Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Tom Shines]

Couldn’t agree more,
Anyone thinking we were going to beat the Storm in Melbourne after they got beat the week before must have been dreaming.
Forget this game and go on our previous results we have improved immensely since last year.
How we perform this week against the Rabbitohs will tell us a lot about where we are heading for the rest of the year.

The Storm were 5-3 and we were 5-4 … perhaps I didn’t see a win coming our way , against a good team that is hard to beat at home, but did you see that beat down ? Anyway, the fans can think what they want…it’s a problem when the players don’t seem to think they can win …

The hate for Seyfarth seems out of line with the performance yesterday.

Hate is a strong word … I know you read the board everyday, so I’m assuming you honestly don’t think the criticism of him started yesterday .

 

[SwervinMervin]

That’s cause Galvin has clocked off…. He only wants to be involved in the fancy plays

Galvin needs a really good defender on either side of him. He’s a light frame and will always be a target for big mobile backrowers to isolate him. Unfortunately, at the moment, he doesn’t have great support either side of him in defence and he’s being exposed in a way some other halves don’t.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

The hate for Seyfarth seems out of line with the performance yesterday.

He was hardly the worst in a bad performance. I'd argue May played worse yesterday.

Galvin is being exposed badly in defence last few weeks.

You can't argue anyone had a good game but he was atrocious. Cleary not playing for the team just himself and id almost float the possibility there could have been a tinge of tanking in there.

 

[rex2ce]

I don't see your post as pointless. I think we all feel the same. However I feel it comes down to attitude that comes from our coaching staff. We knew they were coming for us and we still didn't turn up. Clear as day in the sheds before a ball was kicked.

If you don't turn up in the right frame of mind you will get flogged. The only teams that get flogged by 60 are the ones that give up.

Benji let that happen. That's on him for me. If he doesn't insist on a certain culture then that's what happens. I've never said a bad word about benji but this one is on him.

Like spoonball was last season

 

[upthetigers]

We are in desperate need of an another alpha prop with experience & voice in the James Fisher-Harris mould. Terrell May leads with his effort but we need someone who can stare down an opponent, puts fear in the opposition & can produce big PCMs at will.

At the moment Pole should be our 1st bench rotation until he further develops his game & experience.

Who could this be that could fall out of the tree?

TPJ? For those watching, is he doing well in Super League?

 

[Needaname]

It seems to me that team bonding, culture building and effort get you 9 rounds into the comp. Talent gets you further

It’s a good point, worth exploring further.

 

[Flippedy]

I know Young is very obviously not wanted at the Roosters, but man those are some savage comments to read if you were him.

"That's really annoying" you're still here Dom.

Roosters can get away with anything. Politis and Gus can get away with anything.

Yes and somehow not get lambasted in the media!

 

[88]

Couldn’t agree more,
Anyone thinking we were going to beat the Storm in Melbourne after they got beat the week before must have been dreaming.
Forget this game and go on our previous results we have improved immensely since last year.
How we perform this week against the Rabbitohs will tell us a lot about where we are heading for the rest of the year.

Agree. Will judge them more on if we have taken any real steps forward by how we respond against Souths.

 

[hank37w]

The hate for Seyfarth seems out of line with the performance yesterday.

He was hardly the worst in a bad performance. I'd argue May played worse yesterday.

Galvin is being exposed badly in defence last few weeks.

. . . . . .and people on here wanted to play him in the second row or in the middle at lock.

Our opponents would be licking their lips at that prospect.

 

[Johnnycash]

Time for tigers to stop frothing over 05 and actually move on they seem to always go back to 05. All these ex players from the 05 team in the coaching staff
then you got the banana Richo holding off on Taylan may signing like he’s creating some mad suspense. Just announce it already ya fruit loop or keep fielding a bunch of school boys

 

[Oldman]

The Storm were 5-3 and we were 5-4 … perhaps I didn’t see a win coming our way , against a good team that is hard to beat at home, but did you see that beat down ? Anyway, the fans can think what they want…it’s a problem when the players don’t seem to think they can win …

Every team have bad days

Every team have bad days
I know ours yesterday was horrible but I would like to leave it to next week before writing them off completely.
I have mentioned before last weekend we are 2 years and further recruiting away from being near a top 4 team.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Time for tigers to stop frothing over 05 and actually move on they seem to always go back to 05. All these ex players from the 05 team in the coaching staff
then you got the banana Richo holding off on Taylan may signing like he’s creating some mad suspense. Just announce it already ya fruit loop or keep fielding a bunch of school boys

We gotta walk the line. Just its so fine. JC.

 

[Tom Shines]

Every team have bad days
I know ours yesterday was horrible but I would like to leave it to next week before writing them off completely.
I have mentioned before last weekend we are 2 years and further recruiting away from being near a top 4 team.

I got no idea who is in going to be in the Top 4 this year…the Warriors are there now and the Tigers should have beat them…

Next week will be Interesting ….Latrell can win the game on his own if he wants to ..thankfully he doesn’t often put two good games together in a row …Massive game for the Tigers to steady a very shaky ship …

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

At this point in our lives. Every game is massive for West's Tigers. Spare a penny for your thought.

 

[TigerTone]

Suggestion, get the 3 worst players every week and get them to be on the phone lines for an hour or so just copping sprays fro

I would be hugely surprised , if they even know how to use a landline.
Confussion would set in and they'd all go into their shell.
I wouldnt do that to them , we shouldnt mess with their confidence
anymore than what melbourne has done after that game.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

I'd be surprised too. Landlines are dead.

 

[The Chad]

The Storm were 5-3 and we were 5-4 … perhaps I didn’t see a win coming our way , against a good team that is hard to beat at home, but did you see that beat down ? Anyway, the fans can think what they want…it’s a problem when the players don’t seem to think they can win …


Hate is a strong word … I know you read the board everyday, so I’m assuming you honestly don’t think the criticism of him started yesterday .

No, you're right, the critics have been consistent on him. Just saying that singling him out for yesterday seems rough, given the performance of several of his team mates. He wasn't the worst offender.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Or defender.

 

[The Chad]

. . . . . .and people on here wanted to play him in the second row or in the middle at lock.

Our opponents would be licking their lips at that prospect.

I think people suggesting he play second row are thinking more long term than say, this weekend coming.

 

[The Chad]

Personally I would prefer taking a player off the Knights hands so they can sign Young. We are desperately short for forwards. Give me KPP, Frizell or your mate Hetherington for the remainder of the year.

If they are available- sure!