Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[Rugba]

Remind me of that one ..someone blabbed didn’t they?

The person doing the deal announced it publicaly?

best though was Maloney on radio spilling about TPAs with the Moylan swap

 

[Muffstar]

How does Laundy supply third party deals. There is no way they can argue he is at arms length from the dogs being there major sponsor. Unless you're suggesting they are under the table payments.

I thought I read a while ago that Laundy offered shares in his Hotel business as 3rd party deals.

Don't quote me on that as it was a while ago.

 

[Tom Shines]

I understand your point but the question is whether or not he was "requied to" at that time and on that date.

Im suggesting hes not under any legal obligation to make that statement at that time and on that date when he said he was required to.

So he may not be being truthful.

Even if he provides infornation, police will suss it out. They wont release someone because someone says something.

People lie in statements all the time unfortunately. Police are alive to peoples mischiefs.

But they will follow their processss.

why are you fixated on him being “required “… and that he was under a “legal obligation” to? Perhaps he was asked to by a family member to assist them and they asked him to do so immediately ? Would you do the same if asked even if it meant being 40 minutes late for work ? Even if it’s possible that the statement you provide doesn’t actually make a immeadiate difference?

 

[TSP]

why are you fixated on him being “required “… and that he was under a “legal obligation” to? Perhaps he was asked to by a family member to assist them and they asked him to do so immediately ? Would you do the same if asked even if it meant being 40 minutes late for work ? Even if it’s possible that the statement you provide doesn’t actually make a difference?

He told the club he was "required to" give the statement when he did.

Those are his words.

Im saying its unlikely he was "required to"

Required has a sense of compulsion about it.

He simply wasnt under any obligation.

He wasnt being straightforward with the club.

If a family member asks you, thats a request and not a requirement.

They have different meanings.

 

[Canadian Club]

Junior Tupou given permission to leave the Dolphins.

 

[Tom Shines]

He told the club he was "required to" give the statement when he did.

Those are his words.

Im saying its unlikely he was "required to"

Required has a sense of compulsion about it.

He simply wasnt under any obligation.

He wasnt being straightforward with the club.

If a family member asks you, thats a request and not a requirement.

Perhaps a slip of the tongue …to the journo …we don’t know what he said to the club ..

Under the rest of my scenario that you haven’t commented on … I’ll say that if it was me,,, I would do the same

 

[Fainu Brothers]

Junior Tupou given permission to leave the Dolphins.

Scissor hands

 

[TSP]

Perhaps a slip of the tongue …to the journo …we don’t know what he said to the club ..

Under the rest of the the scenario that you haven’t commented on … I’ll say thst if it was me,,, I would do the same

Youre asking a completely different question and now speculating the story is wrong.

I think youre changing it too much.

Maybe reframe your question without reference to the impugned player.

 

[Vicious]

Hey Vicious
So Newcastle will have 3 players on a million plus ?
Ponga
Brown
Sharp

Plus
Best (big dollars)

Have they the same accountant as the Broncos 😂

Sharpe would be on a minimal contract at the moment, but I think he would command a million dollars per season as a fullback on the open market.
Dom Young heading back on 500k.
Dylan Lucas probably contracted to under 500k, I would say he could get 600-700k on the open market without a problem.
Very hard to see how a Fletcher Sharpe at 5/8 and Dylan Briwn at halfback combination would work as both have individual brilliance, but neither steer the ship.

 

[Wiz]

Have the NRL ever discovered a breach of the salary cap that wasn’t the result of a whistle blower spilling the goods ?

Great question. No they haven’t. They have no interest in creating a scandal for the game via uncovering a salary cap breach.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Sharpe would be on a minimal contract at the moment, but I think he would command a million dollars per season as a fullback on the open market.
Dom Young heading back on 500k.
Dylan Lucas probably contracted to under 500k, I would say he could get 600-700k on the open market without a problem.
Very hard to see how a Fletcher Sharpe at 5/8 and Dylan Briwn at halfback combination would work as both have individual brilliance, but neither steer the ship.

A lot of their problems would be solved if they told Ponga he’s free to go. Then you can play Sharpe at 1, and bring a Toby Sexton type in to play 7. They’d be a much better side.

 

[Tom Shines]

Youre asking a completely different question and now speculating the story is wrong.

I think youre changing it too much.

Maybe reframe your question without reference to the impugned player.

The news story I posted does not provide all the facts to this matter …so the scenario that I’ve provided could be valid …its why I said this about three pages ago ..

We don’t know what the police said. Or the other circumstances , so pointless to speculate

 

[TSP]

The news story I posted does not provide all the facts to this matter …so the scenario that I’ve provided could be valid …its why I said this about three pages ago ..

Reframe the question and ill happily answer it.

 

[Tom Shines]

Reframe the question and ill happily answer it.

I don’t think the scenario I have proposed needs any further “reframing”

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Junior Tupou given permission to talk to rival clubs… would you guys take him back for depth? I personally would tbh.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Junior Tupou given permission to talk to rival clubs… would you guys take him back for depth? I personally would tbh.

Yes.

 

[Tom Shines]

Junior Tupou given permission to talk to rival clubs… would you guys take him back for depth? I personally would tbh.

He is better than Naden…he is still terrible though…so I’ll say no

 

[TSP]

I don’t think the scenario I have proposed needs any further “reframing”

Well we disagree.

 

[Tom Shines]

Yes.

Do some of you guys actually remember some of these players when they were here ? We had AJ a couple of weeks ago that people wanted back .,,at least this bloke is better than him…. But surely we can find someone better ?

 

[tigahhh]

junior tupou granted permission to leave