc. ... It still seems like a mystery to me as you had someone who was really performing...

Unless ofcourse Flanno wants the decks clear for Kyle.
Click to expand...
I think flanno is stinking it up at drags few more loses and he will morph into madge's unpopular half time aggressive head look, cracks starting to appear after he criticized Illias's game as well.
If some of his older recruits go down injured that will compound the problems there.
 
Tiger-ferret said:
Of course and I don’t disagree with that but that only creates discontent personally and throughout the squad. I doubt any player would play their absolute best on 250k for a full 26 rounds when they know they can get 800k. Especially when there are managers and family in their ear.
Click to expand...
From what was presented in the media, Richardson offered an upgraded and extended contract. Galvin is playing beside Luai, one of the NRL's best halves. There are few clubs which could offer that opportunity. His manager and family do not have to balance the club's books.
 
crazycat said:
Wait

We ranted about Luai being on 1.2 and Newcastle sign brown on 1.3!!!

But I take the point. If it's Galvin, 1.3 sets a new landmark. If it's Latu, were not going to get away paying him 500k. The market has risen.

All said and done, I would rather Burton at 5/8.
Click to expand...

Who ranted about Luai ? Not me !
 
Tom Shines said:
Why would Latu want to stay here ..and why would they want to pay him to continue to play reserve grade ?
Click to expand...
I agree that I believe he has a lot of talent and is too good to be playing NSW Cup much longer, BUT he’s another that hasn’t exactly blitzed it playing NSW Cup as yet and really should be if he is wanting to prove he should not be left out of our NRL squad.
I know not many agree with me, but I still think Latu has enough pace, power and ability to be an NRL starting centre.
As long as he is being paid 500k per season, I think he would be happy with that to play alongside of his brothers while he is still young.
Also ask the question, which rival NRL club would he be a definite starting 5/8 at ?
 
Vicious said:
Also ask the question, which rival NRL club would he be a definite starting 5/8 at ?
Click to expand...
It still doesn’t mean he will want to stay here though … he won’t be playing in the halves ahead of Galvin and JL on 1 million plus each …. At least at another club he will have more chance…
 
BlackWhiteGold said:
Club injury report email to members:

Bula & Turuva (ankles from Parra game) both looking good for tomorrow; Naden (round 5 or 6), Olam (going through rehab protocols, should be an update soon), Luke Laulilii (passed HIA protocols & will be ok to play next week).
Click to expand...
Thought Olam was looking at a backdoor option for retirement. What's happening there?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 446 (members: 4, guests: 442)
Back
Top